News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by Mz on Thursday November 05, 2009 @06:57PM (#925101)
"I'm passionate about great user experiences. I think fighting for great user experiences from companies is a good thing. What is passion if you don't fight for what you love"

Stray thought, which likely won't matter to you: Mr. X, who used your site and got fired for it, didn't exactly have a great user experience.

Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by pyre on Thursday November 05, 2009 @07:13PM (#925130)
That's a lot like saying if I purposefully drive off a cliff in my Ford Mustang that Ford gave me a poor user experience because I ended up dead.
Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by jeremymims on Thursday November 05, 2009 @07:26PM (#925148)
Mr. X is going to have a much better job very soon. Don't you worry. This may have ended up being the best decision he ever made.
Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by zackattack on Friday November 06, 2009 @02:12PM (#926669)
You don't know that.
Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by Mz on Thursday November 05, 2009 @07:25PM (#925146)
Ford likely doesn't have the option of removing you from the driver's seat before you go over the cliff. Webmaster's do have the power to remove content that could do harm to the user's actual life. Most of them don't give a flip and wouldn't waste any of their effort to protect someone who posted something they might regret 10 minutes later but be unable to remove once it's posted. Most of them seem to agree with you: It's your problem, bozo.

I have personally left sites where the owner has such an attitude. One of them is now upping the efforts to strong-arm users into joining and participating. They seem to still not get the concept that honey is better than vinegar.

Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by pyre on Thursday November 05, 2009 @07:34PM (#925155)
No offense, but dcurtis (at least claims) to have asked Mr X if it was ok to publish the email. Mr X agreed to allow it as long as his name was removed. How is this now dcurtis's fault when Mr X consciously chose to allow the email to be published?

This is something that seems (at least on face value) to be perfectly reasonable. He published something from an 'anonymous source.' When was the last time you heard of a company searching the text of an email through their email system to find the culprit?

I could see this being a boneheaded way to protect an 'anonymous source' for an Apple rumor (seeing how cut-throat Apple is with plugging leaks), but when it comes to some random large corporation... probably not. It's not even like any of the information that he provided could be construed by an outside person as a 'trade secret' either. On top of that, it's impossible for dcurtis to know what type of contracts Mr X has signed with AA or what their wording is (or even what the current enforcement policies are).

Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by roundsquare on Friday November 06, 2009 @06:24AM (#925827)
When was the last time you heard of a company searching the text of an email through their email system to find the culprit?

Anyone who has worked for a large company has heard of this. It probably doesn't make it into the news a lot, but having worked at <Large Company # 123232> we were told many times that your email is constantly being monitored (though they didn't go into the details of how).

Now, I don't know how AA works, but I'm guessing they made this clear upfront. If not, thats a separate issue.

Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by apgwoz on Thursday November 05, 2009 @07:47PM (#925167)
> No offense, but dcurtis (at least claims) to have asked Mr X if it was ok to publish the email. Mr X agreed to allow it as long as his name was removed. How is this now dcurtis's fault when Mr X consciously chose to allow the email to be published?

And at that, how is it dcurtis' fault that Mr. X (stupidly) used his company email address? That said, is it possible that dcurtis would have believe Mr. X if it wasn't from an aa.com address? I don't know the answer to that.

Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by pyre on Sunday November 08, 2009 @03:14AM (#929058)
> That said, is it possible that dcurtis would have believe Mr. X if it wasn't from an aa.com address? I don't know the answer to that.

How does dcurtis's possible skepticism make him culpable for Mr. X's desire to 'reach out' (to the point that he was willing to use his company email to do so)? Mr. X is still the one making the choice to respond to dcurtis. He's still the one that decides the level of risk to his job that he's willing to take in his dealings with dcurtis. I don't see anything here that could be faulted on dcurtis other than his opinions and writing style.

Re:Creating Controversy for its own Sake (AA.com redesign fi... by Mz on Thursday November 05, 2009 @07:50PM (#925172)
I work for a very large company. I am very careful about what I say online that might in some way be about my job or the company I work for. Maybe lots of people routinely get away with talking trash about the place where they work and it never comes back to them. But if the risk is potentially getting fired (and that seems obvious without having any idea what contracts the guy did or didn't sign), then posting it online seems like an act of callous disregard for someone's welfare. If you are the one that gets fired, it doesn't matter if the statistical odds are very small. The consequence was 100% for you, regardless of how many countless others got away with it. It was a plum for the site to have "insider information". That mattered more to the webmaster than the possibility it would harm Mr. X. So he erred on the side of "good site content" and it's justified because Mr. X. said "sure, post it". I wouldn't be comfortable with that.