News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Makes an Electric Guitar Sound Like an Electric Guitar by TylerE on Monday March 23, 2015 @04:14PM (#9253110)
The acts that's I've seen use it seriously aren't touching a computer. They're using foot switches to drive GuitarRig (or whatever) via MIDI.

The really nice thing about this (besides not having to tote a ton of pedals aroudn) is that you can dial stuff in in advance and forget it. Especially useful for multiple settings on the same pedal - like several different delay settings on different songs - and get the one you want every single time.

Re:What Makes an Electric Guitar Sound Like an Electric Guitar by beat on Monday March 23, 2015 @04:23PM (#9253161)
I've found that "set and forget" approach really problematic myself, and complex midi footswitching not much friendlier than a mouse. Then again, I've never gone on a big tour. What works best for me is convenient knobs right there where I can tweak sound as needed.
Re:What Makes an Electric Guitar Sound Like an Electric Guitar by TylerE on Monday March 23, 2015 @05:21PM (#9253421)
The difference is the big guys likely never touch anything. They just get told by their tech to "hit the blue switch for the solo", or the tech just triggers everything themselves from the wings.
Re:What Makes an Electric Guitar Sound Like an Electric Guitar by ollifi on Monday March 23, 2015 @05:08PM (#9253369)
But those are interface problems. Nothing really to do the internals being software driven. I think many modern synth companies have reverted back to one knob - one function design.
Re:What Makes an Electric Guitar Sound Like an Electric Guitar by Gravityloss on Monday March 23, 2015 @06:13PM (#9253658)
What if the computer crashes?

Do you install updates on the computer? Do you browse the internet with it? Would you expect a ten year old computer to work?

Many everyday interfaces that have previously worked fine for decades, nowadays have computers and sampling inputs. Large multi billion dollar industry giants have managed to create unresponsive elevator interfaces where if you press a button, sometimes something happens, sometimes nothing happens. It's a expletive elevator. How hard can it be?

Perhaps I can trust technology like a Boss multi effects pedal - it's been engineered for a very narrow amount of inputs and doesn't need software updates. It can be made to basically always just work. The company has a long history of actually creating quality products.

But a laptop on stage, or off stage and interfaced with some pedals. That's just a disaster waiting to happen. Maybe if you can pay for one person to just babysit the computer and route around it if / when there are problems, then it's probably great.

Re:What Makes an Electric Guitar Sound Like an Electric Guitar by TylerE on Monday March 23, 2015 @06:38PM (#9253773)
With a modern system like the Fractal Axe-FX there is no "laptop".

This sin't some sort of jerry-rigged VST host - it's a dedicated DSP. There is no OS to crash other than the built-in firmware.

It's really no different than your old Boss, just hundreds of times more DSP muscle.