News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by hullo on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:12PM (#9329662)
If you'd done the same thing with a bust of your mother 10 years ago, they'd have covered it up as well. Try the same thing (with Snowden, or your mother) in France or China, and see what happens. Just because they parks department is doing their job doesn't mean democracy is ebbing.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by hristov on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:41PM (#9329875)
I don't think so. If it is something unauthorized they probably would have removed it in due time. I.e., they would have taken a couple of days to hire professionals to do it. Now they immediately cover it up so that no-one can see it while they arrange for its removal. Why? Obviously they do not want anyone to look at it before it is removed. But why not? It is certainly not offensive in any way. It may prove to be a minor attraction and it will get Brooklyn in the national news.

It really does remind one of soviet style suppression.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by slg on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:03PM (#9330009)
I think you are looking at the situation from our little tech bubble. Regardless of all of our opinions on the situation, it is still very political. This guy is actively wanted by our government for possible treason charges. If you believe those charges have merit, then erecting a statue in his honor could easily be classified as offensive.

This is part of the problem with our side of the debate. We take it as a forgone conclusion that everyone agrees that Snowden is morally right and that the government is morally wrong. We need to do a better job of convincing the general public why issues like this are important. Erecting a statue of Snowden doesn't do anything besides antagonizing both sides of the debate.

EDIT: As this post currently stands at -2 karma, I have to say I am a little disappointed in HN. This isn't Reddit, we shouldn't have brigades of people downvoting comments that bring up gray areas in this debate. I don't think I said anything unreasonable in this comment. However if you do and downvote me, the least you could do is comment about how I am off base.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by GeechieCloud on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:42PM (#9330258)
I agree with you. Comparing it to common graffiti is as much an exaggeration as comparing it to graffiti depicting genocide.

Some skaterz 'tag' is going to take weeks or months to be covered/removed. However, if instead they it was a picture likely to draw both political and media attention plus cause some individuals distress at a memorial they are going to move quickly.

The fact is in this case it was inflammatory toward the US government so we are quick to declare democracy and freedom of speech is ending. I don't think the parks department who franticly called a worker to get there and cover it up is part of this broader conspiracy to deprive americans of freedom of expression. They moved quickly on something they knew would get a lot of attention.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by logn on Monday April 06, 2015 @10:47PM (#9331758)
I listen to lots of progressive as well as libertarian radio/media, and they all support Snowden. He's not just a tech bubble sensation.

I might have agreed with you that erecting a statue does nothing. But that it was promptly covered with a tarp is more revealing than I would have expected.

The Weather Underground protested by blowing up a statue. This is pretty classy.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by cryoshon on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:23PM (#9330152)
There isn't really a legitimate debate, there's the PR department of statism and fearfulness and then the reality-seeking people who decry government power-grabbing and anti-liberalism.

Dragnet surveillance is totalitarianism. I guess there are apologists for totalitarianism, but why, if we are a democracy, do we listen to those who actively advocate for tyranny?

EDIT: Haven't heard any objection to my points yet, primarily that it's not possible to argue in good faith that someone can be both be well-informed about the effects of dragnet surveillance and still be pro-surveillance.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by slg on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:30PM (#9330187)
Comments like this reinforce my point. You are basically framing this entire debate as good versus evil. That is not going to change anyone's minds and it serves no real purpose outside of rallying your own side. There is a middle ground between our government can read everything and our government can read nothing. I don't know where that line is, but the only way we find that line is through open debate. Except no side apparently seems willing to engage in that debate.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by Lawtonfogle on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:49PM (#9330307)
Middle ground does not always exist. For example, take the plans to set up decentralized networks outside of the government's control. There have been discussions on how to allow the government to still be able to fight certain forms of illegal data exchange (terrorism and child abuse) while banning it from being at all involved in the others (drugs). But there is no middle ground solution. Any network that comprises itself enough to allow the government in to monitor and combat certain data will weaken its ability to prevent the government from being able to do the same elsewhere.

