News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sabbath mode by ars on Saturday March 21, 2015 @10:45PM (#9245322)
Whatever created existence (or the big bang) is by definition supernatural (which means outside nature). So my definition is not different, just differently formulated.

> If you can accept that a supernatural being with superior powers created existence, then you cannot be atheist.

Using your definition no atheists even exist, or at least they are illogical because clearly existence exists. It was created somehow. Or are we going to argue about the word "being" in that sentence?

Because if you are, know that I use that definition because any other is not sufficient to describe the full range of human beliefs. So yes, there is a range in atheism, it is not binary.

Re:Sabbath mode by Dylan16807 on Sunday March 22, 2015 @12:52AM (#9245645)
>Whatever created existence (or the big bang) is by definition supernatural (which means outside nature).

Unless nothing created existence, and the big bang was a natural event unrelated to the existence of existence.

>are we going to argue about the word "being"

Maybe. "being" is pretty clear and necessary to have a God. Wind comes from outside the ocean to make waves, but it is in no way a being or a God. No matter how 'supernatural' it would be from the perspective of ocean=nature.

No binary decision is ever truly perfect, but the yes/no of atheism is pretty damn close.

There's only one empty set.

Re:Sabbath mode by kibibu on Sunday March 22, 2015 @09:31AM (#9246674)
> Whatever created existence (or the big bang) is by definition supernatural

This doesn't follow. It is by definition natural because it occurred naturally.