News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by scrrr on Friday April 17, 2015 @03:51AM (#9392772)
I forgot who said it, but it went like this: "If people recognise the banality of war, there will be no more wars."

Of course its not that simple, but we, I suppose especially us techie boys (us because I am one), think that an M1 Abrams tank, a F-15 airplane or a Sig Sauer rifle are, well, cool. We also think uniforms look good. And we dream of being heroes, especially when we are young.

It is, of course, nonsense. All these machines, while technologically interesting, are basically just ugly tools to end lives of other humans. I suppose the glamour and pride only work as long as you believe it does. And so forth.

Of course we need some weapons to defend ourselves, (one might argue our nuclear weapons are more than enough already), because who knows may come and attack, sure. But, yea, I think I just want to say, stop glorifying all this stuff.

It gives me hope that one of the most popular computer games ever, Minecraft, is not a war game. :)

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by antocv on Friday April 17, 2015 @04:30AM (#9392930)
> us techie boys (us because I am one), think that an M1 Abrams tank, a F-15 airplane or a Sig Sauer rifle are, well, cool.

Speak for yourself only.

As a child Ive seen artillery in action, MiGs XX dropping bombs close to basement "us techies" were hiding it, those things are not fucking cool.

It would be so fun one day for you to experience an F15 dropping its load on your village or an M1 Abrams tank, firing its guns towards your house, then lets see if you think those are cool.

In general Americans are far far far from any war, and far far back in history to have any meaningful experience of it. Hollywood takes it lightly, it is entertaiment, for Americans, but "not so much" for lets say Europe.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by pauleastlund on Friday April 17, 2015 @04:33AM (#9392938)
I get what you're saying, but your tone here is pretty hostile here and you don't seem to acknowledge that the point you're making is in perfect agreement with the post you're responding to. You quoted him just before he said, "[This] is, of course, nonsense."
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by willholloway on Friday April 17, 2015 @08:03AM (#9393726)
The way Americans treat war and violence as entertainment is disturbing to him, as he has been at the other end of it.

I've read an interview of a war correspondent that after witnessing war can no longer enjoy war entertainment, as it is disgusting to him.

I think hostility towards an attitude that takes inflicting death lightly, for entertainment is justified.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by scott_s on Friday April 17, 2015 @11:15AM (#9394819)
Understood. But that is actually scrrr's point. But scrrr was making it in a way that explains why people who have not experienced war and violence use it as entertainment.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by nothrabannosir on Friday April 17, 2015 @06:48AM (#9393403)
Did he edit his comment after you replied? I totally agree with what he said to GP: "don't include me in your 'we think war machines are cool.'" That's bad form in general, doubly so on this touchy subject.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by presidentender on Friday April 17, 2015 @10:56AM (#9394681)
Is a train cool? A Saturn V rocket? A 3d printer?

I think so.

The same factors that make machines cool remain intact regardless of the application. Furthermore, there's much more kinetic energy involved when you're trying to take something apart quickly than when you're trying to carefully build it, and more still when someone else is trying to keep the thing intact. Is a controlled demolition cool? If not, why do people watch?

Nobody is arguing in favor of violence. The comments here are recognizing some of the reasons why war seems cool, especially to the young and especially to men.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by jacquesm on Friday April 17, 2015 @05:51AM (#9393212)
Stating something first and then negating it in the same comment is a pretty weird way to make a point.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by treerock on Friday April 17, 2015 @08:03AM (#9393728)
Basically an oxymoron. Shakespeare loved them [1]

[1] http://kerbev.hubpages.com/hub/shakespeare-oxymorons

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by return0 on Friday April 17, 2015 @06:48AM (#9393401)
There is a big qualitative difference between the conflicts in Europe and the wars waged by America. Wars in europe are nationalistic, vicious and leave deep scars even decades later on. It's fair to say we still haven't recovered from the scars of the 2 WWs and are still suspicious of each other. The US army is worldwide police. Their soldiers are basically heavily armed "policemen" who execute missions in exotic countries. That's why hollywood sees war as fun, technical an inhuman.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by orbifold on Friday April 17, 2015 @11:32AM (#9394929)
This heavily armed "policemen" line and that they are the "world police" is just the kind of propaganda the world should believe. There is no evidence that any of their wars, were actually fought with some noble goal in mind. In particular they are not some impartial law abiding, benevolent enforcer of rules, but break international law with reckless abandon. They also facilitate crimes of vicious dictatorships with covert and overt support.

American Sniper is the perfect example for how Hollywood presents wars. While some European and American intellectuals and artists doubted that after the Holocaust and WW II that any of that could be depicted without trivialization. Spielberg and others happily just did that.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by hoggle on Friday April 17, 2015 @10:34AM (#9394511)
I'm a US fan myself - I love the culture - but its people are being misled continously by the powers that be (military industrial complex tag-teaming with a handful of media moguls).

