There are two basic approaches to running a functioning society. You can establish a fair bit of regulation on how each thing is supposed to work and enforce it vigorously, or you can establish some relatively basic principles and then give people a right of private action through the courts.
Every country does some of each, of course. But America leans more heavily on the latter. And I think it's generally good, because it allows for more innovation. The government doesn't have to try to regulate each new thing. Companies know that if they fuck up and harm people, they'll end up on the wrong end of a lawsuit.
One problem with this approach is that it doesn't work well for small harms. If I find a way to fuck over every American to the tune of $10 each, I make $3b. That pile of cash lets me easily fend off the few Don Quixotes who sue me over $10. A class action suit, though, lets one lawyer sue on behalf of every American, and the opportunity of winning back $3b makes the gamble worth it.
As an entrepreneur, I much prefer the American approach. As long as I'm responsible, lawsuits aren't a huge risk, and I don't have to get advance approval from the Department of Commerce, Internet Apps Division, before I ship each new version.
Does the distinction serve a useful purpose? It seems like they are both "people you hire to do work".
Yes, the US Department of Labor has to decide there's no such distinction and must decide to reorganize various structures.
> Does the distinction serve a useful purpose?
Arguably, yes. The issue is that technology has brought on changes that don't fit neatly into the two boxes.
An employer provides everything for an employee who performs a very broad function. Think front-desk receptionist where a computer is provided. Health-care is sometimes provided, but they may be paid as little as minimum wage (sometimes less).
A contractor, on the other hand, is expected to provide everything themselves. Think plumber or locksmith. They bring their own tools, perform a specific task and they're done and free to move onto the next contract. They provide their own health-care, which, since they're traditionally paid far about minimum wage, is perhaps fair.
(There's a lot more to it and it quickly becomes quite involved with tax code, but suffice to say the plumber is recognized as owning their own business and performing their own trade.)
Does the distinction still serve a useful purpose in this day and age?
As long as we rely on employers to provide necessary benefits that (eg preschool), and not the government, it serves a useful purpose.
A contractor could be viewed as a business relationship -- here is the contract, do what it says or don't get paid/the money back from you. Certainly there is value for having work done on a contract. The contractor should be able to do it themselves or subcontract it out.
An employee could be seen as a single individual who shows up on time and is paid for doing so. It is the employer's job to make sure the individual is doing something productive whatever those tasks may be.
That is a very simple separation and not really correct, but certainly there are good reasons for there to be legal separations. Also consider there are so many legal expectations for the two depending on where one is located. A big challenge for startups riding the line.
Personally I am more concerned about basic labor rights & employer abuse rather than guarantees of benefits and minimum wages. One only has to look at migrant labor abroad to get a good idea of just how bad it gets -- slavery alive and well.
Sure, convince the Congress and state legislatures to do so (employment and tax law that makes such distinctions--and not, IIRC, on exactly the same criteria--exists at both levels.)
It's all very legalese.
[1] Although I'm actually not convinced the premise of Uber drivers being employees is correct.
I don't want to spend my morning dumping on the US, but I'm amazed at just how often your poor and very poor are convinced to support causes that only help the very rich.
It is almost impossible to fire employees in many European countries. Solution: only hire people as temp workers.
I think it is odd that you are calling out America for putting employment obligations on business when most decry the lack of protection America gives to employees. Only than a few Asian countries, American employer obligations are among the lightest compared to other first world nations.
http://www.forbes.com/sites/rickungar/2012/12/09/walmart-bai...
This is a well known phenomenon in public choice economics, colloquially referred to as "Bootleggers and Baptists"[0] after an observation during Prohibition.
In brief, the morally righteous and the morally suspect share a common interest in some regulatory goal. The righteous, or "Baptists," want to make the world a better place, e.g. by restricting the sale of alcohol. The morrally suspect, or "Bootleggers," want the same restriction in place because it protects their source of income, i.e. it is more profitable for a bootlegger to sell illegal alcohol than legal and the illegality of their venture discourages competition.
That being said, I am never convinced by a statement akin to the article's "Deep-pocketed companies like Uber, which has raised nearly $5 billion in venture capital since launching, could surely afford the additional expense of putting drivers on its payroll." Being cash-rich, high-revenue, or any other sign of corporate success does not indicate that arbitrary costs can be imposed with trivial impact. It may be true in any specific case, but it is a bold claim requiring more analysis and backing than "they're rich." Affluence does not indicate immunity to costs, nor does it change any reasonable cost-benefit analysis.
Ninja Edit: An effect we see with this phenomenon is that the "Baptists" often move on to their next righteous cause after securing regulation/legislation against the first vicious behavior, content that they have addressed an evil in society. Authorities can point to the Good Thing they did, and bootleggers continue on with their vicious trade.
I would also like to note that I hope we don't get hung up in the language of morality I have used. I chose the morally heavy verbiage primarily because the name of the phenomenon lends itself to such discussion. I am not herein passing any sort of moral judgment on either side of the issue (in my examples or in the case at hand in the article), merely using the language to help identify the goals and motivations of the actors playing either role. The important thing to note is that, regardless of actual moral quality or efficacy, the "Baptist" believes they are doing good for society at large, and the "Bootlegger" has a self-serving interest. These motivations do not imply that the "Baptist" is actually doing good (intention != results), nor do they imply that the "Bootlegger" is actually doing bad ("It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest."[1]).
If Uber's costs will go up if they are no longer able to classify their employees as contractors, they can simply raise their prices. Uber appears to provide both a lower price and higher quality taxi service than traditional cabs, so even if their prices go up they will still be competitive.
If they have to raise prices above traditional cabs (highly unlikely), that suggests their service depended too heavily on a legal loophole that traditional cabs did not have.
I don't think you realize how much it would damage their business model's profitability to have to pay payroll taxes on all their drivers. It's not just about offering a better service to consumers; Uber/Lyft would emphatically not have this many backers if their business model weren't insanely profitable. If profit margins shrink, poof, there goes funding.
Anecdotally, Lyft/Uber are so much better that they could charge me a lot more and still be preferable, though obviously they expect the margins would be smaller. I doubt it would be business-model-killing smaller though.
Also, look at:
> Deep-pocketed companies like Uber, which has raised nearly $5 billion in venture capital since launching, could surely afford the additional expense of putting drivers on its payroll.
The implications of this are decidedly harmful to both consumers and drivers. Once you set this precedent, it will only be the deep-pocketed companies that can afford to put drivers on their payroll. This is especially problematic in the States, where in spite of a substantial amount of their federal budget being for healthcare, lacks a comprehensive public healthcare system, so employee benefits can be quite expensive.
I've recently incorporated in Ontario, and working as/hiring people on contract is very easy. A big part of that is because, apart from issues relating to workplace safety, we're not responsible for paying for healthcare services for people who do work for us. It was also very easy to leave my cushy corporate job for a startup, because I didn't have to worry I'd be made destitute if I had to pay for a few nights in a hospital were I to contract a really bad flu or get hit crossing the street.
More and more I see the US turning into a country where you _must_ work for a large, established corporation. Lawyers like this are just helping those already on top stay there, at the expense of those in the middle or bottom.