In the case where the complainant was legitimate, then yes, your content would be offline for 10 days. However, the complainant would also be guilty of perjury, which would carry a sentence of 2-4 years in California. So, if you're affected, then go to court and get them locked up.
What is often overlooked is that without the DMCA the content host would be liable, so there would be no third party hosting on the Internet. Which pretty much means there would be no Internet as we know it today.
Granted, it's not a perfect system, but it's also not the worst thing out there.
I am not your lawyer, but I bet if you asked your lawyer he/she would recommend you always follow the 10 days rule.
...the complainant would also be guilty of perjury..
Not really. It's only perjury if the person writing the letter knew that they were lying. Which 1) is almost impossible to prove and 2) doesn't address the many, many people who send DMCA notices based on a genuine lack of knowledge about copyright.
It is basically toothless. (Out of curiosity, has anyone ever been prosecuted for a bad DMCA claim?)
You can be a moron all you want, and anyone who tries it is welcome to a hefty fine or jail time.
In my opinion, the bogus DMCA notice issue is VERY overblown.
This is a common misconception.
According to the DMCA, the host MUST wait at least 10 business days after receiving a counter-notification before they can put the content back online. This is ostensibly to give the complainant a chance to file a lawsuit.
In other words, I can knock almost anything off the net for two weeks with a single bogus message.
See for yourself in 202(g)(2) http://w2.eff.org/IP/DMCA/hr2281_dmca_law_19981020_pl105-304...
It's true that the linked article didn't go into detail about counter-notification, but it is dead on and I think you're the one who doesn't fully understand the system :)