As it stands, giving the government the power to read any one particular thing will result in it being abused to read other things that were never intended. And with a history filled with governments always overstepping their bounds, the only real solution is to create something that cannot be read, as any limit that depends upon 'please don't' is only a temporary patch.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by slg on Monday April 06, 2015 @04:52PM (#9330629)
>As it stands, giving the government the power to read any one particular thing will result in it being abused to read other things that were never intended.

Isn't this potentially the real problem? It is why our original system required courts and warrants, checks and balances. The Internet doesn't have to be completely different than the offline world. The police can knock down my door if there is a threat of child abuse or terrorism, but aren't allowed to do the same for a traffic violation. Why would that system need to be different online? We just need to make the process of acquiring and executing a warrant more transparent. That political debate would take precedence over any technical problem like designing a distributed system that could accommodate this type of request.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by Lawtonfogle on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @09:12AM (#9333707)
>It is why our original system required courts and warrants, checks and balances.

The problem is that current technology allows the government to hide behind 'you have no proof we did anything wrong' and 'state secret' defenses. Maybe a system that makes it clear when communications are being monitored, but the government is going to oppose that as much as a system that can't be monitored.

Also, there are few other considerations:

No foreign company is going to kick in your door, but they would be willing to hack your computer/listen to your chatter in an attempt to steal company secrets. Any weak point for the government is a weak point for all others.

Also, government is made up of some individuals that I do not want anywhere near any backdoors of my systems. Not to say everyone in government is incompetent.

Maybe they are if you are head of R&D for some massive project, at which point you would be taking extra precautions.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by jshap70 on Monday April 06, 2015 @05:43PM (#9330872)
>Middle ground does not always exist

I think looking at issues with this lens is how the whole idea of "you're either with us or against us" gets started. It's possible to be less opinionated than that.

I think everyone should take a step back and actually analyze the situation for what it is, rather than immediately grabbing the pitch fork.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by maqr on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @04:50AM (#9332668)
> >Middle ground does not always exist

He doesn't mean ideologically, he means technically. You're either encrypted or you're not.

This isn't about being opinionated, it truly is about whether or not we allow the government to monitor all the things.

The only options are all or none, there is no "just monitor some of the things" option.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by Lawtonfogle on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @09:18AM (#9333753)
The concern is that the technical binary nature of the issue does put pressure on the political sides towards being binary.

For example, those who want a system that protects jounalist in oppressive countries but that does not protect child predators have lots of positions to pick, but those positions (and the groups that hold them) can easily be divided along the lines of those who support a system that protects both and those that support a system that protects neither (it technically protects neither while it will often be sold as protecting one but not the other, and as such the majority of the group may fully believe it does protect one but not the other).

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by dreamfactory2 on Monday April 06, 2015 @05:00PM (#9330670)
Not sure it's that simple. It's a given that everyone wants to be reasonable of course, but 1984 was framed precisely as a kind of political horror story. Should we really react in terms of compromise and middle ground if somebody proposes that we live in such a horror story?

My view is that this kind of thing is a part of what intelligence services are supposed to prevent, not implement, and they are therefore seriously failing to do their taxpayer-funded jobs. Not really sure of the point of employing smart people to protect you if they then use all of their wiles to weaken individual and state security.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by Loughla on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:38PM (#9330237)
That's still inside the tech bubble.

Talk to Old Lady A or middle-aged man B in any number of flyover states; the average American.

They have no concept of what type of data is available about them online. They have no worries about being watched by any agency, because they literally do not understand what is being watched.

Many, many people over the age of 40(ish) make assumptions about what is possible and what is not based solely on past experience. When it was nearly impossible to gather data, house data, and retrieve data about a monstrously large group, no one bothered. Therefore, average Americans from that time period have no idea what is possible.

Like the OP said - take the time to educate folks about what is possible and why they should worry, instead of argue for right versus wrong. All that does is make people pick sides, however irrational the side is.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by yongjik on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:22PM (#9330142)
Think of it from the point of the park officer. If they notice it, and not cover it up, then it will be read as an implicit endorsement, and will generate an unending amount of gossip and headache. Why would they want it.

