News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by mbrock on Saturday April 18, 2015 @01:17PM (#9400171)
Do you think this argument is going to convince someone who enjoys shooting with film? I'm sure it won't, and that's interesting. The question comes up all over in art making, and it's never resolved through these kinds of arguments.

I don't think most people who enjoy shooting on film put it forward as better than digital. That's why you don't hear "a single argument in favour." It's not a question of better or worse.

As for your argument, "digital cameras can do everything film cameras do" is first of all wrong, and second of all irrelevant even if true.

Why wrong? Well, consider chemical crossprocessing, or the effects of expired film, or just the different tones of different types of stock. You might either be uninterested in such things, or think that these effects can be easily reproduced with postprocessing, but even in the latter case it's different, different skills are required, different tools, different mindsets.

Why irrelevant? Because at least some of the perceived value of film comes from the limitations themselves. That's something you can never get at through making the digital tools more advanced—in fact, it just gets worse. For someone who shoots on B&W film, the lack of color can be a feature. Even the small capacity of a film roll can be a boon; for example, it might give me a mindset of scarcity and significance.

There's a restaurant in Stockholm that only uses wood fire. I won't knock it until I've tasted it. And the presence of fire is something in itself, aside from culinary blind tests.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by unfamiliar on Saturday April 18, 2015 @03:17PM (#9400673)
>Do you think this argument is going to convince someone who enjoys shooting with film?

No, I don't think it will convince them to shoot digital, which is a lost cause. I was more specifically arguing about the claim that it is a different art form, which I think is nonsense and pretentious

>Because at least some of the perceived value of film comes from the limitations themselves.

I agree with this and everything else you wrote. But my response to this is to see the advantage in scarcity of shots, and the limiting nature of black and white, and apply those restrictions shooting in digital.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by mbrock on Saturday April 18, 2015 @03:30PM (#9400714)
Ah, I see. Yeah, I'm not sure what "different art form" is supposed to mean, and I don't really see it that way...

But my response to this is to see the advantage in scarcity of shots, and the limiting nature of black and white, and apply those restrictions shooting in digital.

That has a certain rationality to it, but I don't think it's that simple. You could certainly tell people to just do it, but psychologically, emotionally, cognitively, it's not the same.

I'm not much of a photographer, but I know that with music software that has too many options, I end up confused, stressed, exhausted by possibilities. That's not inherent to the tools, it's just a feature of my limited psyche.

So I appreciate tools that are themselves "restricted." But when I'm actually using such tools—like simple guitar effect pedals, or simple portable recorders—I don't think in terms of restrictions. Because I don't have to think so much about the infinite possibilities of digital stuff at all. I can "get into a zone", kind of like driving a manual car.

When I do photography, I'm attracted to the notion of "contemplative photography," which some people might find weird. But it means among other things that the intimate physical aspects of the equipment are as important as anything. Dealing with a colorful menu display with choices of widescreen, pixel resolutions, presets, etc has a subtle cognitive presence that can be disturbing.

Instruments and tools are "user interfaces" or "user experiences." Sometimes the distinction between analog and digital is fetishized. The distinction between simplicity and complexity seems more important.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by gaius on Saturday April 18, 2015 @04:59PM (#9401011)
I think is nonsense and pretentious

If your experience of film photography is sending a roll off and getting an envelope of prints back, then maybe, but if you are developing yourself, the development process involves all sorts of trade-offs of time, temperature, and chemistry, then wet-printing is more of the same, along with literal dodging and burning (do you ever wonder why the Photoshop tools are called that?). It really has very, very little in common with a digital workflow. So your point is one from ignorance.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday April 18, 2015 @06:16PM (#9401294)
>It's not a different art form, it is just an evolution of it. (user Unfamiliar, above) //

I think he's kinda right there when he goes on to note that the resulting final image from a digital process can be visually adapted to emulate what can be achieved with film.

But I also think you're right to note that the craft of chemical development is markedly different to digital photo processing (photoshopping or what-have-you) [with or without printing].

It makes me consider typewriters vs. wordprocessors; or a potters hands vs. a jigger [or jolley].

To my mind the road travelled to reach a final artistic presentation can be important even if the evidence of it is not present in the form or image itself.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by anigbrowl on Saturday April 18, 2015 @07:28PM (#9401484)
>Do you think this argument is going to convince someone who enjoys shooting with film?

