Under the right circumstances, prediction markets can work surprisingly well even when no money is involved and even when not all the participants are expert. Of course, there needs to be some expertise/information in the group. Random picks aren't going to converge on the right answer.
Does each guess submission cost money? If so, then that's a pretty standard market. People who know more about cow weights are more likely to spend money because they have more to gain. Of course, even with free tickets, it could just be that people at rural fairs know a reasonable amount about cow weights.