The result would have been exactly the same if somebody put a bust of Hillary Clinton with letters "Clinton, 45th president of USA", even though Clinton would be a pretty safe choice for a lot of people (including those who hate Snowden).

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by aceperry on Monday April 06, 2015 @07:02PM (#9331188)
I doubt the park officers decided by themselves to cover up the bust. I'm sure that they had orders from higher up to do this.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by ics on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:48PM (#9330295)
They have to wait for someone to move it (maybe someone within the Parks department, they have the equipment at least) but it's worth pointing out that a job in NYC Parks as highly bureaucratic it is desirable. Many employees are professionals (seriously, you have no idea if the guy throwing the tarp happens to have a masters in landscape architecture, or the next guy, or...) and park officers must be designated as special patrolmen by the NYPD. The very first rule of being an "Urban Park Ranger" is: "Under supervision, perform patrols of park facilities as part of a highly visible uniformed division. Ensure the safety and enjoyment of park users and the protection of park property." It's great that we can all discuss the merits of this from our own viewpoints– I fully support the artists here– but it is precisely the job of Parks employees to assist in the removal of any form of unauthorized modifications to the park. Simplest reason? Parks has no idea how the statue was made or how it was installed. What happens if it falls on someone? Or someone climbs it and a piece breaks off? We take it in good faith that this thing is just a harmless statement of expression– Parks employees most certainly should not.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by drchaos on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @09:50AM (#9333964)
> What happens if it falls on someone? Or someone climbs it and a piece breaks off?

How exactly does covering it up help with that? I agree that there are valid reasons for wanting to remove it, but covering it up before that is just ridiculous.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by ics on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @11:28AM (#9334722)
I said it elsewhere, but it's just a sign to the removal crew so that they don't have to look [hard] for it. It might be unnecessary, it might just be up the whim of whoever was working that day. We don't know, and so I'm not going to call it a conspiracy. An exception (i.e. protection for the display of public art, even if scheduled for removal) would be pretty great, just not a high priority for our public officials unless we're vocal enough in our support here.

Edit: Oh sorry, you meant how does covering up help with the potential of it falling... Not much, except to possibly prevent people from being interested in it and going near it. Only the people who know what it is already would be interested. But I don't think it's actually going to fall, just that if they're going to remove it there's no surprise that it's covered. It's not uncommon at all to see tarped statues in Parks when any sort of maintenance is being done for a variety of reasons.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by briandear on Monday April 06, 2015 @05:26PM (#9330790)
"Not offensive in any way.." That' certainly subjective. Comparing Snowden as a war hero could be offensive to those that actually fought in wars. If they put it in the Nathan Hale statue at CIA, now that would be ironic.

I'm on a the fence about Snowden, however disrespecting a war memorial to prove a point seems to border on tasteless. How about putting a Snowden statue in front of an AT&T store; that would be better messaging in terms of protest without disrespecting actual war heros.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by kelnos on Monday April 06, 2015 @09:32PM (#9331561)
It's also arguable that what they did was disrespecting a war memorial. Today's wars are fought increasingly without conventional military units or weapons. I personally wouldn't consider Snowden a war hero, but I do consider him a hero, and I wouldn't begrudge people the opinion that he is indeed a war hero.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by rosser on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:51PM (#9329941)
> It really does remind one of soviet style suppression.

If by "one" you mean "you", maybe.

No-one is getting gulag-ed or shot for doing this. To liken this response to Soviet-era human rights abuses betrays a pretty myopic view, IMO.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by cryoshon on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:44PM (#9330267)
Hey man, we have Gitmo and all of our black sites around the world. Human rights abuses happen there with 100% certainty and 0% transparency.

Oh yeah, and we have the world's largest prison population by far.

So maybe not a real Soviet style gulag, just a bunch of smaller gulag-like places to store our undesirables.

Sure, it's not as bad as the USSR, but why is this sort of thing permitted whatsoever in a democracy again?

