News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by rayiner on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:35AM (#9231744)
The regulatory capture argument someone made below is hard to square with the history: http://www.americanbar.org/publications/franchise_lawyer/201.... At first, cars were sold directly to consumers by manufacturers, and independent dealerships were rare. It's really hard to explain using a regulatory capture or lobbying model how car manufacturers, huge incredibly profitable companies at the time, lost their bid to preserve the status quo.

In reality, these were consumer and economic protection laws. States didn't like how much money was flowing from their economies to Detroit, and by making direct consumer sales illegal they gave a lot of leverage to franchises, which are local businesses. They also justified the laws on consumer protection grounds--local car dealers would be a lot more responsive to customers than a megacorp in Detroit.

As for the "planned economy" aspect--remember that the ideas of what constituted unreasonable interference in the economy were very different back then. The revolution of applying economics principles to government didn't really happen until the 1960's and 1970's. Before that, quite extensive interventions in the economy were routine. For example, prior to the 1970's, the Civil Aeronautics Board set airline ticket prices! That would be amazingly controversial in the U.S. today, on either side of the aisle, but was par for course back in the day.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by mr_luc on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:58AM (#9231892)
Sure, they didn't originate with regulatory capture.

But the actions to prevent Tesla from selling direct now, today, have definitely been the result of regulatory capture.

The original interventions created a kind of local businessman, who knew he owed his existence to these local regulations.

And now that these laws have been made unnecessary due to the availability of both information and exposure -- and incontrovertibly unnecessary in the case of for instance a large city or densely populated state, where healthy competition exists -- the reason that they hang on and prevent companies from Tesla from opening shop is absolutely regulatory capture.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by DougBTX on Thursday March 19, 2015 @10:16AM (#9232041)
> regulatory capture

There doesn't seem to be much disagreement about the facts, just the definition of "regulatory capture".

The idea which "regulatory capture" describes is when regulations fail to do what they are intended to do, when instead of restricting they empower.

But the regulations have not "failed", they are still restricting manufacturers and empowering dealers, so this isn't "regulatory capture", just bog-standard monopoly-granting.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by jessriedel on Thursday March 19, 2015 @10:39AM (#9232212)
No, that's not the normal definition. Wikipedia, for example:

> Regulatory capture is a form of political corruption that occurs when a regulatory agency, created to act in the public interest, instead advances the commercial or special concerns of interest groups that dominate the industry or sector it is charged with regulating

Enforcing barriers to entry is a huge aspect of regulatory capture. A regulation that creates $1 million/year of compliance costs nominally "restricts" all players (and certainly doesn't "empower" them), but that money is often a pittance for large companies while effectively squashing new entrants, greatly to the large companies' benefit.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by jessriedel on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:56AM (#9231883)
I don't think the possibility that the original laws were motivated by good intentions conflicts whatsoever with the hypothesis of regulatory capture today. Industries have been using outdated laws to build barriers to entry since time immemorial.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by libria on Thursday March 19, 2015 @10:07AM (#9231956)
> States didn't like how much money was flowing from their economies to Detroit, and by making direct consumer sales illegal they gave a lot of leverage to franchises, which are local businesses.

That seems to make sense. What's different about Palo Alto, CA that they're ok with money flowing directly there? Is it because dealerships have become unnecessary middlemen putting more $ on the cost before it reaches consumer hands?

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by rayiner on Thursday March 19, 2015 @10:11AM (#9231991)
Palo Alto isn't different.[1] Getting rid of these laws will cost NJ jobs, while making products slightly cheaper for everyone else. In a state like NJ, that's a tough pill to swallow no matter what.

