Re:Cheer YC: Happy Holidays!
by gduffy on Tuesday December 25, 2007 @01:58AM
(#92567)
I think it's more productive to acknowledge all holidays and get 24% more audience, instead of going to extra effort to be sectarian in your good will.
There are plenty of people like me out there, for instance. My family celebrated christmas at this time of year when I was younger. I still feel like having a happy holiday right around now, but I don't connect with any of the Jesus stuff. Thanks to the original poster for wishing me a happy non-christmas-holiday-that-I-celebrate-around-the-same-time-as-christmas (on mine, I get to argue with people on the Internet!).
I feel your point has been thoroughly dismissed now. Happy holidays anyway!
Re:Cheer YC: Happy Holidays!
by Jd on Tuesday December 25, 2007 @02:30AM
(#92572)
Actually, since I'm not celebrating the holiday in question either and am more to happy to argue on the Internet, here are my more extended thoughts.
Even if some subset of the population is going to lose the Jesus bit doesn't it make more sense to keep the name of the holiday the same? For instance, if you are going to send out holiday well wishes (which I appreciate, I also upmodded the original poster) and going to send them out at a specific time (for example, Dec. 25) doesn't it make sense to refer to the holiday as 'Christmas' ?
In my own limited personal campaign of holiday well-wishes, I usually end up only wishing Christmas greetings to people I know are Christians, sending more general holiday greetings to others at a time other than Christmas.
In conclusion, my contention is that if you are going to send your greeting on Christmas, you might as well call it a Christmas greeting. If you send it Dec. 20, or 27, then maybe a holiday greeting.
Re:Cheer YC: Happy Holidays!
by gduffy on Tuesday December 25, 2007 @03:02AM
(#92577)
It's terribly more efficient to send out generic holiday wishes to everyone and stop associating with anyone who gets too offended that you didn't conform to their particular brand of holiday. I really don't want to keep a 6 billion row spreadsheet of holiday associations for everyone I might encounter and wish well of.
Will mass confusion ensue if generic "happy holidays" cards are sent on the same day as christmas? Will people not know what day of the year it is? There is no utility to the nomenclature. No religion owns the day, and it's hardly a religious holiday to begin with.
It doesn't offend me when people say merry christmas, it only offends me if they are attempting to correct somebody who says happy holidays. It's a superset. You're correcting someone who says "yes! it's the weekend!" with "no, but thank god it's Saturday!".
Re:Cheer YC: Happy Holidays!
by iamelgringo on Tuesday December 25, 2007 @03:55AM
(#92579)
Sigh... I thought long and hard about the Christmas vs Holiday wishes thing. I'm actually pretty devout in my Christianity, but I rather dislike people who are jerks about it. How about this:
To my Christian friends Merry Christmas.
To my Jewish friends Happy Hannukah.
To my Atheist friends Happy Holidays.
And to all a happy New Year.
(Unless you're Chinese, then I'm a few weeks early.)
Re:Cheer YC: Happy Holidays!
by Xichekolas on Wednesday December 26, 2007 @10:56AM
(#92725)
Don't you think it's a waste of time to pre-plan your holiday wishes to be so politically correct? You could wish me a Happy Kwanzaa and I'd get the idea that you wanted to wish me well for whatever holiday I choose to celebrate... I wouldn't immediately be offended because you didn't know which 'holiday reference' I preferred to hear.
Re:Cheer YC: Happy Holidays!
by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday December 25, 2007 @09:56AM
(#92597)
Gosh no, guys!
It's all about market differentiation. You should ideally wish each person a holiday wish based on their unique belief and practices. Lots more karma in that than blanket statements.
It's the long tail of holiday-greeting-karma-whoring strategy. :)
Re:Cheer YC: Happy Holidays!
by iamwil on Monday December 24, 2007 @03:41PM
(#92488)
At first I thought there was a meaning to the colored numbers, but then I noticed they alternated. Too bad. It'd be neat to indicate how fast a story is moving up the list. However, it'd be completely inaccessible to color blind people.
Re:Cheer YC: Happy Holidays!
by albertcardona on Tuesday December 25, 2007 @12:02PM
(#92608)
I never understood what so great about changing the year. We have not needed an accurate sun/earth based calendar since the last time the majority of the population were farmers in need of harvesting and seeding.
Weeks and months area also devoid of meaning, and again a need only for farmers, hunters and gatherers. Since we live in a digital age, why not celebrate periods that are a power of 2? Like 1024 ... counting my life in kilodays would relate a lot more to what I'm doing every day than the notion of the earth revolving around the sun.
But happy holidays!
Regardless, it's still a nice thing to do, don't you think?
There are plenty of people like me out there, for instance. My family celebrated christmas at this time of year when I was younger. I still feel like having a happy holiday right around now, but I don't connect with any of the Jesus stuff. Thanks to the original poster for wishing me a happy non-christmas-holiday-that-I-celebrate-around-the-same-time-as-christmas (on mine, I get to argue with people on the Internet!).
I feel your point has been thoroughly dismissed now. Happy holidays anyway!
Even if some subset of the population is going to lose the Jesus bit doesn't it make more sense to keep the name of the holiday the same? For instance, if you are going to send out holiday well wishes (which I appreciate, I also upmodded the original poster) and going to send them out at a specific time (for example, Dec. 25) doesn't it make sense to refer to the holiday as 'Christmas' ?
In my own limited personal campaign of holiday well-wishes, I usually end up only wishing Christmas greetings to people I know are Christians, sending more general holiday greetings to others at a time other than Christmas.
In conclusion, my contention is that if you are going to send your greeting on Christmas, you might as well call it a Christmas greeting. If you send it Dec. 20, or 27, then maybe a holiday greeting.
Will mass confusion ensue if generic "happy holidays" cards are sent on the same day as christmas? Will people not know what day of the year it is? There is no utility to the nomenclature. No religion owns the day, and it's hardly a religious holiday to begin with.
It doesn't offend me when people say merry christmas, it only offends me if they are attempting to correct somebody who says happy holidays. It's a superset. You're correcting someone who says "yes! it's the weekend!" with "no, but thank god it's Saturday!".
To my Christian friends Merry Christmas. To my Jewish friends Happy Hannukah. To my Atheist friends Happy Holidays. And to all a happy New Year. (Unless you're Chinese, then I'm a few weeks early.)
So uh... Happy Fourth of July!
It's all about market differentiation. You should ideally wish each person a holiday wish based on their unique belief and practices. Lots more karma in that than blanket statements.
It's the long tail of holiday-greeting-karma-whoring strategy. :)
Merry Christmas, all!
Seriously, you should contact my agent in Kenya for your $4,000,000 check. For a small fee of $10,000 you can have his phone number.
</tongue_in_cheek>
Laws of Nordstrom.
I was a few hours too early... http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=92249
Edu, don't worry you still have New year ;)
Anyway, Happy Holidays all.
Makes my eyes bleed red and green :)
Weeks and months area also devoid of meaning, and again a need only for farmers, hunters and gatherers. Since we live in a digital age, why not celebrate periods that are a power of 2? Like 1024 ... counting my life in kilodays would relate a lot more to what I'm doing every day than the notion of the earth revolving around the sun.