News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by morgante on Saturday April 11, 2015 @09:48PM (#9361702)
I don't think it's fair to call someone who advocates against abortion and same-sex marriages a libertarian.
Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by natmaster on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:00PM (#9361745)
While Rand Paul is not a libertarian (this is a concept promoted by the media to make him seem radical), your understanding of abortion issues is quite off. The real debate about abortion is over when life that deserves protecting begins. There is nothing else anyone disagrees with. If the fetus was an animal PETA would be the only ones having issue; if the fetus was dead noone would have issue with removing it. Some people believe that because a baby is not yet outside its mother, it has no rights. Other believe that until a baby is named, it has no rights. That is what the issue is about, and thinking otherwise you might as well not engage because you will go in circles all day.

As far as same-sex marriage, Rand Paul thinks it is not the federal government's responsibility to regulate that. Removing regulation over social issues from government IS a very libertarian philosophy.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by morgante on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:06PM (#9361768)
I don't think Rand Paul is a libertarian (I was simply responding to the parent).

As for abortion, even if you consider the fetus a "person," I don't see how a libertarian would make a good case for the government to force the mother to continue to sustain and provide for it.

> Removing regulation over social issues from government IS a very libertarian philosophy.

Delegating to the states is very different from removing the regulation. The libertarian thing to do would be to ban such regulation.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by natmaster on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:22PM (#9361830)
> I don't see how a libertarian would make a good case for the government to force the mother to continue to sustain and provide for it.

So all neglect laws should be removed?

> The libertarian thing to do would be to ban such regulation.

That requires a constitutional amendment. Those are not easy to get passed.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by morgante on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:33PM (#9361871)
> So all neglect laws should be removed?

I am not a libertarian, so I wouldn't. But several libertarians I know have said we so, and also argue that there should be no duty to feed the poor, etc.

> The libertarian thing to do would be to ban such regulation. That requires a constitutional amendment. Those are not easy to get passed.

That depends on what regulation we want passed. The First Amendment already includes some pretty important limits on the power of government (included limits which Paul seems loathe to enforce).

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by natmaster on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:50PM (#9361909)
"several libertarians I know have said we so" This is a first for me to hear, though it's important to note libertarians are individuals too, and have their own ideas! I have not found any libertarians promoting children as full-class citizens; so this is very new to hear this. Suffice it to say, I don't think that viewpoint is common.

"First Amendment ..." to the constitution. Are you just agreeing with me here?

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by tzs on Saturday April 11, 2015 @11:56PM (#9362084)
> So all neglect laws should be removed?

That was the position of Murray Rothbard [1], who was one of the major intellectual founders of modern libertarianism, particularly anarcho-capitalism. He was a founder of the Ludwig von Mises Institute. Most internet libertarians seem to be followers of his school of libertarianism (although they often do not know it...).

His book "The Ethics of Liberty" covers children in chapter 14. You can find the PDF online. There's a big chunk of chapter 14 here [2]. Here's the most relevant part:

    Even from birth, the parental ownership is not
    absolute but of a "trustee" or guardianship kind. In
    short, every baby as soon as it is born and is
    therefore no longer contained within his mother's
    body possesses the right of self-ownership by virtue
    of being a separate entity and a potential adult. It
    must therefore be illegal and a violation of the
    child's rights for a parent to aggress against his
    person by mutilating, torturing, murdering him, etc.
    On the other hand, the very concept of "rights" is a
    "negative" one, demarcating the areas of a person's
    action that no man may properly interfere with. No
    man can therefore have a "right" to compel someone
    to do a positive act, for in that case the
    compulsion violates the right of person or property
    of the individual being coerced. Thus, we may say
    that a man has a right to his property (i.e., a
    right not to have his property invaded), but we
    cannot say that anyone has a "right" to a "living
    wage," for that would mean that someone would be
    coerced into providing him with such a wage, and
    that would violate the property rights of the people
    being coerced. As a corollary this means that, in
    the free society, no man may be saddled with the
    legal obligation to do anything for another, since
    that would invade the former's rights; the only
    legal obligation one man has to another is to
    respect the other man's rights.

