News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Redesigned GNU C Library manual by krapp on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:50AM (#9246560)
Arguably, a threaded forum by design encourages tangential discussions which deviate from the topic the deeper you go. The problem in HN's case is all the threads are open and entirely visible - which is one of the cases where its minimalist layout works against readability.

I think the best solution would be thread folding (which I know is being worked on anyway) where the default is that all threads are collapsed. Then, off topic discussion wouldn't take up any more than a single post's worth of space by default. Having it be a conscious choice to move deeper into a thread also ensures that no one has to scroll past much content they don't care about.

Re:Redesigned GNU C Library manual by aw3c2 on Sunday March 22, 2015 @08:53AM (#9246571)
That would be incredibly annoying on touch interfaces and generally not allow quick scanning of comments anymore. It would take a lot more time.
Re:Redesigned GNU C Library manual by krapp on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:05AM (#9246603)
I suppose open threads by default would be more friendly, or maybe defaulting to open for mobile layouts.

But it taking more time would kind of be the point - opting in to participate rather than opting out by scrolling past content means fewer sarcastic comments about how a thread is off topic and irrelevant.