Re:The knowledge argument
by tunesmith on Thursday March 19, 2015 @02:14AM
(#9230454)
This seems to be more about a limitation of language than a problem with the logic. Using "knowledge" in both premises looks clumsy. But looking at it purely conceptually, where Mary would intellectually understand the complete theory in the B&W room, and then gain new experiential insight when leaving the room, it seems to at least prove that experiential knowledge is inherently different than theoretical knowledge.
That's more what confuses me about the structure of this argument, though - I would take the experiential insight to be more "physical". So I still don't understand what they mean by physicalism.
Re:The knowledge argument
by meric on Thursday March 19, 2015 @02:44AM
(#9230523)
If Mary only knows about colours "intellectually" then she might be a SHRDLU for colour, knowing the calculations of blocks symbolically but not knowing blocks and gravity, having never experienced it. http://hci.stanford.edu/winograd/shrdlu/
That's more what confuses me about the structure of this argument, though - I would take the experiential insight to be more "physical". So I still don't understand what they mean by physicalism.