Re:You (and Joel Spolsky) are tone blind
by rimantas on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @03:46PM
(#933894)
Just a thought: if said work is of substantial length then you have enough context/space to express all the subtleties by other means. In case of the message limited to 140 characters or email one-liner you need some crutches to the same. Are we trading 5 lines of email for one ":)"?
A counter-example in six words:
For Sale: Baby shoes, never worn
is a short story by Ernest Hemingway. http://www.litkicks.com/FlashFiction/
See, no emoticons :)
Re:You (and Joel Spolsky) are tone blind
by billswift on Wednesday November 11, 2009 @09:38AM
(#935297)
That sort of works as fiction, in part because it is so ambiguous - it could be anything from a tragedy to a farce.
Re:You (and Joel Spolsky) are tone blind
by joe_the_user on Tuesday November 10, 2009 @04:54PM
(#934038)
Well, there's the works of Sapho and Haiku as example of evocative short works.
It does take effort to produce such things. And even then they require some cultural context.
Despite the limitations of the written word, human authors have been producing written works with profound emotional impact for thousands of years. And without emoticons!
It's true it requires concentration and imagination to read Shakespeare (with full impact) than it takes see his plays performed.
Still, a vast emotional "punch" can be contained in the written word, just requiring a bit of effort to extract.