News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by AceJohnny2 on Tuesday April 14, 2015 @10:04PM (#9378506)
Maybe the CUA thing doesn't matter. After all, Vim is much worse in first impression, but it's more popular by an order of magnitude. Maybe Emacs just needs to be installed by default, and for that, needs to slim down. Make more of its embedded elisp optional?
Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by wodenokoto on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @12:57AM (#9378955)
To me it is all about a sane starting point. With Sublime I could jump in and start writing code in a beautiful and immediately helpful environment, even though I had never programmed before. As I got better at programming I wanted more advanced features and most of them I found in the included batteries, and a few I got from plugins (although all the good plugins I want seem to have died).

With VIM or Emacs I have no idea where to start, except for maybe a few weeks in the terminal and manual before I can even start to code. Then it is still an open question about what it will scale to. I am not sure I want my environment to look like [this].(http://blog.jetbrains.com/pycharm/files/2013/06/vim3-1024x74...)

With Spyder, RStudio and Octave GUI I can start programming right away, I can see the benefit of the IDE right away, the only problem is I have 3 different text editors with their own short cuts and features.

Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by tincholio on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @01:52AM (#9379106)
If it takes you a few weeks to get started with the basics (in either Emacs or vim), you're doing it wrong. Following their respective tutorials you can get up and running (for basic open/navigate/edit/save/search/replace) functionality in a few hours. You won't be proficient, but you should be able to get stuff done. The rest comes with usage; you can't learn either editor properly by reading the whole book and then not using them. Proficiency comes from constant use, and you never stop learning. I'm an Emacs user of 13 years, and using Evil for the last 3 or so, so I'm comfortable in vim as well, and I still learn new stuff about them all the time.
Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by crucialfelix on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @03:07AM (#9379326)
The basic functionality is completely useless for doing actual programming work.

> (for basic open/navigate/edit/save/search/replace) functionality in a few hours

Do you know how long it takes in Sublime / Atom / TextMate ? Approximately zero.

I use Spacemacs (Emacs with VIM inside) and even after months of working with it I'm still faster in Atom. That's not because I'm "doing it wrong".

Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by RBerenguel on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @07:09AM (#9380112)
Sorry to chime being negative, but it takes you approximately zero because it uses the same paradigm as software you learnt years ago. It probably didn't take you zero time to learn how to open a file, what a files was, what a search-replace was, how it worked, etc, the first time you were confronted with it
Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by crucialfelix on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @09:10AM (#9380691)
Yes, that's my point. Emacs could, but does not integrate with the OS and established keys that well.

Spacemacs fixes some of that integration. cmd-X C V S all work. but no cmd-F or cmd-R

Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by RBerenguel on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @09:54AM (#9380946)
Well, the keybindings on emacs predate most other keybindings. I don't use it very often, but Cmd-F is forward-word, to move forward a word (heh.) For keyboards without arrow keys it is very handy (my oldest laptop didn't have them.) Cmd-R I have never used its binding (so I could rebind it, but what binding would you like to have in it? "Reload"?
Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by crucialfelix on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @02:33PM (#9383084)
sorry I mean cmd-shift-f which is usually find and replace.

and cmd-f is not the same as ctrl-f. in the emacs tongue it is referred to as s-f

predating is irrelevant. most of the younguns using text editors were born well after emacs was created.

Emacs is technically capable of being customized to suit established usage patterns. its only cultural stubborness that stops it.

Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by tragic on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @11:48AM (#9381746)
Sigh.

From my angle, I've been learning/using the CUA-type keyboard shortcuts since I was about 8 years old - so that's 20 years now, and 16 or so before I wrote a line of code.

The question is not 'how quickly can I learn open/save/etc in vim/Emacs?', or even 'how quickly can I learn open/save/etc and remember it next time I open vim/Emacs?' but 'how quickly will I be more productive in either of them than something that does use all the shortcuts I've been using for two decades and are basically wired into my unconscious as deep as the need for oxygen, food and sex?'

On that scale, I think a few weeks is the most generous estimate possible. I understand why people love vim and Emacs, but they often underestimate how steep the learning curve is if you're very, very used to doing the same things slightly differently.

Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by david-given on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @05:53AM (#9379873)
Hours? It's more like about one minute --- that's how long it takes to do lesson one of vimtutor, which tells you how to save and quit, move the cursor, and insert and delete text. Going all the way to the end of vimtutor would probably take about 15 to 20 minutes, and assuming you remembered it all would make you pretty effective (I've been using vim for years and there's basic stuff in there I've never used; skimming it just now I kept going 'huh, I did not know that').

I will admit that the vi learning curve can be stupidly steep in places, but right down at the novice end it's not bad at all.

Re:Chris Granger on the LightTable architecture by Grue3 on Wednesday April 15, 2015 @10:03AM (#9381008)
What prevents you from programming in Emacs out of the box? It has a superset of Notepad functionality straight away, and more complex functions are easily learned through built-in help.