Re:The DMCA takedown problem
by eli on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @09:02AM
(#935248)
That's fine, but that means you are waiving your rights to the safe harbor provision and opening yourself up to a lawsuit, should the person choose to pursue it.
I am not your lawyer, but I bet if you asked your lawyer he/she would recommend you always follow the 10 days rule.
...the complainant would also be guilty of perjury..
Not really. It's only perjury if the person writing the letter knew that they were lying. Which 1) is almost impossible to prove and 2) doesn't address the many, many people who send DMCA notices based on a genuine lack of knowledge about copyright.
It is basically toothless. (Out of curiosity, has anyone ever been prosecuted for a bad DMCA claim?)
Re:The DMCA takedown problem
by drusenko on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @04:19PM
(#936263)
If the original notice doesn't have real contact information, it is invalid. Once pointed out that the notice is invalid, there is no reason and no liability in not following an invalid notice.
I am not your lawyer, but I bet if you asked your lawyer he/she would recommend you always follow the 10 days rule.
...the complainant would also be guilty of perjury..
Not really. It's only perjury if the person writing the letter knew that they were lying. Which 1) is almost impossible to prove and 2) doesn't address the many, many people who send DMCA notices based on a genuine lack of knowledge about copyright.
It is basically toothless. (Out of curiosity, has anyone ever been prosecuted for a bad DMCA claim?)