Seems a bit excessive.
A better bet would be F-Prot or Nod32 which seem far lighter and a tad more quiet about their business except when a malware is actually found (which is also customizable I believe).
However, I see a hard task ahead of any startup that wants to come up in this field. Writing sig definitions for the 100000+ viruses already difficult is a massive initial undertaking. The older players already have most of it written down but a startup would have to put in a ton of effort just to catch up.
You download an app/email attachment etc, check it and then install/open it.
Vista sort of has this but it doesn't clear the suspicion, so if you download a simple utility (or even a help file) it will warn you every time you open it - unless it comes inside an installer.
http://www.microsoft.com/Security_Essentials/
It runs unobtrusively in the background (only a tray icon), is simple to use, and doesn't install additional cruft (e.g., the AVG IE toolbar).
Now, this may be a bit off-topic, but does anyone know about which software he's talking ? I personally find that most of the virus scanners try desperately to let you know how effective they are, constantly notifying what they have done to help you, to validate their existence.
On the other hand, you have the more minimalistic virus scanners, like ClamAV, but I really can't tell if they're effective or not. I fear they are not.
Anyone has recommendations for a good virus scanner that doesn't suck ? Perhaps pg can make this a request for startups, please ? It's about time this whole industry stopped sucking. :)