Re:A fast, offline reverse geocoder in Python
by dexterbt1 on Saturday March 28, 2015 @08:47AM
(#9281335)
Starred. We're currently using nominatim + osm data + postgis on our own hosted servers. Can this be a good alternative?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A fast, offline reverse geocoder in Python
by thampiman on Saturday March 28, 2015 @08:52AM
(#9281344)
I should think so. I've tried nominatim/osm data but it took forever to query a large set of coordinates. I was only interested in knowing the nearest city and admin regions 1/2. And this library is really fast... ~20s to lookup 10M coordinates on my MBP. If you'd however like to know the full address, then this is maybe not a good idea.
Re:A fast, offline reverse geocoder in Python
by dexterbt1 on Saturday March 28, 2015 @09:04AM
(#9281366)
That's fast. Though yes, our use case involves reverse geo of full street level addresses. Currently we do several 10s to 100s of req/s on nominatim.
The sibling thread asked about using OSM data; it'd be awesome if street level OSM data is workable.
Re:A fast, offline reverse geocoder in Python
by ldng on Saturday March 28, 2015 @08:56AM
(#9281349)
For reverse geocoding only as it does not seem to do geocoding proper. Pelias[1] might be a better alternative once they simplified the install process. I had to "reverse engineer" (aka read and understand) their chef cookbook as a Vagrant was not an option form me. Not that complicated but time consuming when don't know Chef.
Re:A fast, offline reverse geocoder in Python
by staz on Saturday March 28, 2015 @10:25AM
(#9281575)
We are currently using Postgis + geonames (the same DB used by this project) and it works very well. I'm curious to see benchmarks comparing the two.
edit: We are only interested in knowing the nearest big city though