As for whether these justifications are wrong--it's hard to say. From a jobs point of view, it's probably still not a win for NJ for those dealerships to shut down and have NJ money flow over the internet directly to California. The consumer protection angle is a lot weaker in a day and age where Tesla can monitor your car's stats over the internet.
Consumers will pay less for their cars, and the extra $1000-$2000 dealerships make on each car, will remain in the consumer's pocket. This is better on the whole.
Dealerships are market inefficiencies, as they create no real value or "wealth"[1]. They give nothing to consumers in return for the $1-$2k extra that consumers pay for each car.
[1] As defined by Paul Graham in: http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html
This is very surprising complaint to hear - the whole capitalist economy is filled with inefficiencies! (and Paul Graham is hardly saying something novel here).
In reference to local car dealers part. So states were mainly only interested in the money, but then justified it under the guise of consumer protections.
Is that fair to say ? Or did states really care about consumer protections ?
And in the pursuit of truthiness, and not creating a false dichotomy, are both those wrong ?