Like so much else, "it depends". If you're sure that's the explanation and no other makes sense, you're bonkers... our knowledge isn't strong enough to make that claim exclusively.
However, as answers to the Fermi Paradox go, "Something out there stomps flat anything that looks like a developing civilization", as unpleasant as it may be to contemplate, is definitely in the running. Along with a difficult-to-bound number of other candidate answers, but it's not a crazy one based on the meager evidence we've collected to date on the topic.
* That life in our galaxy is unique to our planet given our now solid knowledge that similar planet systems and planets of the correct size in habitable zones are beyond abundant
* That intelligent life, given the above, is also not unique to our planet
* That some intelligent life is not millions of years more advanced
* That there is nothing capable or motivated to wipe out entire planets for reasons to us which seem irrational and murderous
---
Lots of folks get confused between the increasing rationality of assuming life exists somewhere besides Earth and conspiracy nuts who think every unusual weather phenomenon and experimental aircraft is an alien.
---
The disconnect and irrationality comes from attributing non-Human sentience to unexplained phenomena.
If your foot hurts, it's pretty easy to go on WebMD and convince yourself that you have bone cancer. It's not irrational because it's impossible, but because your overactive imagination has chosen the most interesting solution over the most reasonable one.
---
Likewise your mind shouldn't be closed to the idea of something we observe in the next century being definitely attributable to extraterrestrial intelligence; but it will take some extraordinary exclusion of natural happenings to make it conclusive.
The latter belief is supported by a lot of evidence: the molecular machinery of our kind of life is pretty common, and the chemistry that drives it appears to be robust and nothing special.
To get a sense of how special the kind of intelligence that builds spaceships is, however, consider that every complex feature of organisms, from insect societies to wings to eyes, has evolved many, many times, all independently of one another.
Intelligence of the kind that builds spaceships, on the other hand, has evolved exactly once in the history of our planet, and appears to have been the result of a runaway mate competition and mate selection process in our social primate ancestors. There was certainly no material advantage to having a brain big enough and well enough designed to build spaceships when you were busy scrabbling for food (a feat that a huge range of unintelligent organisms, including unintelligent social organisms, manage reasonably well.)
So it is quite plausible that there is life all over the place in the universe, and intelligence almost nowhere. Just because we can see the advantages of intelligence doesn't mean there is a clear evolutionary path toward it, and the history of life on Earth suggests in fact that the path to the kind of intelligence that builds spaceships is extremely narrow and twisty.
Life as such might be common as mold in cosmos but utterly unable to move from star to star or even broadly choose it's "destiny".
- And simplest hypothesis is that if these Martians existed, they wiped themselves out, as it human beings seem on the way to doing. What are the odds?
While an appealing argument, it is in actuality sophomoric, not the sophisticated argument it fancies itself. Independent probabilities stack exponentially; as we look out into our universe, chances for life only expand somewhere between n^2 and n^3 as we look farther out (it's not pure n^3, our universe has vast empty spaces). We don't know what is really required for life. It could be little more than "a space to grow and some sunlight", but then, we kinda know there's a bit more to it than that from our own Moon. It could also be a surprisingly large stack of requirements (see any ol' Rare Earth argument, as all I'm referring to is the possibility that it could be a large stack), in which case the mere presence of bajillions and bajillions of planets are irrelevant in the face of what could be 1:2^bajillions odds.
We do not know. "But there's so many planets out there!" is just your human mind being blown by large numbers, not a scientific argument. We can not establish that the odds against life may well be even larger numbers. And we can establish through arguments such as the Great Filter [1] that if life is in fact abundant and easy, there's still something very wrong with our understanding of the universe. If it's so easy to be alive and intelligent, we really, really ought to see a different universe. "There's so many planets, how can life be rare?", as emotionally appealing as it may be, hasn't got a very good answer for that. It isn't the last word on the topic as you are presenting it.
It was not about ruling anything out, or a statement that any particular position was irrational.
As you can see in my other posts, in general I'm mostly arguing against certainty of any of the options. I've got my personal guesses, which I am not ashamed about, we are all entitled to our guesses, but intellectually honest people must put error bars on them that fill pretty much the whole probability range. But, by the same token, we can't eliminate very many of them either.
