Re:Shen: A Sufficiently Advanced Lisp [video] (2014)
by 616c on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @05:18PM
(#9299963)
So true. I am watching this video and I am very impressed. I am a novice programmer, but from what I read on HN the Shen system hits all cylinders a lot of the more powerful advanced programming paradigms. I am a Shen outsider and there seems to be some much overhead that is not technical when I read about it and it upsets me bc, well, it is a work of art.
I just started studying Java, and found the yet to be certified Java implementation. I am afraid to look at it, lest brains come of my nose.
Re:Shen: A Sufficiently Advanced Lisp [video] (2014)
by tluyben2 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @05:57PM
(#9300178)
One of the great advantages of Shen is that it is built on top of a very simple Lisp called KL of which you can (at least basically working) implement an interpreter or compiler in any language in a day. And when you did that, Shen will run on it. That's why there are so many targets and that's why most targets are not mature. I find it a great advantage though; you can make a compiler or runtime embedded in whatever you are doing really fast and then optimise it as you go.
Edit: I would say, if you want to practice on implementing a compiler & runtime (or VM with JIT or LLVM frontend etc) KL is a good place to start. It's so easy (again, to get something working; to optimise etc is obviously just as painful as with any other language implementation) that it is a lot of fun and you learn a lot if you never did it before.
Re:Shen: A Sufficiently Advanced Lisp [video] (2014)
by 616c on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @06:30PM
(#9300355)
Is there any good introductory info on K lambda? I did some quick Googling and Wikipedia searching, I did not find a singular article about this, not general lamdba calculus or something useful to a complete novice like me.
Re:Shen: A Sufficiently Advanced Lisp [video] (2014)
by doublec on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @07:00PM
(#9300469)
I think this from the Shen site describes it: http://www.shenlanguage.org/learn-shen/shendoc.htm#Kl
Re:Shen: A Sufficiently Advanced Lisp [video] (2014)
by tluyben2 on Wednesday April 01, 2015 @03:10AM
(#9302070)
Yes, you would use that doc to implement it and then the Shen distribution to test if it works as expected. Unlike Shen, K lambda is quite a simple Lisp implementation, if you know a bit of Lisp it should all look pretty straight forward. It doesn't have any advanced stuff built in; that's all done on top.
Re:Shen: A Sufficiently Advanced Lisp [video] (2014)
by e12e on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:06PM
(#9301271)
Thanks for that link. I might not agree with all views presented, but the question about re-licensing as framed there was new to me. I'm very much pro GPL/FSF -- but when leveraging copyright to achive copyleft, it is important to understand the inner workings of copyright, and as this thread highlights the nitty-gritty of "derived work" and the difference between a liberal license to (re)distribute, versus the right to assert copyright, and thereby re-license.
This link may be a start: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/qilang/mVSJIyp-OhM/FjcAOAWUi...
It's unfortunate that the original authors views on licensing takes so much discussion away from Shen itself as it's an interesting language.