Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014)
by baddox on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:46PM
(#9214624)
I can make a similar argumentum ad absurdum, but on the other side. I don't like chocolate ice cream. I never eat it anyway, so I have absolutely no problem with it being banned.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014)
by CalRobert on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @07:49AM
(#9217308)
When chocolate ice cream kills over 30,000 innocent people a year in the US, and about half a million around the world, every single year, that will become a valid argument. The point is that huge, heavy, and fast metal machines should not be permitted to operate in cities without substantially greater restriction.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014)
by 6t6t6 on Monday March 16, 2015 @10:05PM
(#9215851)
The fact that you eat chocolate ice cream doesn't affect my health, only yours.
The fact that you drive a car affects the health of everyone living in the city, takes a huge amount of public space, and makes cities ugly and less habitable.
I guess you can understand the difference.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014)
by baddox on Monday March 16, 2015 @10:13PM
(#9215878)
I understand the difference, but the argument I'm criticizing is insufficient.
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014)
by 6t6t6 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:59AM
(#9216626)
Do you use to down-vote opinions that differ from yours?
Re:Can a city really ban cars from its streets? (2014)
by easytiger on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @04:29AM
(#9224233)
What about the people who live in a city but regularly need access to a rural area to visit relatives. At least in the UK mobility in the rural areas is effectively impossible without a car. If one has a life entirely in the city there is no option but to own a car in the city, say London, and use it to traverse the city to get out.
In London at least, during a normal working day 95%+ of traffic is commercial in nature. You can't stop that kind of traffic without stopping the ability of the city from functioning.
Cars are awesome - they really are! So are helicopters. That doesn't mean one should have to drive a car just to buy a quart of milk.