I am very wary of "X always ends up as Y" arguments. If you don't like big companies abusing power, then close the loopholes or break them up (though I much prefer the former). If you don't like big government abusing citizens, then change the laws to limit government.
I like big government because they really do tend to work towards the public good. Look at healthcare or welfare in Australia for an example. I like big tech because they really do increase economic efficiency, and drive technology forwards.
I think as poorly of the conspiratorial thinking of #4's as they do of the "dark side".
I'm aware you were simplifying a little, but I think that's more than an insignificant divide.
In theory at least. I end up much closer to #4 since I'm not convinced that the government-people feedback loop works correctly, but I can imagine circumstances in which I might be #2.
It seems there is now a four-way breakdown among American techies:
And it all depends on your base political philosophy or leanings.This article is a pretty formulaic example of what happens when someone from the 2nd perspective discovers John Perry Barlow's writings.