News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by blhack on Tuesday March 24, 2015 @06:18PM (#9259889)
Americans really want to drive diesels. There is a huge demand for diesel volkswagens.

The supply just isn't there; maybe there is a lag between cost-unconscious new-car buyers [ordering new cars], and cost-conscious used-car buyers [buying what the new car buyers leave].

Source: I used to work in the automotive remarketing industry.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by jcastro on Tuesday March 24, 2015 @06:41PM (#9260037)
Loved our Volkswagen Sportwagen TDI.

One of the problems is that VW that they add premium options to the TDI marque. So you can't get a bare bones Jetta TDI without the highest trim level, fancy wheels, and other things that add to the cost. On top of that the gasoline ones are efficient enough where the price difference becomes a non-factor, even when taking the MPG into account.

They are damn fun to drive though, torquey without the compromises of a 4 cylinder gasoline engine. The used market on the sportwagens is great too, which is why we ultimately traded it in for a Tiguan since the demand for the wagens was high enough to make that a relatively easy financial decision.

Unfortunately VW doesn't do diesel Tiguans in the US, which is weird, you'd think the SUV market would be a no-brainer for TDI.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by ajtaylor on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @02:12AM (#9261536)
Couldn't agree more about how much fun the TDI's are to drive! Simply a blast on tight, curvy roads.

Your note about the Tiguan makes me sad. I'm moving back to the US next week and was seriously thinking about getting a Tiguan (and hoping for a diesel). I'll add the Sportwagen TDI to my list.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by durin42 on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:45AM (#9262855)
Rumor is that the MQB platform Tiguan will be available in TDI, but I think that's not expected until MY2017.

Wagen is a great vehicle. I love mine.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by Fomite on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @01:58AM (#9261510)
I seriously considered the Golf TDI, and didn't mind the premium options, but I ended up not liking the high-torque of the turbo diesel on the front (both my wife and I could picture us slamming into the back of someone in DC traffic), and went with the GTI instead.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by bbradley406 on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:31AM (#9262468)
Simple solution: shift earlier, since you can shift up at 2k (before the turbo really takes off) without lugging the engine at all.

Complex solution: Chip the engine - some people prefer a smoother power curve, which can be achieved with a tune.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by Fomite on Thursday March 26, 2015 @06:59AM (#9268758)
I don't feel like driving a manual in a busy city, and much prefer letting the more fuel efficient dual clutch transmission do the work.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by bbradley406 on Thursday March 26, 2015 @08:35AM (#9269051)
Understandable (except for the "more fuel efficient" bit), but with your reply to @huuu in mind, being able to select your gear (and keep it in that gear) would eliminate any unexpected surging. Dense traffic isn't a lot of work in a TDI, because you don't need to shift frequently if at all. In my experience 2nd gear covers between 10-35mph comfortably. I have a 1.25 hour commute that's a mix of stop-and-go in small towns and highway, and the TDI is great for every bit of it.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by Fomite on Thursday March 26, 2015 @03:46PM (#9272545)
Everything I've seen suggests the dual-clutch automatic transmission is more efficient than the manual, including VW's own figures. It came as a surprise to me, but a nice benefit for other factors.

I imagine that yes, being able to keep it in low gears would have helped, and indeed putting it into manual mode for some of the parts I found the worst (rapid turns from one busy street to another) helped, but it put it in the "More trouble than it was worth" category.

That being said, the TDI was a great car, and a serious contender for my money. I just preferred the GTI a bit more, but given I love the GTI, that's good company to be in.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by TylerE on Sunday April 05, 2015 @10:53PM (#9326238)
The published numbers say that. The real world numbers say very much otherwise. The manual CRUSHES the DSG, often by 4-5mpg or even more for some drivers, especially on the highway.

It's geared lower, for one thing, only 2000rpm at 75mph.

FWIW, I traded in a 2012 TDI with the DSG for a manual Mk7 a few days ago. Love the stick, although it's taking some getting used to (this is my first manual).

