News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by gaius on Saturday April 18, 2015 @01:42PM (#9400294)
For someone who shoots on B&W film, the lack of color can be a feature.

Yes, you will definitely notice this if you shoot alot - composition in B&W images is more about geometry and symmetry and texture, and you look at colours differently two, you are always thinking, that's a vivid contrast in colour but they will be the same tone of grey. Shooting colour with the intent to convert later, is as you say a different mindset.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by steve19 on Saturday April 18, 2015 @07:03PM (#9401423)
how is it a different mindset? you don't see B&W through your viewfinder? you see the exact same thing the color-covert-later shooter is seeing.

also, modern digital cameras with EVF allow you to see B&W through the viewfinder.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday April 18, 2015 @09:31PM (#9401720)
But not film B&W, which has a different colour and contrast response to "let's remove all the saturation" viewfinder B&W.

Personally I'm happy with a 100% digital workflow. In fact these days I take most photos on an iPhone, and leave the SLR at home.

But I also know that film and optical filtering look different..

You can produce an imitation of a film look with digital processing. But it's an imitation. There are subtleties of colour, grain, contrast/brightness response, and differential colour resolution that are very complicated.

And different films respond in different ways. Everyone can see the difference between digital, budget Kodak, and a roll of Fujifilm Velvia.

And if you're shooting medium or large-format, that's a different ballgame again.

Don't believe me? Take some pictures of a fire. The film and digital versions will look completely different.

Is it worth the effort? For snappy snaps, certainly not. Digital kills it for convenience.

But if I worked as high-end commercial landscape, architectural, or art photographer, I'd certainly consider film for at least some projects.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by 75dvtwin on Saturday April 18, 2015 @05:20PM (#9401101)
I agree with that. I find that looking at good B&W photos is similar to listening to acoustic instrumental music. Where the characteristics of the music are passed through an instrument without coloration by voice or by other instruments