News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by wheaties on Thursday March 19, 2015 @08:45AM (#9231455)
Oh, it's easy. It's through things like regulatory capture, funding campaigns and thus having direct access to congressional workers, having people appointed to regulatory bodies that are partial to your stance and/or other means of influencing non-elected officials. Basically, if you can't beat them through normal market means, pass laws so they can't beat you.

Sounds cynical but take note, back when cars were first coming out the laws that were passed in response to them were designed to impede the adoption, not promote.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by amalcon on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:05AM (#9231563)
Your explanation doesn't really make sense.

Consider: who would benefit most from the removal of these laws? The obvious answer is the General Motors Corporation. They could own their own dealerships, getting better control of customer experience and a bigger cut of the profits. It's not like they're short on capital such that they would be forced to franchise anyway. As the largest automaker in the world for most of the last century, they would get a significantly outsized benefit compared to any competitor.

Now for a rhetorical question. Who has more political power in the U.S: car dealerships in aggregate or General Motors? Answer: General Motors, of course!

Another rhetorical question: Does Tesla have more political power in New Jersey than GM as well, given that the exception was carved out specifically regarding the type of vehicle they produce?

edit: New Jersey is no stranger to economic protectionism. They actually prohibit self-service auto refueling as a jobs program, which would seem to be more threatened by Tesla than car dealerships. I'm not trying to argue that it doesn't exist, just that it doesn't explain what's going on here.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by adventured on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:18AM (#9231642)
These are state laws. General Motors had less influence at the state and local level than the auto dealerships did. At that level it's about intimate relationships, those dealership owners directly knew and financed their local politicians and GM did not.

GM was facing a nearly impossible 50 state battle, spanning thousands of politicians, in trying to do anything about the dealership cartels. Instead, GM was ultimately ok with a truce with them so long as GM could control issuing (or revoking) the dealer licenses.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by amalcon on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:25AM (#9231683)
Michigan has auto dealer licensure requirements, which (as far as I can tell, though I am not a lawyer so you shouldn't believe me) are very similar to those in New Jersey. Car dealerships do not have more political influence in Michigan than GM does.

Also, if it were just a political fight between businesse interests, GM could just go over the states' heads: people frequently buy cars across state lines, so the commerce clause reasoning for a law prohibiting these laws wouldn't even be as tortured as it usually is.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by raldi on Thursday March 19, 2015 @10:01AM (#9231919)
> Who has more political power in the U.S: car dealerships in aggregate or General Motors? Answer: General Motors, of course!

What makes you so sure?

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by peterfirefly on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:37AM (#9231758)
Detroit liked it because it was and is a barrier for foreign car makers.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday March 19, 2015 @10:35AM (#9232181)
I think the ban on self-service fueling is a great idea and I wish more states (beyond Oregon) would do it.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by ctdonath on Thursday March 19, 2015 @11:46AM (#9232745)
I'm baffled that anyone would think that's a great idea. Compelling drivers to pay someone to do something that nearly all drivers have no problem doing themselves seems absurd. Please explain your reasoning.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by Tenhundfeld on Thursday March 19, 2015 @01:35PM (#9233434)
I wonder if GP is trolling. Having spent time in NJ visiting family, I've researched this issue a bit and have never found any logic to support the ban on self-service pumps – beyond corruption, politics, etc.

The one interesting thing I did find is that many disabled motorists have a very hard time using self-service pumps – while still being able to drive safely with vehicle modifications. The Americans with Disabilities Act even has a requirement that gas stations provide refueling assistance, with some exceptions. (http://www.ada.gov/gasserve.htm)

That still doesn't mean self-service should be banned. At most, it's argument for requiring gas stations to have >=1 full-service pump.

The other funny thing is that many NJ natives seem to really like using full-service pumps and want to keep the ban. And because they have low gas taxes and import so much fuel, NJ still has some of the cheapest gas in the country. So, there's not much political will to change it – despite the inanity.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by GFK_of_xmaspast on Thursday March 19, 2015 @04:25PM (#9234381)
We are rapidly moving towards making lots and lots of jobs on the low end of the skill spectrum obsolete. (and plenty of medium-to-high skill jobs as well) Non-self-service stations provide a lot of employment opportunities.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by Tenhundfeld on Friday March 20, 2015 @12:02PM (#9238483)
Yeah, that argument doesn't work for me. Creating arbitrary, unnecessary inefficiencies in the market does not benefit a society economically in the long-run – and is bad mechanism for wealth redistribution.

Why not ban ATM's to provide bank teller employment? Or ban self-checkout at grocery stores? Let's not forget all of those poor elevator operators out of work.

Maybe we should go around breaking windows to create work for local glaziers? (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window)

I appreciate the sentiment of wanting to provide low-skill employment opportunities, but this is not the way to do it. It's provably bad logic.

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by ams6110 on Thursday March 19, 2015 @11:06PM (#9236047)
When I was a kid nearly all fuel stations were "full service." You would pull in, and an attendant would pump the fuel, check oil, clean your windows, air up tires if needed, take payment, and you never had to step out of the car. It was really nice, actually. Now you get to do all that yourself while standing out in the cold or heat, or dealing with an indifferent clerk who adds zero value to the transaction.
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by ctdonath on Friday March 20, 2015 @09:17AM (#9237454)
Providing the service as an option is fine.

Mandating it is absurd. That people would go so far as incarcerate people for pumping their own gas goes way beyond resolving an inconvenience and well into normalizing bureaucratic oppression. (Yes, that sounds overstated - but really, jail time for pumping gas? it's not about the pumping, it's about something being very wrong & dangerous about the mindset that thinks jail time for pumping gas is reasonable.)

Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by ahallock on Thursday March 19, 2015 @11:10AM (#9232443)
Why is it a great idea?
Re:New Jersey legalizes direct Tesla sales by ptaipale on Thursday March 19, 2015 @09:01AM (#9231549)
In more plain language: car dealers (companies and their workers) lobbied for politicians to ban competition. They give campaign funding, and in exchange they get legislation like this ban.