If you really just wanted to fight what you thought was a terrible user experience, you would've brought up a list of usability concerns and optionally some remedies. You would not have called them names, you would not have called for mass firings, nor would you have gone into insane hyperbole.
In this new age of online communication we as a society really need to find ways of remaining civil without seeing each others' faces.
Working for one of the largest sites on the internet, I know first hand how difficult to get even a single usability feature pushed through - for good reason. A wholesale redesign would take a supreme amount of coordination, dedication, and effort, from multiple teams of people. It is anything but "cheap and simple", and your continuous insistence of this falsehood shows how little real experience you have in large-scale web dev.
Failing to appreciate the complexities of an enterprise-scale website makes you inexperienced and perhaps ignorant.
Failing to admit that there are complexities to an enterprise-scale website that you aren't aware of is being smug and arrogant.
It is always easy to say that things are easy to fix on an outsider's perspective. In reality, it isn't. I have worked for a big company before and changing things, even the obvious ones, are often difficult.
You may not like the user experience of the site but it is possible that conversion is still high.
There is definitely management problem based on their finances. Redesigning their site may not be in their top priority now.
Let's call a spade a spade here though. In a lot of these large companies the barriers are artificial. Especially when your redesign will 'encroach' on someone's little fiefdom that they've cultivated over the years. I've heard stories of people that were left to their own devices (even in a small company) and when it became a dictate that he/she had to open up to others in the company they quit rather than give up their little 'kingdom.'
These barriers are not there to protect the company in any way, shape, or form. They are there due to petty politicking and stuff that should best be left on the 3rd grade schoolyard. Sure we have to deal with them if we are going to exist in 'corporate culture' but they don't need to be there. This happens in large companies because at some point it becomes harder to control/eliminate, not because it's a necessary part of being a large company.
Like the parent poster, I too have worked in a large company. I was hired mainly to re-develop the intranet (it looked like it was designed in 1995). When I resigned 9 months later I still hadn't done any work on it. Now I had access to the files. I could have just changed it myself but there would have been an uproar and I probably would have been fired. In fact, just making minor changes such as cleaning up the CSS got me in trouble because other people used Dreamweaver to edit some pages and my changes made things look different in Dreamweaver.
I imagine the people responsible for the AA website are in a similar boat. They have access to change things but there are these barriers - artificial or not.
Now I've worked at some different sized companies and I've realised that is the way things were supposed to be at that company. This company handled people's pensions and needed to be conservative. The systems in place were DESIGNED to slow things down to make sure that everything was done right.
Startups have their own speed of work and large companies have a much slower pace. There are reasons for both.
By definition, a large company has LOTS of people, and lots of people involved in a project like changing a website design. They all have their own goals, their own direction and ways to do their job correctly. They won't always line up. The developers want to do whatever makes their work easier, while the ops people want to be sure the servers are stable. The graphics guys want to go with a stunning new design, but the marketing people want to put up a banner with their newest trips to europe.
There are lots of cross-cutting concerns. Everybody can do their job perfectly, and without malice, and still have lots of friction in a change.
It's not all about "big egos want their feifdoms"
Okay. I respect this tremendously, but...
> When I mention this, and when I call out the CEO specifically, people call me arrogant, young, naive, and stupid.
...then you've got to be ready for this. You're going to get it your whole life if you keep acting the way you're acting. It upsets people. They think you're acting out of your place, and you haven't put in your hours and earned your stripes and who the hell does this kid think he is? I went through a similar thing when I was younger and went into business.
Here's one of my favorite quotes, it's by Bertrand Russel:
"Conventional people are roused to fury by departures from convention, largely because they regard such departures as a criticism of themselves."
Okay, so step 1 - you've got to be willing to accept that you're going to provoke reactions like this if you keep acting as you've been acting, questioning authority and the way things are in a very confrontational way. And when people confront you, they won't fight fair and fight your arguments, they'll pull anything out of the hat they can to discredit you or get under your skin. It's going to happen more often rather than less as you go forwards.
So if you can accept it, and keep on going, you can do some things. So I support you as someone who dropped out of high school and went into business quite young, and got called all sorts of nasty things too, and I admire you character. With that said:
> Fixing AA.com would be ridiculously cheap and simple...
This is where you go wrong. No, it probably wouldn't. You can get all the mileage you're currently getting, and a lot more credibility by changing that statement to, "Hell, maybe there'd be a lot of bureaucracy to cut through to fix AA.com and it'd cost some coin, but it's possible and it needs to be done." --> Lots more credibility. Doesn't lose much bite.
When in doubt, fake the modesty. You'll get much more mileage out of life. Later you might learn that some things are more complicated than they initially appear, but you're going to get better mileage anyway if you sympathize with the difficulties people are likely to face trying to make change. And if you're a little extra nice and sympathetic, and it really would be cheap and easy, then your suggestions sound even more palatable.
So - I'm with you, and keep on trucking man. Maybe add a touch of sympathizing with difficulties people face (guess/fake it if you can't see any potential difficulties) and your critique is much more likely to be received well.
It used to be that software was as close as you get to meritocracy. It seems that the web, and especially "web 2.0", changed that. We now have people like Scoble or Arrington who gain their status by pouring their energy not into building great stuff, but into ceaselessly promoting themselves. Many of us see this as crass and pushy.
