With VIM or Emacs I have no idea where to start, except for maybe a few weeks in the terminal and manual before I can even start to code. Then it is still an open question about what it will scale to. I am not sure I want my environment to look like [this].(http://blog.jetbrains.com/pycharm/files/2013/06/vim3-1024x74...)
With Spyder, RStudio and Octave GUI I can start programming right away, I can see the benefit of the IDE right away, the only problem is I have 3 different text editors with their own short cuts and features.
> (for basic open/navigate/edit/save/search/replace) functionality in a few hours
Do you know how long it takes in Sublime / Atom / TextMate ? Approximately zero.
I use Spacemacs (Emacs with VIM inside) and even after months of working with it I'm still faster in Atom. That's not because I'm "doing it wrong".
Spacemacs fixes some of that integration. cmd-X C V S all work. but no cmd-F or cmd-R
and cmd-f is not the same as ctrl-f. in the emacs tongue it is referred to as s-f
predating is irrelevant. most of the younguns using text editors were born well after emacs was created.
Emacs is technically capable of being customized to suit established usage patterns. its only cultural stubborness that stops it.
From my angle, I've been learning/using the CUA-type keyboard shortcuts since I was about 8 years old - so that's 20 years now, and 16 or so before I wrote a line of code.
The question is not 'how quickly can I learn open/save/etc in vim/Emacs?', or even 'how quickly can I learn open/save/etc and remember it next time I open vim/Emacs?' but 'how quickly will I be more productive in either of them than something that does use all the shortcuts I've been using for two decades and are basically wired into my unconscious as deep as the need for oxygen, food and sex?'
On that scale, I think a few weeks is the most generous estimate possible. I understand why people love vim and Emacs, but they often underestimate how steep the learning curve is if you're very, very used to doing the same things slightly differently.
I will admit that the vi learning curve can be stupidly steep in places, but right down at the novice end it's not bad at all.