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by superobserver on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:56PM (#9329968)
Not just Soviet-style suppression, but state sponsored censorship. While the local rules of the park may deem that this is simply vandalism, I fail to recall such instances in the US demanding this kind of censoring and it should be pointed out a little more saliently in the article for appropriate effect.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by sigzero on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:12PM (#9330070)
You are kidding right? This has nothing to do with "Soviet-style suppression, but state sponsored censorship". It is the Park service doing its job. It IS vandalism. Plain and simple.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by superobserver on Monday April 06, 2015 @03:22PM (#9330143)
I was pointing out the limited applicability of "Soviet-style suppression" in the above post - that much is obvious. The rest of my comment stands and your post counts as little more than needless handwaving.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by pharke on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:41PM (#9329878)
Do you have examples of precedent where this occurred in the U.S.? If not, you're simply speculating based on your own opinion/mood/blood sugar level.

Graffiti is rarely covered up so quickly unless it is found to be particularly offensive. My personal belief is that this statue was deemed to be politically offensive and inciting as well as likely to draw media exposure and so was quickly removed from view even though this is not a required step in the process of restoring the monument to its former state.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by ics on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:51PM (#9329938)
Err... we're talking about an installation in one of the most heavily trafficked park systems in the world. I'm surprised it stayed up long enough for some stranger to get a video of it. Sure, there are neglected parks in NYC but the Ft. Greene / Prison Ship Martyrs' Monument is not one of them.

http://www.nycgovparks.org/parks/fort-greene-park/inspection... For fun.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by tjradcliffe on Monday April 06, 2015 @04:44PM (#9330591)
There have been many different opinions expressed here with regard to how quickly a politically innocuous statue would have been taken down, with different people claiming "it just makes sense" that such a statue would/wouldn't be covered and removed as quickly. This is a nice illustration of why the human intestine has such limited epistemic utility: my gut and your gut will rarely agree and there's no way based on gut feel alone to decide which if either is correct in any given situation.

So the right thing to do now is to put up a politically innocuous statue and see how long it lasts, or to find cases that are closer to this situation than graffiti, which is both commonplace and relatively less obtrusive, and less likely to be taken for an "official" statement of anything.

I used to live beside a park where a local artist erected an extremely strange Transformer-like statue in a central location that took several weeks to be removed, but it wasn't in the US and it was in the poorer area of a small town, so there are too many differences to draw any useful conclusions from it.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by davorb on Monday April 06, 2015 @05:36PM (#9330835)
There was a guy that placed a bust of himself in a University library in Sweden. The bust is still there.

https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&pr...

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by anon808 on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:30PM (#9329808)
Or maybe they would've removed it, and until they did left it uncovered. Neither of us know what they would've done.

Not sure what China or France doing things has to do with how we do things in the US.

Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by hullo on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:36PM (#9329848)
Well I can tell you 15 years ago Giuliani would have been up there with a sledgehammer himself taking it down, holding a press conference, and vowing the harshest consequences possible once the perpetrators were tracked down. By that scale can we say that the state of democracy in the US is actually greatly advanced?
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by aceperry on Monday April 06, 2015 @02:47PM (#9329922)
I agree. The response depends on who is in charge. Maybe in a place like Berkeley, birthplace of the free speech movement, they might consider keeping the statue there.
Re:Massive, Illicit Bust of Edward Snowden Stuck to a War Mo... by pandybar on Monday April 06, 2015 @08:45PM (#9331449)
Don't worry too much, U.S. couldn't become China in one day just like you couldn't build Rome in a day.

I notice this little detail in the Tiananmen Square protest in 1989, five years after 1984. After the students build the parts of the statute named Goddess of Democracy, the state security bureau declared that any truck drivers helping them would lose their license.[0] At first this amused me a little bit, seeing how pathetic the security bureau was, but soon I feel so frustrated and disappointed be cause it hasn't been any better about politics after 26 years. Of course they have learned how to frame citizen under the coat of "Rule by law". Government without its chain is just like the Smaug.

[0] http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goddess_of_Democracy