Also in the manual's favor is the $1,100 cheaper upfront cost and not needing a ~$400 transmission service every 40k.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by Fomite on Tuesday April 07, 2015 @05:56PM (#9337455)
Interesting. I'm rather fond of my DSG, and manual was a little bit of a non-starter because my wife wanted a car she could drive, and learning stick in DC is...a terrible idea.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by ajtaylor on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @02:10AM (#9261531)
I owned a 2009 Golf TDI and loved every minute of it. The car was simply a blast to drive. In the 18 months I drove the Golf I didn't have any issues with high-torque. In fact, the turbo lag guaranteed you wouldn't slam into the car in front of you unless your foot was firmly planted for multiple seconds.

The fantastic fuel economy was the icing on the cake.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by huuu on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @02:12AM (#9261535)
Are you serious? Isn't the GTI still faster?
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by Fomite on Thursday March 26, 2015 @07:01AM (#9268768)
The GTI is faster but has less up-front torque. The issue was not hurtling down the highway at high speed (both can do that perfectly ably), but the feeling we both got that the combination of early torque and turbo lag just begging for the car to surge forward unexpectedly and rear end someone.

The GTI gets rid of one of those problems, and is a spectacular car in its own right.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by ams6110 on Tuesday March 24, 2015 @06:20PM (#9259904)
They can be good cars. For years I drove a 25 year old Mercedes 300D. It was cheap to buy, nice to drive and extremely reliable. Unfortunately rust finally got it.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by Scramblejams on Tuesday March 24, 2015 @06:35PM (#9259998)
Might be a great car to drive but I've lost count of the times I've cursed a 300D in front of me for fouling the air I'm breathing. They're just awful to follow in traffic.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by ams6110 on Tuesday March 24, 2015 @06:51PM (#9260088)
They are certainly not as clean as a modern diesel but if they are properly adjusted they aren't bad. Most of the smokey ones probabley haven't been maintained for years.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by mschuster91 on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @02:05AM (#9261519)
In Germany we have mandatory 2-year checkups by a licensed inspector (TÜV/DEKRA) for normal cars and 1-year checkups for trucks, buses and taxis.

This includes not only a visual inspection of all safety-relevant parts of a car but also a check of the emission values.

How is this handled in the US?

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by theandrewbailey on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @08:32AM (#9262474)
It's on a per state basis, and sometimes per county. There's no inspection in Ohio, but an annual one is required in Pennsylvania. Also in certain counties of Pennsylvania, an emissions test is required for anything that's not a heavy duty truck. I wish they would require them for everything because I have to hold my breath every time a dump truck comes by.

Source: I have an appointment for car inspection this morning.

Edit: certain counties

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by madcaptenor on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:25AM (#9262736)
In some states emission testing is only required in certain areas of the state. For example, in Georgia only cars registered in Atlanta-area counties have to be emission-tested. (Also, cars less than three years old are exempted.)
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by alirazaq on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @04:01AM (#9261722)
About the same in California; mandatory emissions check every 2-years. In the case of a private sale, if the owner has not had it inspected within 90-days of sale the buyer is required to have it inspected upon registration.

There are exceptions with older (vintage) cars, and relatively new cars.

As with most things, these laws vary from state-to-state, and even county-to-county within said states.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by panglott on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:40AM (#9262817)
California is known for having the toughest regulations in this area.

Kentucky had a limited emissions inspection regime from 1999-2005, when it was killed by the Republican governor. The only current inspection requirement I know of is if you purchase an out-of-state used vehicle. We have plenty of ancient cars on the road that have never been inspected.

Sometimes police officers will pull you over if you have obviously-broken headlights or such, and tell you to fix it, but not often.

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by maxerickson on Wednesday March 25, 2015 @09:48AM (#9262873)
Wikipedia has a decent article about where in the US emissions testing is required:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_inspection_in_the_United_States

Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by ptaipale on Tuesday March 24, 2015 @06:40PM (#9260032)
Modern diesels are quite different, though. They've got particle matter filters so not much smoke coming out.
Re:Why do Americans not drive diesels? by Scramblejams on Tuesday March 24, 2015 @06:46PM (#9260060)
May be, but as far as I'm concerned those 300Ds can't rust away fast enough.