News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What you wanted to know about AI by AndrewKemendo on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:38PM (#9213362)
Could you argue against the position directly?

No I can't because there isn't a way to argue it. I can't argue that it would be safe because I have nothing to point to that says it will be or even could be. We simply do not know enough about how it would be built to reason on it.

It's not within the scope of the quoted works to elaborate a technical roadmap or provide firm dates for the arrival of superhuman machine intelligence.

Correct, but they don't even reference a technical road map because there isn't one. It's too early to tell.

Do you have any points regarding this particular difference of opinion?

Not really, other than my own opinions which are as baseless as the others. I mean I have my own opinions and thoughts on things but they aren't empirically based at all, which is my main contention. We can't reason, let alone start making policy on stuff that we haven't the slightest idea how to build.

Re:What you wanted to know about AI by maaku on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:15PM (#9214065)
Well, color me disappointed. I think there are many arguments against the viewpoints of MIRI and Bostrom, both discrediting the perceived risk of super-intelligences and the the idea that we could build a "provably friendly" alternative.

But I don't think it's at all a fair criticism to say that you need a technical roadmap to engage in that debate. I would rather say that they need to be willing to discuss specific architectural details in order to even sit at the table, sure. The field of "AI safety" needs more engineering and less philosophy. But that doesn't require unity around a single roadmap, or any concept of deliverable dates.

Re:What you wanted to know about AI by AndrewKemendo on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:01PM (#9214364)
I would rather say that they need to be willing to discuss specific architectural details in order to even sit at the table, sure.

We are in violent agreement then. When I say roadmap I certainly don't intend to mean that each step needs to be perfectly detailed.

The field of "AI safety" needs more engineering and less philosophy. But that doesn't require unity around a single roadmap, or any concept of deliverable dates.

Exactly exactly and well said! That is 100% the point. Mind meld complete.

Re:What you wanted to know about AI by maaku on Monday March 16, 2015 @06:13PM (#9214815)
Awesome :)
Re:What you wanted to know about AI by rl3 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @06:03AM (#9217054)
>The field of "AI safety" needs more engineering and less philosophy.

An alternate phrasing might state that it needs more philosophy and an even greater amount of engineering.

If the field is in its infancy from a technical standpoint, then it probably is from a philosophical one as well.

Re:What you wanted to know about AI by maaku on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @11:35AM (#9218626)
No the philosophical musings have proven to be worse than a distraction IMHO.