News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by jkot on Sunday March 29, 2015 @01:00PM (#9285543)
There are limits on everything: acceleration, maximal speed and even noise. Formula E will be boring same way as Formula 1. Identical cars circling around the track.
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by jmartinpetersen on Sunday March 29, 2015 @01:13PM (#9285585)
It seems your data on F-1 are slightly out of date. Yes, the rules are the same for everyone, but each team optimizes within them differently. As for identical cars, I guess McLaren only wish they had a car like Mercedes or Ferrari (or any old car that could actually last an entire race).
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by bitL on Sunday March 29, 2015 @03:12PM (#9286049)
There is no longer awe associated with breaking records/introducing diverse tech into motorsports anymore. I guess previous generations had it better as they could watch how somebody breaks 190, 200, 210, ... mph barrier, run engines with 900, 1000, 1100hp for the first time, run two sets of rear or front wheels etc. None of that applies now, motorsports are now regulated and consolidated. New revival attempts introduce super ugly cars (look at IndyCars in the past 10 years, or even current Formula E), all mind-blowing racing that deviates from the norm is now banned (Zanardi's "The Pass" can't happen anymore), engines can't be pushed to higher hp unless we want to allow multiple casualties per race, as Firestone Firehawk 600 shown us in 2001 we already crossed the threshold of what humans can withstand and had to backtrack... F1 is now boring (who cares that some German guy in a red car wins?) and mainly a world unto itself with very little connection to the real world as the rules are a result of decades of political fights (i.e. they aren't representing technological pinnacle of what is possible rather what powerful people allowed each other). There were glimmers of interesting things happening with drifting etc. but they never had mainstream potential. I really don't see much future in this, the existing motorsports can be probably milked for a while with a proper marketing strategy, but the future lies elsewhere.
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by jkot on Sunday March 29, 2015 @03:29PM (#9286128)
> engines can't be pushed to higher hp unless we want to allow multiple casualties per race,

We need robots than.

Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by TheLoneWolfling on Sunday March 29, 2015 @05:41PM (#9286597)
It would be interesting to do remote control. I.e. nobody in the car. Two classes: one with restrictions (i.e. driver must be in control - no assists / etc. May be tricky to define.), one without (want to go fully computer-controlled? Sure!).
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by andrewchambers on Monday March 30, 2015 @12:37AM (#9287677)
Remote control means you can tweak the scale of the cars/races.
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by TheLoneWolfling on Monday March 30, 2015 @10:58AM (#9289926)
Yep.

Although it would be interesting to go "you must have a space where a person can fit, and if you ever kill the dummy inside you lose the race" (defined a little more precisely, of course).

Remember: you probably want to keep the scale vaguely car-size. That way you'll get the most applicable innovation coming out of it. And also that way it'll tend to be the most interesting to spectators.

Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by bitL on Sunday March 29, 2015 @03:44PM (#9286202)
More like sophisticated human augmentations...
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by spott on Sunday March 29, 2015 @01:35PM (#9285672)
I don't know, the sport of it, rather than the engineering of it, is now more important.

Instead of the company with the most money, the driver skill is more important this round.

Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by mehhhhhhh on Sunday March 29, 2015 @01:50PM (#9285728)
Yes. Just watched a race where two different race leaders lost, because they( and not the car ) made a mistake.
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by dublinben on Sunday March 29, 2015 @01:13PM (#9285589)
Formula E is actually worse than Formula 1, since they are built by the same manufacturer. You can't level the same criticism at F1 these days, with a dominant team like Mercedes.
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by TallGuyShort on Sunday March 29, 2015 @03:03PM (#9286006)
Renault's monopoly is temporary - it's to bootstrap the series. I think they should replace F1's every-constructor-makes-their-own-chassis rule with a rule to have everyone build their own powerplants / drives. That's where you want this series to provide innovation.
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by daphreak on Sunday March 29, 2015 @03:07PM (#9286025)
Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by brc on Sunday March 29, 2015 @06:29PM (#9286724)
If you think formula 1 cars are identical, you're not really paying attention.

They look the same in the way a Lenovo and an Apple look the same.

There are rules on track and wheelbase, crash structure and aero wing size that tend to dictate the overall silhouette, but from there, everything else is very different.

Re:Racing goes electric: At the track with Formula E, the fi... by driverdan on Sunday March 29, 2015 @09:50PM (#9287269)
Identical cars make for better, more exciting racing. It comes down to driver skill instead of who can invest the most money. That said, I think restrictions like F1 are better because they lead to interesting innovations.