    Applying our theory to parents and children, this
    means that a parent does not have the right to
    aggress against his children, but also that the
    parent should not have a legal obligation to feed,
    clothe, or educate his children, since such
    obligations would entail positive acts coerced upon
    the parent and depriving the parent of his rights.
    The parent therefore may not murder or mutilate his
    child, and the law properly outlaws a parent from
    doing so. But the parent should have the legal right
    not to feed the child, i.e., to allow it to die. The
    law, therefore, may not properly compel the parent
    to feed a child or to keep it alive. (Again, whether
    or not a parent has a moral rather than a legally
    enforceable obligation to keep his child alive is a
    completely separate question.) This rule allows us
    to solve such vexing questions as: should a parent
    have the right to allow a deformed baby to die
    (e.g., by not feeding it)? The answer is of course
    yes, following a fortiori from the larger right to
    allow any baby, whether deformed or not, to die.
    (Though, as we shall see below, in a libertarian
    society the existence of a free baby market will
    bring such "neglect" down to a minimum.)
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murray_Rothbard

[2] http://mises.org/library/children-and-rights

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by GabrielF00 on Sunday April 12, 2015 @12:38AM (#9362183)
Is the world envisioned in the second paragraph really one that people want to live in?
Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by morgante on Sunday April 12, 2015 @01:16AM (#9362242)
I actually would much prefer it.

If a parent is so terrible that literally the only force compelling them to feed their children is a legal one, then someone else should be raising that child.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by GabrielF00 on Sunday April 12, 2015 @01:27AM (#9362261)
I don't fully understand this comment.

The current system provides a mechanism for someone else to raise the child (CPS can take the child away).

In Rothbard's world, who intervenes in the case of parental neglect? The text implies that nobody intervenes.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by sukilot on Sunday April 12, 2015 @12:26AM (#9362148)
The fact that mothers give birth to babies,not to fully formed and educated adults, is a major unsolved problem of Libertarian and Objectivist (and part of Conservative) philosophy.
Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by crazy1van on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:36PM (#9361881)
> I don't think it's fair to call someone who advocates against abortion and same-sex marriages a libertarian.

Regarding abortion: Libertarians believe in individual liberties. So if you believe that an unborn child is a person, it is very consistent with libertarian-ism to protect its life. The crux of the debate is when does does a fetus become a person.

Regarding same-sex marriages: Again, relating this question to personal freedom, a typical libertarian position is that in the eyes of the law and gov't, a gay marriage should be the same as a heterosexual marriage. However, an individual should have the freedom to not participate in a gay marriage. In other words, saying one person has the freedom to marry who they wish and another has the freedom to not participate in the wedding is very consistent with libertarian views.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by ScottBurson on Saturday April 11, 2015 @11:40PM (#9362039)
So if you believe that an unborn child is a person, it is very consistent with libertarian-ism to protect its life.

But not everyone believes that a fetus is a person. In fact people have quite divergent views on that question, and I am inclined to doubt the debate will ever be finally settled. It is more a matter of religion than of science.

I don't think it's consistent with libertarianism to enact an answer to that question into law when it is still so much debated.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by morgante on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:41PM (#9361891)
> So if you believe that an unborn child is a person, it is very consistent with libertarian-ism to protect its life.

Is it though? Most libertarians say the government shouldn't force you to feed a starving person, but banning abortion means forcing a mother to feed and care for another person (even if you consider a fetus a person).

> Regarding same-sex marriages:

Can you explain how a governmental (even at the state level) distinction between marriage types is consistent with libertarian philosophy?

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by crazy1van on Saturday April 11, 2015 @11:04PM (#9361945)
> banning abortion means forcing a mother to feed and care for another person (even if you consider a fetus a person).

There's a difference between murdering a person and being forced to feed him. So assuming for this argument that a fetus is a person, an abortion would be akin to murder. Being forced to care for the person would be akin to being forced to raise him. Libertarians who believe fetuses are persons are arguing you can't abort the baby, but you can have the baby adopted.