As so often the case it's about money and power (e.g. oil). Where was the police during the Rwanda and Dafur genocides? Even the UN kept relatively silent in contrast to how horrible those were.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by coldtea on Friday April 17, 2015 @07:34AM (#9393587)
>If people recognise the banality of war, there will be no more wars

It's not that wars are seen as heroic, or religious differences and other such BS.

A lot of modern wars can be explained as the results of colonialism (either traditional or in its current covert form). Larger countries have interests in exploiting less powerful countries, to get control of trade areas, cheap oil and labor, etc. Of course they say the bring "democracy" etc, even when they leave chaos and hell on their way out (plus some profitable contracts for them).

Before the 60s the did it directly, literally enslaving 7/10 of the world in their "colonies". After that they do it by proxy (e.g. by drawing borders in such a way that establish countries and "nations" that will fight between them so that they can more easily control the area, install lackeys in power, etc.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by orkoden on Friday April 17, 2015 @02:18PM (#9396142)
Wars were fought before western colonization too. Lots of current conflicts have nothing to do with colonization.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by honzzz on Friday April 17, 2015 @04:28AM (#9392922)
This reminded me of the article "The Jihad Cult: Why Young Germans Are Answering Call to Holy War" [1] - after reading it, I got the impression that at least some young men became jihadists because they are basically narcissistic losers whose attempts to be cool via normal and non-destructive means (like becaming famous rapper or kickboxer) failed so they convinced themselves that joining ISIS is the cool thing - they perceive it like courageously fighting with their 'brothers' to enforce God's will... or something like that, they perceive this concept as cool and some of them desperately want back home when they get to Syria and see the grim reality of real ISIS. The whole article is worth reading.

[1] http://www.spiegel.de/international/world/why-young-germany-...

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by gaius on Friday April 17, 2015 @06:48AM (#9393400)
Post-modern Western journalists and politicians are spectacularly ill-equipped to understand and hence deal with, people who actually believe in something, whatever that thing may be.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by Retric on Friday April 17, 2015 @10:55AM (#9394670)
That's a ridiculous statement.

Any sort of Group of people X is Y statement is very unlikely to be true, but this is more so than most. Western Journalists regularly risk life and limb for what they believe in. In many ways it's like saying the clergy are atheists sure some of them are, but there is strong !atheist selection pressure going on.

EX: Let's cover an Ebola outbreak!

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by gaius on Friday April 17, 2015 @11:08AM (#9394765)
You appear to have skipped a word or two in what I wrote.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by Retric on Friday April 17, 2015 @11:34AM (#9394942)
Like many people, I don't feel the need to defend politicians ;)
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by dmichulke on Friday April 17, 2015 @06:51AM (#9393416)
It may also be just a piece of propaganda, especially since it's written by Spiegel.

Somehow all opponents to the pro-US mainstream opinion end up there being narcissists (IS), evil dictators (Putin, Assad) and weak governments (Iraq, Afghanistan, just recently Greece), usually ridiculing them without asking for their motives.

A few months ago Spiegel even had to defend itself openly because people cancelled their subscriptions due to what was perceived as warmongering (Kriegshetze)

My own opinion is that unless media reports positive and negative aspects from both parties (because there is never only one culprit, neither in politics nor in marriage), they cannot be taken seriously.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by saiya-jin on Friday April 17, 2015 @07:32AM (#9393575)
I predict this might give me a lot of hate, but these people coming back is the worst possible outcome for (not only german) society. I don't believe for a second that at least most of them are not properly unbalanced (or worse) and will do no good to society for rest of their lives. I cannot imagine myself doing something like that, and I was no angel when teen. You can see in all media how war looks like there, so they cannot say they simply didn't know.

They wanted war, let them have it all the way to the bottom with all the (percieved) glory of death. They had chance offered to become members of society they were living in, and they refused. Okay, we should respect that choice, but with all consequences. Younger age is no excuse for such mistakes.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by the-dude on Friday April 17, 2015 @11:16AM (#9394823)
I think it is not fair to claim these young men want war. I think they want to fight for their cause.

Also, it is the United States which created a power-vacuum in the region. Why they did this is still a mystery to me.

I demonstrated in Amsterdam against the invasion of Iraq at the time as it was already clear at the time it was a racket.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by cmdkeen on Friday April 17, 2015 @04:11AM (#9392841)
No we need weapons to defend others. The USA and UK are in part two of the richest nations in the world because they are physically isolated from threats, we grew, and continue to grow, rich of trade with the rest of the world.

The West has the capacity to be heroic and for a brief period at the turn of the millennium was actually doing that. Kosovo and Sierra Leone were examples of successful military intervention followed up by nation building. Before that the first Gulf War was again a successful intervention.

The cause of peace allows Rwanda, Bosnia and a hundred other regional conflicts and genocide to claims the lives of millions and blight regions. We should not let Afghanistan and Iraq - and really the root problem is Iraq detract from the potential to affect positive change in the world.

