You want the packaging to be part of the aesthetic experience, rather than purely functional. OK, so you like Apple's packaging, but 'best in the world'? Japanese people have been doing that sort of thing for centuries.
I saw it, too, but it was his opinion to make. Nothing wrong with it, subtle or otherwise.
Also, standard foam is terrible for the environment, something the article doesn't bother to mention, while implying the standard packaging with foam is fine (while mentioning environmental friendliness should be a goal).
I blame losing Steve Jobs and his ridiculous sensitivity to such details.
"Being rich demands fine motor skills."
-- a high end smartphone ownerOne of the article's points is that elaborate packaging is an embarrassing display of consumerism. I guess camping in front of a store to be the first, and being interviewed opening the box is kind of sad in that way too.
The author's example of "standard packaging" is not bad packaging, as it does its job well. It protects the product, the reason for the purchase, and it isn't difficult for the user to unpack. It might arguably be more environmentally friendly in its use of corrugated cardboard, and I have no idea about the foam. But it is likely less wasteful on this measure than Apple's packaging when you consider the entire process required.
When you tack on the "customer experience" aspect of this packaging, not caring about creating luxury packaging doesn't mean the company does not think about the user's experience or care about the product itself. In the author's situation, the user is more aware of how wasteful and unnecessary this packaging is, and it doesn't help his experience. It also makes the product unnecessarily expensive.
Apple only has the best packaging in every way if you ignore these negative aspects.
Apple has also used the more standard packaging approach for some of its products, such as laptops, in the recent past, but with white printed cardboard. Does that mean Apple didn't care or pay attention to detail back then?
Even though we're told from an early age to never judge a book by its cover, first impressions are hard to shake. And handling packaging is the first impression, not actually using whatever is inside the package. It's the first time an end-user actually physically interacts with your company.
So I agree with you. If the customer is interacting with it, it's a part of the customer experience and should be at least considered. Not everyone can have Apple's resources, yes. But everyone can do the very best with what they have.
I'm thinking of Chubbies, that short-shorts company for guys who want to be Magnum PI. They are a small(ish) startup, but their packaging does not feel that way. It feels like their company. Looks preppy, feels rugged, and is over-the-top with nationalistic and company pride.
Why change something not visibly broken?
I disagree that non-luxury packaging automatically means the company doesn't care about the product contained inside. It's a matter of strategy & costs. I'm not familiar with HP packaging, but you should know that ASUS does offer luxury packaging for its gaming range of products for instance, especially laptops.
My opinion is that it's possible to design thoughtful, non-generic packaging without crossing into luxury materials territory. Experience and loads of creativity are required though. At least this is what I understood from the article (taking into account the Pencil example as well), that startups should bet on resourcefulness instead of throwing money in non-priority directions.
Another aspect to consider: I don't have the specific numbers to back this up, but we live in a world where the general trend is towards minimalism and simplifying our lives, which includes getting rid of no longer necessary stuff, such as a product's temporary home (packaging). Considering it has such a short life, it makes little sense to invest a lot of resources into packaging as a startup, unless you're selling electronics, where at least some consumers have a habit of saving the packaging materials to increase resale value of the product when they decide to upgrade.
So yeah, a company could package very simply, in an environmentally sound manner, and still make the unwrapping itself a positive aesthetic experience, rather than just an inconvenience on the way to using the product.
Apple could do that as well. They probably will do that, if they start seeing a more positive RoI in simple rather than elaborate packaging. But they'll still do it with the same obvious attention to detail.
So I should have been more clear... it's not non-luxury packaging that makes me distrust a maker. It's careless packaging, or packaging where the attention to detail is clearly focused on reducing cost (or worse, theft) rather than my experience as a consumer.
The packaging has a customer. Who's the customer? The end user, or the accountants?
When do you perceive that Apple decided to become the kind of brand that focused on its packaging? Because I'm going to say I think Apple have ALWAYS had a weird interest in packaging. You go back to the Mac Plus, it shipped in a glossy white box with full four-color printing on the sides showing a happy mac and a huge Apple logo, with all the components beautifully subpackaged up inside. That was not the norm in the 1980s (I've still got, for example, an Atari ST in its original box and it was matte white with blue printing all over, mostly shipping codes and handle with care signage).
This is a company which, remember, had the signatures of every designer of the original mac molded onto the inside surface of the case.
PS - Did you read the whole article? They're agreeing with you.
I find it more satisfying when you free a cleverly suspended gadget from an anti-static bag suspended in a molded/origami fiberboard nest. Easily disposed of, light, unobtrusive, recyclable (and possible for mere mortals to re-assemble if RMA is ever required, heaven forbid)
Of course Apple devices never need to be sent returned so maybe that isn't a concern.
Focusing on a great user experience includes focusing on the packaging. The experience should be totally seamless. For an upscale/luxury consumer goods company (like Apple), shoddy packaging is expensive - far more expensive than the luxury packaging whose costs the author decries. If I want a mediocre experience, I'll go to HP or Asus or something. A continuously delightful user experience buys customer loyalty. The thoughtfulness of good packaging engenders trust.
If I see bad packaging, I trust the the attention to detail less for the company that made the product. If they don't care about the box, they won't care about the buttons, or the software, or the color correctness, or any of the thousands of other details that make a consumer product. Then I stop shopping for quality, and start shopping for a price point and feature list.
When Apple argues that they have the best products in the world, they can point right to their packaging - they have the best packaging in the world. Best in every way.
Is this good logic for a startup? Of course not! No startup has Apple's resources. A startup has to focus on ONE thing. But Apple has to focus on ALL things.