> Can you explain how a governmental (even at the state level) distinction between marriage types is consistent with libertarian philosophy?

I might not understand the question, but many libertarians want the government out of the business of defining marriage at all except where it relates to interacting with the government. Paul seems to have dithered on this issue quite a bit, but this quote of his to National Review in 2013 seems fairly libertarian: "I'm an old-fashioned traditionalist. I believe in the historic and religious definition of marriage...That being said, I'm not for eliminating contracts between adults. I think there are ways to make the tax code more neutral, so it doesn't mention marriage. Then we don't have to redefine what marriage is; we just don't have marriage in the tax code."

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by morgante on Saturday April 11, 2015 @11:12PM (#9361962)
> Being forced to care for the person would be akin to being forced to raise him.

Until the baby is born, it does depend entirely on the mother's resources. It literally pulls energy out of her blood stream.

Now, I don't think fetuses are people, but if you believe they are then you have to admit that for the duration of the pregnancy the mother is compelled to feed and provide for that "person."

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by crazy1van on Saturday April 11, 2015 @11:42PM (#9362043)
Yeah, it gets tricky to pick the policy that maximizes individual liberty when one person is biologically dependent on another to live. One way to analyze it is to look at which person sacrifices the greater freedom. If the mother terminates the pregnancy, the baby loses its life. If the baby is allowed to live off the mother's resources until birth, the mother sacrifices 9 months of her body's resources. Again, this all assumes the fetus is a person, which I believe is Rand Paul's position.
Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by jebblue on Saturday April 11, 2015 @11:04PM (#9361944)
>> The crux of the debate is when does does a fetus become a person.

The core of the debate should be human life is not terminable based on convenience.

Anyone who argues that it is, personage, would have no way to argue against any war, past, present or future.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by scottjad on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:24PM (#9361839)
So Ron Paul (anti-abortion) is not a libertarian? I think this is news to Ron Paul, all of Ron Paul's congressional staffers and campaign volunteers, r/libertarian, mises.org, reason.com, Cato, Students for Liberty, IHS, FEE, FFF, antiwar.com, every libertarian podcast and radio show, and libertarians everywhere. /s

While pro-choice is the view held by the majority of libertarians, there is a large minority of libertarians that are pro-life and they are accepted as libertarians by almost all libertarians.

If every libertarian who disagreed with the libertarian majority on one or two issues were disqualified from being a libertarian there wouldn't be any libertarians left.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by theonemind on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:50PM (#9361913)
People have an odd view of gay marriage, where people have some sort of right to marry who they choose. Marriage isn't a right, it's a privilege granted by society to try to promote nuclear families. They get tax breaks, etc. at the expense of anyone who doesn't prefer that family structure.

Ideally, these rights could be assigned piecemeal between any two individuals, with non-exclusion (i.e., polyamory is allowed.) Perhaps my spouse isn't the best at difficult decisions, and I'd prefer my stable son to be able to make difficult medical decisions, like whether I should be kept on life support. Perhaps I would like to file taxes jointly with my roommate for two years, if we shared household expenses.

In no way is granting gay marriage some kind of rights equalization, but an expansion of an already unfair system, so I oppose it, just as if white people could own black people, but not vice versa, I would not be in favor of allowing black people to own white people, and would oppose any such measure, while being in favor of real equalization by abolishing the system of anybody owning anybody.

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by dataker on Saturday April 11, 2015 @10:17PM (#9361819)
I think one should probably be pragmatic. I mean, if you're a republican, you practically need to have someone with these ideals. Otherwise, it'd be impossible to have enough votes.
Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by lubos on Saturday April 11, 2015 @09:55PM (#9361731)
Well, there is also something called "Christian libertarianism".

See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_libertarianism

Re:Rand Paul Pledges to Immediately End NSA Mass Surveillanc... by ende on Saturday April 11, 2015 @11:26PM (#9361996)
There's also something called Libertarian Socialism (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libertarian_socialism). As a concept, it defies the strict ordering of the left-right spectrum.

Libertarianism is probably best not defined as a noun but as an adjective.