If one believes the radiation anomalies are from nuclear explosions, it seems at least remotely plausible that they came from off-planet (because who would do that to their own?). At that pointpoint it's not entirely lunacy to consider the existence of genocidal aliens.
None of that means that any of those are true, but each seems to be an explanation that might occur to any normal person who accepts the preceding points. The idea of genocidal aliens has been part of our cultural zeitgeist for some time -- isn't that the premise of Mass Effect?
Occam's Razor dictates that the simplest answer is probably correct. What's simpler:
A) This is the result of a naturally occurring process that has happened on our own planet.
B) Aliens
I'm as excited as the next sci-fi fan to shake hands with aliens, but this isn't even remotely close to a reasonable argument.The more recent paper seems like a rehashed subplot from Heinlein's "Rocket Ship Galileo"
From chapter 11:
Morrie grasped his arm, to steady himself apparently, but quite as much for the comfort of solid human companionship. "You know what I think, Ross," he began, as he stared out at the endless miles of craters. "I think I know how it got that way. Those aren't volcanic craters, that's certain—and it wasn't done by meteors. They did it themselves!"
"Huh? Who?"
"The moon people. They did it. They wrecked themselves. They ruined themselves. They had one atomic war too many."
"Huh? What the-" Ross stared, then looked back at the surface as if to read the grim mystery there. Art stopped taking pictures.
"How about it, Doc?"
Cargraves wrinkled his brow. "Could be," he admitted. "None of the other theories for natural causes hold water for one reason or another. It would account for the relatively smooth parts we call ‘seas.' They really were seas; that's why they weren't hit very hard."
"And that's why they aren't seas any more," Morrie went on. "They blew their atmosphere off and the seas boiled away at Tycho. That's where they set off the biggest ammunition dump on the planet. It cracked the whole planet. I'll bet somebody worked out a counter-weapon that worked too well. It set off every atom bomb on the moon all at once and it ruined them! I'm sure of it."
I'm not arguing against Occam's Razor. I actually think, given those broad questions, that we haven't even begun to scratch the surface of the simplest explanation(A).
Once one begins hypothesizing "things that can do anything in ways we don't understand for reasons we don't understand but occasionally do some things we do understand but again for no clear or unambiguous reason" then one's ability to use Occam's razor is gone.
Maybe a spaceship go marooned on Mars and exploded in the process of trying to fix it's warp drive. What are the odds? Clearly we don't know what the odds for any of this.
A simpler hypothesis is a supposed Martian civilization wiped out itself. No necessarily true or supported by much evidence but it seems at least sort-of testable since it doesn't assume variables beyond our conception of what's possible. Human civilization has been poised on the brink of large-scale nuclear in the not-too-distant past so intelligence creating world-destroying-nukes hardly seems like that big a stretch.
We don't know of a way to travel between them _quickly enough to be practical for humans_. That's not a problem for machines. They can be patient and take thousands of years.
Well, as far as we know, 100% of all species who can do it, will do it.
Maybe that's why the entire galactic community didn't want to believe in the existence of Reapers - "Genocidal aliens cleaning up the entire galaxy? Now this is just bonkers!".
He could've consulted with another subject matter expert, but instead he decided to act as though the very notion of an ancient civilization on Mars getting nuked to extinction is prima facie absurd, and then ended his article with the kind of things you'd expect to hear from a Fox News anchor.
And I say this as someone that thinks the chances of any advanced civilization having been on Mars at any point in the past, let alone getting nuked to death, is ... rather unlikely.
PZ Myers is probably right, but in this case, it's only accidentally.
"This article was written in early 2005, and submitted then to Science. Perhaps predictably enough, it was rejected."
Reminder: http://scienceblogs.com/principles/2012/01/30/the-arxiv-is-n...
The link you provided is interesting speculation, perhaps an amusing philosophical exercise, but if you think it's science, then we aren't talking the same language.
> That doesn't sound crazy to me, just human."
I linked to a reasonable article by him to establish that he wasn't just a nut, but we'll have to agree to disagree on his metaphysical crisis, because the speculation that anomalous levels of radiation in parts of Mars is due to "big nasty genocidal intelligences," that sounds Dianetics-level bonkers to me.
I think he's drawn attention to some very interesting data, but that's where I get off the bus.
Update: I actually watched the video he did with Supreme Master TV, give it a look and judge it for yourself: http://youtu.be/NBuN3uHnjYY