Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by nickysielicki on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:04AM
(#9275390)
This is the same guy that caused a fluster when he made a super dangerous modified H5N1, to the point that the government asked him not to publish. Of course, he did do it eventually.
Pretty much the definition of being a badass, he makes extremely dangerous biological weapons and cures deadly disease.
That's my school! Good time to be a badger... Also a bad time I suppose, it's 5:00am and I'm still up? Homework? What?
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by mellavora on Friday March 27, 2015 @04:50AM
(#9275234)
Let's hope that it makes its way through human trials. Even better, let's hope that their development platform generalizes. Lots of known nasties out there which we can dramatically reduce with vaccines.
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by k_sze on Friday March 27, 2015 @06:40AM
(#9275501)
Probably because once the cultured virus is taken away from the host and put into the vaccine, it can no longer reproduce inside the recipient of the vaccine (unless the recipient happens to express the VP30 gene, which had to be engineering into the monkey kidney cells anyway). So virus in the vaccine can cause only minimal damage because it can't reproduce.
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by maxerickson on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:49AM
(#9275898)
When the protein is present, the Ebola is able to reproduce, manufacturing viral particles that look just like any other Ebola.
In a host cell that does not manufacture the protein, the virus is unable to reproduce (apparently the jargon for this is "replication-defective"). So the virus particles manufactured above can be injected with little risk of infection.
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by semi-extrinsic on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:22AM
(#9275807)
If I understand correctly, the hard part safetywise is not making the vaccine, handling it and giving it to the monkeys. It's the fact that you then have to give the monkeys real Ebola to see if the vaccine worked. So the hard part is handling real Ebola and monkeys infected with it.
What these guys have done is broken that real Ebola into two pieces, where one piece is only in the monkeys. So even in the worst case scenario that a monkey infects a human with "real" Ebola when they are testing the vaccine efficiency, the "real" Ebola is now unable to replicate itself in the human body. It's very clever.
Edit: so I think the answer by k_sze is wrong, but I'm not sure. Is there an immunologist in the room?
Previously, we showed that a whole EBOV vaccine based on a replication-defective EBOV (EBOVΔVP30) protects immunized mice and guinea pigs against lethal challenge with rodent-adapted EBOV.
edit: to be clear, k_sze is not wrong, they tested the vaccine against active virus.
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by kokey on Friday March 27, 2015 @08:25AM
(#9275818)
Reading about these tests on monkeys in a biosafety level 4 facility reminds me of The Andromeda Strain. I remember watching the movie for the first time a few years ago and saw how the strain killed a monkey. I was thinking to myself perhaps killing a monkey for a movie was acceptable back in 1971. It turns out they just made it pass out with CO2, under the supervision of the SPCA. It was also one of those strange movies where I could remember the story line but had no visual memory of it, until I remembered I read the book on a commute many years before.
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by sanoli on Friday March 27, 2015 @10:18AM
(#9276379)
The safeguards and the thoroughness of the trials are there for a reason. The necessary evil of it is that it takes time to be thorough, it takes time to be safe.
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by tim333 on Friday March 27, 2015 @02:30PM
(#9278190)
If I was working in an area with Elboa and some risk of getting infected I'd be happy enough to try the vaccine. The risks of this vaccine seem minimal compared to the danger of the disease.
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by Xeoncross on Friday March 27, 2015 @10:48AM
(#9276581)
So wait, the delete one of the eight genes that virus uses to replicate itself, inject that into the monkey, and then give the monkey the vaccine and watch the monkey's body kill the Ebola?
If the Ebola can't reproduce, how do we know that the vaccine had anything to do with the Ebola dying? It's not like it can live forever crippled and unable to reproduce.
Re:Ebola whole virus vaccine shown effective, safe in primates
by maxerickson on Friday March 27, 2015 @11:10AM
(#9276718)
They manufactured the vaccine virus by developing 2 things: a strain of Ebola that lacked the gene to express a certain protein and a cell line that did express that protein. They infect cells from that line with their defective strain of Ebola, and since the cells are providing the protein, it is able to reproduce.
They isolate that vaccine virus from those cells, expose it to hydrogen peroxide, and then expose the monkeys to it. Lacking the protein, the virus is unable to reproduce.
After that exposure, when the monkeys have had time to develop immunity, they are exposed to active Ebola virus. So the earlier exposure to the vaccine virus provides them with immunity against the active virus.
Pretty much the definition of being a badass, he makes extremely dangerous biological weapons and cures deadly disease.
That's my school! Good time to be a badger... Also a bad time I suppose, it's 5:00am and I'm still up? Homework? What?
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pardis_Sabeti
[1] https://www.flickr.com/photos/ahibadi/sets/72157605798942179
[2] http://www.thousanddays.com/
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/27/ebola-wars
Why does this work?
In a host cell that does not manufacture the protein, the virus is unable to reproduce (apparently the jargon for this is "replication-defective"). So the virus particles manufactured above can be injected with little risk of infection.
What these guys have done is broken that real Ebola into two pieces, where one piece is only in the monkeys. So even in the worst case scenario that a monkey infects a human with "real" Ebola when they are testing the vaccine efficiency, the "real" Ebola is now unable to replicate itself in the human body. It's very clever.
Edit: so I think the answer by k_sze is wrong, but I'm not sure. Is there an immunologist in the room?
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/early/2015/03/25/science.a...
Previously, we showed that a whole EBOV vaccine based on a replication-defective EBOV (EBOVΔVP30) protects immunized mice and guinea pigs against lethal challenge with rodent-adapted EBOV.
edit: to be clear, k_sze is not wrong, they tested the vaccine against active virus.
In other words this is good news for the next outbreak
Surely it's good news for the next outbreak, and every subsequent outbreak?
If the Ebola can't reproduce, how do we know that the vaccine had anything to do with the Ebola dying? It's not like it can live forever crippled and unable to reproduce.
They isolate that vaccine virus from those cells, expose it to hydrogen peroxide, and then expose the monkeys to it. Lacking the protein, the virus is unable to reproduce.
After that exposure, when the monkeys have had time to develop immunity, they are exposed to active Ebola virus. So the earlier exposure to the vaccine virus provides them with immunity against the active virus.
(Disclaimer: I am a layman when it comes to biology.)
Why not? Viruses don't have a metabolism or anything, shouldn't they live forever unless destroyed?
http://www.sciencemag.org/content/early/2015/03/25/science.a...