News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The growing size of firms may help to explain rising ineq... by PaulHoule on Thursday March 19, 2015 @03:14PM (#9233956)
I've wondered if 401k plans and IRAs have held back small businesses because people could have spent the money to start their own businesses; it is horribly difficult to beat an S&P 500 index fund, but the popularity of those funds mean a lot of people are spraying money at them.
Re:The growing size of firms may help to explain rising ineq... by maxerickson on Thursday March 19, 2015 @03:45PM (#9234130)
Do you think they've displaced a significant amount of savings?

(They've displaced things like pension programs, but those are even less flexible)

Re:The growing size of firms may help to explain rising ineq... by bcg1 on Thursday March 19, 2015 @04:11PM (#9234291)
The hidden fees of 401k plans have been displaced to Wall St firms unbeknownst to most participants because they don't show up on statements, and because the balance that people see on their statements give an inflated sense of how much they have saved, even though they still need to pay taxes when they withdraw.

It also diverts money away from more conservative long term investments in tangible wealth like real estate and into the stock market, so people are less diversified and lose out when the markets go down. 401k's really only let you take long positions, while financial firms can take either side of the trade... you can reason out who the winner will be in that situation.

Re:The growing size of firms may help to explain rising ineq... by Consultant32452 on Thursday March 19, 2015 @04:42PM (#9234483)
Those things aren't significantly different compared to pensions. In a pension your pension fund will be paying wall street fees. You have even less control to be able to do things like invest in real estate with a pension. At least in a 401k plan you can potentially invest in mutual funds that are proxies for real estate.

I have an IRA through my employer (which happens to be my own company, but that's irrelevant). I can bet against the market via ETFs if I want in my IRA. Your employer just chooses a plan for you with crap flexibility.

I think the biggest change has really been the social acceptance of massive consumer debt. I cringe so hard every time I hear someone say something like, "I paid down my credit card a bit so I could buy that new XBox." People didn't used to live that way and the removal of pensions had nothing to do with that. I would still put a lot of blame on Wall Street there, but not because of fees on retirement plans.

Re:The growing size of firms may help to explain rising ineq... by bcg1 on Thursday March 19, 2015 @06:54PM (#9235126)
I agree with you... my statements were actually specifically about 401k's, and whether or not they contribute to capital misallocation. Almost all 401k plans are much more restrictive than IRA accounts. Personally I think that a self-directed IRA is a fantastic vehicle where you can buy actual real estate etc, but they are so far outside the norm that they almost don't exist when speaking in generalities.

I also agree about the social acceptance of consumer debt. They say you learn from your mistakes, and boy have I done a lot of learning. Resolving to get and stay out of debt is a life changing decision for sure.

Re:The growing size of firms may help to explain rising ineq... by sliverstorm on Thursday March 19, 2015 @04:04PM (#9234235)
401k's and IRA's are not obligatory. If you wanted to invest your money to start your own business, no one is forcing you to put that seed money in a retirement account. Plus Roth IRA's can be withdrawn from at any time...

And, even if retirement accounts do impinge a bit on things like small businesses, do remember that stable retirement prospects are a social good.

Re:The growing size of firms may help to explain rising ineq... by PaulHoule on Thursday March 19, 2015 @06:29PM (#9235000)
In theory, but in practice the tax deferred retirement plans are doing very little for the median American.
Re:The growing size of firms may help to explain rising ineq... by AceJohnny2 on Thursday March 19, 2015 @07:14PM (#9235216)
As I understand, this is exactly what manipluating the federal interest rate is about targeting: they're changing the incentives on different investment types. When federal interest rates are low, this pushes people to search for other (riskier) investments.

Also, I wonder if 401ks and IRAs have that much weight in the grander view of "invested" money saved away, considering their tax-deductability, and thus appeal as a savings plan, is limited and constrained (this year: $18k for a 401k, $5.5K ($6.5K if you're over 50) for IRAs).