inpoiun
You (the author) come along and say, no it isn't illegal - please put it back up. If they put it back up don't they lose the DMCA safe protection? They are publicly siding with your claim that it's legal.
Also there is the practical point that a takedown notice simply means clicking a link on the host's site or emailing an address. Getting it back involves sworn affidavits, visits to lawyers an trying to find a human contact at the hosting company.
No, because by putting your content back up the host is opening themselves to liability if it turns out you are wrong. Nobody is going to do that
>sue the person who filed the complaint
The person who filed the complaint is a mailinator address, or in Russia/Iran/Cuba or works for a corporation with more lawyers than you .
Vista sort of has this but it doesn't clear the suspicion, so if you download a simple utility (or even a help file) it will warn you every time you open it - unless it comes inside an installer.
On the net I pay my ISP for basic service and can get anything from the BBC and Guardian to HN. If Murdoch has his way and abolishes the communist cancer of net neutrality I will pay for basic network that includes Fox.com then the advanced package to get HN, then premium package to get Youtube. I suspect that however much I pay I won't the BBC or Guardian !
You download an app/email attachment etc, check it and then install/open it.
There might also be naughty reasons to do these things