News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The knowledge argument by thaumaturgy on Thursday March 19, 2015 @02:30AM (#9230488)
But this looks identical to the "immovable object vs. unstoppable object" paradox. It presupposes something that doesn't actually exist.

Experience is information. It doesn't make sense to imagine a situation in which she has all the information about a thing, except experience. Either she has all of the information about it, or she doesn't.

Re:The knowledge argument by jordonwii on Thursday March 19, 2015 @02:46AM (#9230531)
Let's take the claim "experience is information" to be true (I've yet to find a reasonable definition of "information", so I agree).

Jackson's point here is specifically to show that there are at least two kinds of information: physical information, and information that is not physical. Bearing that in mind, what do you mean by: > "Either she has all of the information about it, or she doesn't."

Re:The knowledge argument by thaumaturgy on Thursday March 19, 2015 @03:31AM (#9230656)
What I mean is that all information is physical information -- I'm rejecting outright his starting premise, because no amount of research on wavelengths or poetry will excite the exact same neurons in your brain that are excited by actually seeing a color.

I suppose that my objection falls under 4.2 in http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qualia-knowledge/, specifically, metaphysical physicalism: "there are no non-physical individuals, properties or relations and no non-physical facts".

What would be a good example of non-physical information?