No, I don't think it will convince them to shoot digital,

Your whole argument is based on a false premise - that people who enjoy shooting film don't like digital. There are lots of us who like doing both. I like shooting 4k digital in film production because it has huge economic advantages. I like shooting still digitally because I can take 200 pictures in an afternoon without switching cards, and go back and check focus and exposure on the stop to know if I've got the shot I wanted or not.

Shooting film isn't about having a limited number of shots or shooting in black and white (although I do prefer black and white, but have no problem doing that from digital sources, plus there are even B&W-only digital cameras that trade away color options for might higher resolution). Instead it forces you to select your shots based on how things look and the much more limited shooting options available, as well as exploring the decidedly nonlinear nature of the film substrate itself. I'm interested in the artifacts that many try to engineer away in pursuit of accuracy, and would much rather use tools where those artifacts are more likely to emerge naturally than start with a perfect image and try to paint them on afterwards.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by unfamiliar on Monday April 20, 2015 @04:51AM (#9406838)
>I'm interested in the artifacts that many try to engineer away

See, I just don't find that stuff interesting. Lens flare from non-coated lenses, light leaking into badly constructed film cameras, old film which has gone bad, weird colour shifts due to the imperfection of the chemicals used - none of these things contain any profundity for me. My interest is in the subject and the context of the photograph. These "artefacts" that you talk about are no more interesting than tool marks on a sculpture or brush strokes on a painting. It doesn't add any depth to a piece of art just because flaws in the tool are reflected in the final product. Otherwise you could make your sculpture 10 times more meaningful by refusing to use anything but a butterknife to make it.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by gaius on Saturday April 18, 2015 @01:42PM (#9400294)
For someone who shoots on B&W film, the lack of color can be a feature.

Yes, you will definitely notice this if you shoot alot - composition in B&W images is more about geometry and symmetry and texture, and you look at colours differently two, you are always thinking, that's a vivid contrast in colour but they will be the same tone of grey. Shooting colour with the intent to convert later, is as you say a different mindset.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by steve19 on Saturday April 18, 2015 @07:03PM (#9401423)
how is it a different mindset? you don't see B&W through your viewfinder? you see the exact same thing the color-covert-later shooter is seeing.

also, modern digital cameras with EVF allow you to see B&W through the viewfinder.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday April 18, 2015 @09:31PM (#9401720)
But not film B&W, which has a different colour and contrast response to "let's remove all the saturation" viewfinder B&W.

Personally I'm happy with a 100% digital workflow. In fact these days I take most photos on an iPhone, and leave the SLR at home.

But I also know that film and optical filtering look different..

You can produce an imitation of a film look with digital processing. But it's an imitation. There are subtleties of colour, grain, contrast/brightness response, and differential colour resolution that are very complicated.

And different films respond in different ways. Everyone can see the difference between digital, budget Kodak, and a roll of Fujifilm Velvia.

And if you're shooting medium or large-format, that's a different ballgame again.

Don't believe me? Take some pictures of a fire. The film and digital versions will look completely different.

Is it worth the effort? For snappy snaps, certainly not. Digital kills it for convenience.

But if I worked as high-end commercial landscape, architectural, or art photographer, I'd certainly consider film for at least some projects.

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by 75dvtwin on Saturday April 18, 2015 @05:20PM (#9401101)
I agree with that. I find that looking at good B&W photos is similar to listening to acoustic instrumental music. Where the characteristics of the music are passed through an instrument without coloration by voice or by other instruments
Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by mc32 on Saturday April 18, 2015 @07:15PM (#9401459)
One of my favorite Fil groups on flickr is https://www.flickr.com/groups/onfilm/pool/ (Film isn't dead, it just smells funny). Some are very serious about their preference, some just like experimenting. Reading their discussions can be at times, enlightening.

Just to reinforce on the point of people wanting to continue with what they know and love, we still have people who mostly work on large format film or medium format film. Granted, the perception granted by the lenses for these formats, give you a completely different feeling from that of 35mm and smaller.

One thing film was better at than digital, at least a couple of years ago was dynamic range. You can have the bright sun in your filed of view and the surrounding area are not "blown out" (all highlights)

Re:The photographers who refuse to abandon traditional film ... by gscott on Saturday April 18, 2015 @06:17PM (#9401295)
The nice thing about B&W it is easy to develop at home so worst case after developing it is scanning it to get it into the computer.