The criticism here is of Dustin's incredible arrogance in calling everyone at AA completely incompetent (which is patently untrue), and in his eagerness to make it a public controversy in order to shine the spotlight on himself. His web site is a virtual shrine to himself. Everyone knows that creating controversy draws public attention. Just check every 37signals talk or blog post. It works. All you have to do is vehemently argue that the experts are morons and that you know better, and people will pay attention. Some people don't appreciate the deliberate use of controversy to gain attention, though. That's the issue at hand.
The user’s experience is always more important than you think it is. First impressions are always more important than they should be.
In this case, I genuinely believe that AA will live or die based on the experience their customers have. Fixing their homepage is the start of a systematic change they need to make. However, if they don’t regain their customer-experience focus, I think it will doom them.
As a guy who flys 10's of thousands of miles a year, I could care less about their homepage. I don't even use it, I usually go to Orbitz.com so I can get as many itinerary and price options as possible.
I'd rather AA offer better seats, or in-flight wifi, or the ability for me to pay an extra $10 to board in the first group when I am not in first class so I don't have to fight for overhead space.
Their website could be a fucking gopher site for all I really care.
There are a number of web entrepreneurs/hackers that I pay attention to. Some are young, some are old but I know they have paid their dues and earned their stripes.
(PS. I think 37signals did this sort of thing brilliantly: http://37signals.com/better. Reading the copy just makes me feel warm inside and shows good emotional intelligence.)
Stray thought, which likely won't matter to you: Mr. X, who used your site and got fired for it, didn't exactly have a great user experience.
I have personally left sites where the owner has such an attitude. One of them is now upping the efforts to strong-arm users into joining and participating. They seem to still not get the concept that honey is better than vinegar.
This is something that seems (at least on face value) to be perfectly reasonable. He published something from an 'anonymous source.' When was the last time you heard of a company searching the text of an email through their email system to find the culprit?
I could see this being a boneheaded way to protect an 'anonymous source' for an Apple rumor (seeing how cut-throat Apple is with plugging leaks), but when it comes to some random large corporation... probably not. It's not even like any of the information that he provided could be construed by an outside person as a 'trade secret' either. On top of that, it's impossible for dcurtis to know what type of contracts Mr X has signed with AA or what their wording is (or even what the current enforcement policies are).
Anyone who has worked for a large company has heard of this. It probably doesn't make it into the news a lot, but having worked at <Large Company # 123232> we were told many times that your email is constantly being monitored (though they didn't go into the details of how).
Now, I don't know how AA works, but I'm guessing they made this clear upfront. If not, thats a separate issue.
And at that, how is it dcurtis' fault that Mr. X (stupidly) used his company email address? That said, is it possible that dcurtis would have believe Mr. X if it wasn't from an aa.com address? I don't know the answer to that.
How does dcurtis's possible skepticism make him culpable for Mr. X's desire to 'reach out' (to the point that he was willing to use his company email to do so)? Mr. X is still the one making the choice to respond to dcurtis. He's still the one that decides the level of risk to his job that he's willing to take in his dealings with dcurtis. I don't see anything here that could be faulted on dcurtis other than his opinions and writing style.
Brand development is complex and takes years to develop. All this brand-strategy-through-design is fucking nonsense, stop drinking your own kool-aid. That's why I got out of the advertising industry and into consumer products. I'm sorry but designers are not that critical to a brand, and proclaiming such sounds extremely ego centric and naive.
Furthermore, you're criticizing one of many sales channels and generalizing the entire company based on that. You can buy AA tickets through a variety of websites, retailers, travel agents, etc. -- not solely AA.com. In fact, I don't think I've ever bought an AA ticket on AA.com.
When I read your response to Mr. X's response a few months ago, I was quite surprised that YOU were surprised about all the moving pieces in a big corporation. I think you lack quite a bit of business experience, and snail mailers aren't going to get you there. I caution you to think about your word choice when you say things like clueless and incompetence because you're branding yourself a millennial.
But that will not be true in the future, and bringing attention to bad experiences is THE WAY designers can bring about a better world.
But something about accepting it as unchangeable fact does not sit well with me.
It takes a little more than some new shine on something to really improve a user's overall experience. It often takes a near complete restructure of the information and logic flow.
We're on the cusp of a changing society. Customer experience is becoming, in a very literal way, the brand of a company. And when I come across companies so clueless that they won't spend 50k to hire a design firm to design their online identity/experience, I can't help but wonder what kind of negative effect that has on the evolution of the internet and on customer experience design as an industry.
Fixing AA.com would be [strike]ridiculously[/strike] relatively cheap and simple, especially if it was just a new skin based on the logic they already have built (even though there are serious flaws there as well). Yet the company has not done this. It hasn't even hinted at this, and it fired the one guy who seemed to care about it in the organization. This is a management problem, not a design problem. When I mention this, and when I call out the CEO specifically, people call me arrogant, young, naive, and stupid. But I honestly believe the fault for a failing like this, a failing so visceral that it affects the image of the entire company in the eyes of its customers, rests solely in lap of the CEO.
American Airlines is no doubt a terrible company, and not just from a design perspective. The culture there is broken, the "business" is failing (it loses billions of dollars a year), and the majority of customers hate the experience. Something is wrong. Bringing attention to it, I think, can't possibly be a bad thing.