News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by anonbanker on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:25PM (#9361434)
lots of tumors end up being larger than the host. I don't see how that makes anything I said any less relevant. if RH/Debian/Arch move away from POSIX and GNU, they aren't Unix anymore. with the RPC GPL/LGPL backdoor, they're barely free software.
Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by jdub on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:32PM (#9361454)
Linux systems are barely POSIX, were never UNIX, and systemd doesn't have anything to do with POSIX.

Windows has a crummy POSIX layer, and it's not like it ships sysvinit.

Be serious.

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by anonbanker on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:35PM (#9361470)
it's amazing how you can be misleading, while telling the complete truth. are you a lawyer?

Linux systems are quite POSIX. the whole point of GNU was to be compatible.

They were never unix, because they weren't of BSD or AT&T heritage. true, and completely irrelevant.

systemd absolutely hates POSIX, and is actively steering Linux away from it.

I have no idea why windows even applies here. If you are comparing Windows to systemd, you may be correct, but both are abhorrent to OpenBSD users.

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by cmurf on Saturday April 11, 2015 @11:58PM (#9362092)
OS X is fully POSIX compliant. Its launchd is rather more similar to systemd, having abandoned startup scripts 10 years ago.
Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by anonbanker on Sunday April 12, 2015 @11:43AM (#9363675)
launchd has various levels of support in FreeBSD, and less in Net/OpenBSD. However, I've never heard a single positive thing mentioned about systemd from the BSD community, despite it's apparent similarities to launchd. Apparently, BSD people like Apple more than Red Hat. I don't blame them, personally.
Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by jdub on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:41PM (#9361483)
md absolutely hates POSIX, and is actively steering Linux away from it.

Remember maths class? Show your working. systemd has fuck all to do with POSIX. If anyone still cared about POSIX, I'm sure you could waste money to get a systemd platform fully certified.

(By the way, OpenBSD is about as POSIX compliant as Linux in that neither are particularly concerned about it.)

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by anonbanker on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:46PM (#9361500)
so, you're agreeing with me that Lennart, and therefore systemd, hates POSIX? or are you disagreeing, and saying that, if tested for compliance, systemd would pass?

can you please show me where OpenBSD shows as much hatred of POSIX compliance as LP (or even Linux) does?

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by jdub on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:48PM (#9361504)
I'm saying it's irrelevant.

(Plus, you have yet to point out anything about POSIX that is incompatible with systemd, or vice versa. Go away now, troll.)

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by anonbanker on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:50PM (#9361513)
so, I'm confused; are you calling me a troll because you can't state that systemd would pass POSIX compliance, or because you agree that Lennart doesn't like POSIX at all?

Do you even use OpenBSD?

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by jdub on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:51PM (#9361517)
Like I said: If anyone still cared about POSIX, I'm sure you could waste money to get a systemd platform fully certified.

Again, show your work.

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by anonbanker on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:53PM (#9361525)

  show your work.
You state it again as if it meant something.

But back to my question: you're stating that, if tested, systemd would pass POSIX compliance. that's very interesting, and I'd like to see how you came to that conclusion. care to elaborate?

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by jdub on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:55PM (#9361529)
You initiated the claim about systemd and POSIX, as if it were relevant. Show your work.

(I've just looked at your history of comments. Discussion over.)

Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by anonbanker on Saturday April 11, 2015 @08:57PM (#9361534)
how nice of you to decide when the conversation ends. Before you go, can you at least explain why you think systemd would pass POSIX compliance testing? are you familiar with both the standard and systemd's codebase? or was this conjecture?
Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by dang on Sunday April 12, 2015 @04:31AM (#9362635)
Please, both of you, don't bicker like this on Hacker News.
Re:GNOME 3.16 on OpenBSD [video] by anonbanker on Sunday April 12, 2015 @11:59AM (#9363734)
Noted. forgive me. I was attempting to see how far the systemd apologists would go to defend their project (a call to arms was made on #systemd on IRC to post on this thread). They usually flood the thread with people (one new account was made for this HN thread specifically), and I was curious to see how many people it would take to defend a propaganda blitz. I counted three pro-systemd people in the thread, and you'll note from my past posting history, this is the longest back-and-forth I've participated in. there is a definite pattern of systemd sockpuppetry on HN, and I figured you should at least see how far they'll go.

Thank you for keeping HN civil.