News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by freehunter on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:36AM (#9296468)
Is it any different from from the Macbook versus Macbook Pro? Massively different devices. The odd duck out is the Surface RT line, which seems to be abandoned now, removing that confusion.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by mikeash on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:53AM (#9296603)
I don't think the MacBook [Pro] is a flattering comparison. Apple is rapidly falling away from their traditional simple and obvious product lines, and the current MacBook lineup is extremely confusing to a lot of people.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by wlesieutre on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:07PM (#9297384)
Having a new "MacBook" that's thinner than the "MacBook Air" is admittedly a bit weird, but it's a transition period. Once the price on the new one goes down, they'll drop the Air from the lineup, and it'll just be MacBook vs MacBook Pro again.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by hobarrera on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @01:58PM (#9298497)
I completely agree.

The MacBook Pro Retina 13" is almost the same weight and size as a MacBook Air 13". It no longer makes sense to keep the Air around as a "lighter" alternative.

IMHO, both the Air and the non-retina-Pro are going away. Keeping just the MacBook and the retina-Pro is what makes sense the most (the rest are just cheaper alternatives, and Apple doesn't generally do cheap).

Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by nsxwolf on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @03:26PM (#9299202)
The problem is the performance of the new MacBook has taken such a hit. The Airs had started converging on the territory of conventional high performance laptops, but now they're back to ultra low power low performance Intel skus to make the form factor possible again.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by wlesieutre on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @03:48PM (#9299376)
Just like the recently announced Surface 3 (with an even slower Atom x7), it won't matter to most people. A 5 year old Air was fast enough to check email, watch YouTube, and write text documents, and the Core M versions will be the same. The thinner and lighter MBP turns into the computer for people who want a smallish performance laptop.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by rickyc091 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:24AM (#9296906)
Apple actually makes a good way of differentiating the products on their site (http://store.apple.com/us/mac/compare). On top of that their sales people will generally ask you what your purpose for the laptop is as to not oversell you on something you don't need.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by kaolinite on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @02:55PM (#9298994)
My dad went into an Apple Store intending to spend £1000 on a MacBook. He ended up coming home with a £400 iPad which suited his needs better (and which he loves). I couldn't respect the sales staff more for that.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by tim333 on Thursday April 02, 2015 @12:56AM (#9308752)
Yeah - one of the nicest things about the Apple stores. Presumably the staff are not on commissions pushing them to make sales. You can go in and just check your email and no one bothers you. In contrast I used to live opposite a Sony store and tried wandering in to check if they's invented any cool stuff lately and there would be a sales guy in my face with 'which model are you interesting in buying sir?' within about 20 seconds. Shame really. Scared me off and presumably other people who like Sony as the store was empty and closed soon after.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by gress on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @06:19PM (#9300295)
Confusing to people actually buying MacBooks, or just to those writing about them?

Also even if the current lineup is not perfectly orthogonal because the purpose of the Air is less clear than it used to be, this has happened before when new lines are introduced. What leads you to assert that they are 'rapidly falling away' from anything, rather than just in a transition period with the new line?

Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by mikeash on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @07:43PM (#9300632)
The MacBook line has been a mess for years now. There was a bad point when they had retina and non-retina versions for the whole Pro line. The iPad line is becoming pretty nuts. They simultaneously advertise the iPad Air 2, the iPad Air, the iPad Mini 3, the iPad Mini 2, and the original iPad Mini. Even iPhones are starting to suffer from this. It used to be obvious (either pick the best, or decide how much less you want to pay, then buy the one at that price) but now you have to figure out whether you want bigger or smaller, better camera or better pocketability, etc.

I like having more choices, personally, but Apple used to have a much more streamlined product offering.

Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by gress on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @10:43PM (#9301212)
I'll concede that the iPad line is weird, but I just don't agree with the pattern you are trying to make for the rest of them.

I don't agree that 2 sizes of iPhone is any different from 2 sizes of laptop or two sizes of iPad.

Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by Corrado on Wednesday April 01, 2015 @03:09AM (#9302067)
Actually, there are 4 sizes of iPhone currently on the Apple store; 6, 6+, 5s, 5c. That gives you 3 different screen sizes and quite a few color and storage options. I find the current state of the Apple catalog to be depressingly complex and look forward to when there are 4 models to choose from; Business/Consumer, Portable/Desktop. But that's just me.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by mikeash on Wednesday April 01, 2015 @09:50AM (#9303491)
I think the problem is non-orthogonality. So many choices are bundled together, and you have to decide everything at once, instead of taking it one at a time. For a MacBook, back when the line was really simple, you'd pick a size, then pick a speed, pick storage, etc., more or less independently. All you had to control for at each stage was cost. iPhones were even simpler: pick a storage size and you're done.

Now, things are bundled together. If you choose an iPhone screen size first, you're implicitly choosing camera quality, materials, speed, fingerprint recognition, and such things all at once. If you like a plastic case (some people do!) then 4" is your only choice. If you want the best camera, you have to get a 5.5" phone even if that doesn't fit in your pocket. If you're buying a MacBook, you have to optimize ports, weight, speed, fancy new haptic trackpad, and other such things all at once.

Compared to other manufacturers, Apple is still doing pretty well here. But it's still considerably worse than it used to be.

Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by gress on Wednesday April 01, 2015 @11:31AM (#9304371)
This is technically true, but I think you're exaggerating the effects of some of the choices vs others.

For example, the difference in camera quality between the iPhone 6 and 6+ is minimal. Yes, if you are obsessed with 'the best' camera quality but want it in a smaller phone, you are faced with a compromise, but for almost everyone the phone size massively overshadows the trivial difference in camera. So people will pick the size they want and those who pick the bigger device will have the minor bonus of a marginally better camera.

Almost nobody obsesses over the full matrix of possible tradeoff the way you are implying. They just choose from what is available based on what is most important to them. The iPhone lineup is easy to select from based on this approach.

Yes, they could make things more orthogonal by say, not having the plastic phone, but it seems to me that this would have almost no effect of the ease of choosing, while just serving fewer customers.

Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by gurkendoktor on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:45AM (#9297142)
There is nothing that runs on one Mac that doesn't run on all the others. Apple's device classes are getting confusing, but at least everything in a category has access to the full ecosystem (either iOS or OS X).
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by freehunter on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @12:00PM (#9297304)
There's nothing that runs on current-gen Microsoft hardware that doesn't run on all the others either, with the exception of phones (and Apple has that limitation too). There are no current-gen Windows RT devices.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by tracker1 on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @08:44PM (#9300875)
A well-written Windows 8 application should be able to target desktop, phone, tablet and xbox with very little rework, and mostly shared libraries.
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by smackfu on Tuesday March 31, 2015 @11:47AM (#9297161)
Well, you can't run iPad apps on an iPhone. Unless they are universal. But you can run iPhone apps on an iPad.

So not exactly simple.

Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by gurkendoktor on Thursday April 02, 2015 @11:05AM (#9311089)
To continue my other post, you are of course right and I shouldn't have brought up iOS. Running iPhone apps on an iPad is such a kludgy experience that it might as well not work at all. Let's see if Apple manages to make things even worse with the rumoured iPad Pro :|
Re:Announcing the Surface 3 by gurkendoktor on Thursday April 02, 2015 @10:25AM (#9310859)
Agreed, but I was merely replying to a post that argued that the MacBook and MacBook Pro are as different as Surface and Surface RT.