4 years in prison in a bankrupt state for sending a letter claiming copyright infringement? Yeah right. The Unabomber sent bombs through the mail for years without being caught. If someone can do that, it should be trivial to send email to hosting companies without going to jail.
Have you ever jaywalked? If so, you'll realize that not every law is enforceable.
This email happens to include your full name, address, and other contact information. And it also certifies under penalty of perjury that you are telling the truth.
If you don't believe that you can go to jail for 2-4 years in CA for committing perjury, google it. I'm not bullshitting you.
Perjury is a serious offense. Clinton was impeached for it.
You don't put your real contact information on fake letters you send.
Then the original DMCA notice (with fake contact information) is invalid and doesn't need to be followed.
The sender knows it's invalid. How does the recipient know?
In this hypothetical scenario, the person affected could take a few minutes to verify the information, and then report back to the host that the contact information is invalid.
Then they can go after the sender, and lock them up for a while.