Finally it's worth saying that military capability gives humanitarian capability. The recent Philippines disaster saw HMS Illustrious deliver all the spare rice in Singapore in a short space of time along with a number of helicopters as well as fit, motivated, organised and well led teams to assist in disaster relief.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by lostlogin on Friday April 17, 2015 @05:38AM (#9393168)
I'm not sure that 1 or 2 successful interventions make a heroic period. And the First Gulf War was a farce. What has occurred in Iraq since is directly related and the stationing of troops in Saudi during the conflict had a profound influence on many, including Bin Laden. Intervention is always complex but this was a disaster.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by cmdkeen on Friday April 17, 2015 @05:56AM (#9393231)
I'd hardly call over a decade of regional stability a farce. It checked any expansionist tendencies of other regional powers. It helped make a very powerful point to Iran who didn't cause any problems with the Straits of Hormuz for a long while after, to Libya who had been invaded Chad only years before etc.

It was the 2003 invasion of Iraq that kicked off the nightmare and heightened regional and global instability. It was that massive miscalculation which hugely multiplied the number of jihadists and gave victories to radical Islamists.

Remember Iran had been chanting death America for years by that point, religious zealots already hated America and the West.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by lostlogin on Friday April 17, 2015 @06:14AM (#9393288)
Regional stability didn't make for a very good time in Iraq if you were a Kurd, had supported the U.S. in any way or if you wanted to eat. Infant mortality went through the roof and the death toll from coalition bombing civilians was also a problem. Regional stability is a phrase that gets used to justify support for vicious dictatorships that suit foreign powers.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by Htsthbjig on Friday April 17, 2015 @05:17AM (#9393101)
"Before that the first Gulf War was again a successful intervention."

Successful? You must be joking or only talk about US and UK side.

First Gulf war was a disaster. The US and UK invaded a country and asked the locals to support them, but then they went away. So Saddam took all the people that supported US and UK and simply killed them.

First GW only served one purpose, to claim hegemony of the US military on the war after the cold war and fall of the wall, that there was only one military ruler in the world.

But it was a disaster form an strategic point of view, killing all your supporters in one country, then killing the other side,thus creating a power vacuum as no educated elite is left, creating a failed state.

Remember that Saddam was a US ally and now we know he asked US what will happen if they invaded Kuwait. The US said it was none of their business. Of course it was.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by cmdkeen on Friday April 17, 2015 @05:47AM (#9393195)
GW1 militarily was a huge success, Kuwait - a "five feet high nation" in the Lloyd George sense, was defended from aggression from its much bigger, nastier neighbour. The principal of territorial integrity was upheld. The strategic aims were upheld.

It was our business, and should be our business. That's the whole point of things like the UN charter - remember there were a series of UN resolutions condemning the invasion of one sovereign nation by another. Without recourse to more powerful countries keeping the peace what defence do smaller nations have? That was the real tragedy of the 2003 invasion of Iraq, the undermining of that moral authority.

You're also trying to have your cake and eat it by saying we shouldn't be involved in other countries affairs and then laying the failure of an internal uprising on the West. It wasn't an invasion where we asked the locals to support us, it was a national revolt (also in the North) as a result of the dictator being seen as weak following his failed invasion of Kuwait.

The USA made a few radio broadcasts, that's not enough to kick off an entire revolution. Iraq was in social turmoil after the Iran-Iraq war and the Gulf War, it was a powder keg waiting to go off.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by lgieron on Friday April 17, 2015 @07:58AM (#9393707)
> The principal of territorial integrity was upheld. The strategic aims were upheld.

Let's be honest, the US cares about those only in there's oil or other goodies involved (see the lack of response to the current situation in Ukraine, where there's little to gain and much to lose for the US).

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by Paradigma11 on Friday April 17, 2015 @11:45AM (#9395047)
What were the goodies in Afghanistan, Somalia or Kosovo?
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by hnal943 on Friday April 17, 2015 @10:15AM (#9394394)
The change in leadership explains the change in response. Obama does not believe the US should have the same role in the world the Bush did.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by XorNot on Friday April 17, 2015 @10:44AM (#9394589)
He's also not stupid enough to put US soldiers within shooting distance of accidentally starting literal World War 3.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by lentil_soup on Friday April 17, 2015 @05:12AM (#9393074)
"The recent Philippines disaster saw HMS Illustrious deliver all the spare rice in Singapore in a short space of time along with a number of helicopters as well as fit, motivated, organised and well led teams to assist in disaster relief."

Then you can have the same efficient result with a non-military organization. What's so special about them having guns?

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by serge2k on Friday April 17, 2015 @08:16AM (#9393789)
The need/want of the US to have their guns all over the planet means they often have people in a position to help.

If they weren't out there defending people/enforcing US interests then they wouldn't be there at all.

Re:Why Young Men Go to War by lentil_soup on Friday April 17, 2015 @08:38AM (#9393876)
Sure, but then it's a bad argument as defense of the military. Their purpose is not to help in disasters, that they happen to be there is secondary.
Re:Why Young Men Go to War by vasac on Friday April 17, 2015 @05:20AM (#9393111)
Well, you didn't seem so upbeat when your ex-allies practiced some 'nation building' on 9/11. Things don't look so heroic when happen in your own backyard, do they?