[1] In fact, I imagine lots of state legislators hate Palo Alto for making middle class jobs in their states obsolete while creating a few high paying jobs in California and diverting the difference to shareholders in New York. We're talking about a state hollowed out by deindustrialization, where the promise of better jobs to replace the ones lost was made decades ago, and still has yet to materialize.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by paddy_m on Thursday March 19, 2015 @11:08AM (#9232430)
I don't know if you are advocating for a zero sum view of the economy, but you are definitely describing one. The thing about those middle class jobs that New Jersey is losing, is that they didn't need to exist. The only way they did was by stealing through coercion a little bit from people who chose to buy cars in New Jersey (mostly state residents).
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by rayiner on Thursday March 19, 2015 @12:12PM (#9232915)
I'm not describing a zero-sum economy. It's possible that NJ suffers a net local loss, even if that's more than outweighed by a net benefit in NJ + CA. And even if NJ enjoys a net local benefit, you still have a bunch of people out of work in return for everyone paying slightly lower prices for cars. In a place like NJ, where unemployment is the #1, #2, and #3 concern, you can see why legislators would be gun-shy about getting rid of local protections in the name of economic idealism.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by swatow on Thursday March 19, 2015 @11:34PM (#9236112)
The standard arguments for free trade apply as much to individual states as to countries. Just as the US enjoys a net benefit from buying goods from China instead of making them, so does New Jersey enjoy a net gain from its residents buying California cars without any New Jersey middleman.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by remarkEon on Thursday March 19, 2015 @01:26PM (#9233370)
I'd probably suggest that if a direct-from-manufacturer store would open in NJ the people most likely to be able to find employment at such an establishment would be those who used to work at a dealership.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by brc on Thursday March 19, 2015 @11:21PM (#9236081)
It's not just states that hate Palo Alto. Foreign governments the world over are chafing at the amounts of revenue that pour into Google and Apple and they don't get even the tiniest cut.

A large economy will have consumers spending millions on google ads and iTunes content, and none of it will end up in the tax coffers of the local country.

This is better off for everyone except for the politicians who want to throw money around.

The eventual result will be make-work schemes like the local dealer franchises. Expect enforced-local entities in some countries where an office is created and people do meaningless work so the tax revenues can be domiciled. In other words, the exact same model as the car dealerships.

It's bad but people hate being exposed to the market, because it systematically punishes laziness. Most people will vote for a politician to make it easier for them to be lazy, even if it ultimately makes them worse off.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by MollyR on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:48AM (#9231832)
That was very insightful.

In reference to local car dealers part. So states were mainly only interested in the money, but then justified it under the guise of consumer protections.

Is that fair to say ? Or did states really care about consumer protections ?

And in the pursuit of truthiness, and not creating a false dichotomy, are both those wrong ?

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by rayiner on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:55AM (#9231878)
To get legislation like this passed, you build a coalition. So the consumer protection angle isn't just a guise so much as it is an angle to get the support of consumer-minded legislators.

As for whether these justifications are wrong--it's hard to say. From a jobs point of view, it's probably still not a win for NJ for those dealerships to shut down and have NJ money flow over the internet directly to California. The consumer protection angle is a lot weaker in a day and age where Tesla can monitor your car's stats over the internet.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by winter_blue on Thursday March 19, 2015 @10:24AM (#9232091)
Actually, no extra money will flow from NJ to California.

Consumers will pay less for their cars, and the extra $1000-$2000 dealerships make on each car, will remain in the consumer's pocket. This is better on the whole.

Dealerships are market inefficiencies, as they create no real value or "wealth"[1]. They give nothing to consumers in return for the $1-$2k extra that consumers pay for each car.

[1] As defined by Paul Graham in: http://paulgraham.com/wealth.html

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by rayiner on Thursday March 19, 2015 @10:30AM (#9232142)
Eliminating an economic inefficiency (the middle-man) creates a surplus. Where that surplus flows, whether to the consumer or the producer or split between both, depends on the market.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by hurin on Thursday March 19, 2015 @11:14AM (#9232481)
> Dealerships are market inefficiencies, as they create no real value or "wealth"[1].

This is very surprising complaint to hear - the whole capitalist economy is filled with inefficiencies! (and Paul Graham is hardly saying something novel here).

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by SilasX on Thursday March 19, 2015 @11:43AM (#9232719)
The GP wasn't saying that all middlemen add inefficiencies or destroy value, only that these particular ones do since you're forced to use them regardless of need.