News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by vertex-four on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:52PM (#9208999)
> Rentals are for a limited time by definition.

I know people (in fact, every branch of my family, along with many of my friends) who have rented their entire lives, because they can't own - they've never been able to amass enough capital or convince someone else to lend them it. Should they be uprooted every year (or more often) because someone wants to make a bit more money?

Rentals are whatever the combination of the contract and the local law say they are, by definition.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by mod on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:58PM (#9209024)
> Should they be uprooted every year (or more often) because someone wants to make a bit more money?

No, they shouldn't be, but that's not really the issue. The issue is: should landlords be legally allowed to uproot them?

My answer is a decisive yes. For whatever the reason, they should be able to not renew a contract once it expires.

I don't see why laws should be in place to restrict how much someone makes. Nobody has to have that particular apartment, or live in that particular place, etc. There's always options.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by vertex-four on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:03PM (#9209052)
> No, they shouldn't be, but that's not really the issue.

Yes, it really is. Which does the most harm - uprooting people and families every year, forcing them to deal with the stress of moving and finding new life patterns which match wherever they live now, or disallowing landlords from making a bit more money?

EDIT: s/allowing/disallowing/

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by mod on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:11PM (#9209091)
I guess you mean "disallowing landlords to make more money."

Again I think that's a red herring. There are plenty of reasons an owner might want to remove a tenant outside of profit. But again, it's not the issue--this is really straight to the heart of property rights.

Someone owns a property, and by and large, should be able to do what they want with that property.

Living on someone else's property is part of the risk of renting. Similar to working for someone else--would you also argue an employer should have to keep paying a worker who is underperforming (or any of a litany of legitimate reasons), because if they didn't that worker might have to deal with the stress of moving & finding new life patterns?

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by vertex-four on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:16PM (#9209114)
Property rights only exist because of the law, otherwise, in general, property amounts to "what you can personally protect from people using force". It makes sense that alternate property models from "full ownership" can be implemented without the world crumbling.

As I say in another comment, when you rent out a house to a tenant, you already lose certain property rights, at least while the tenant is living there. You can't write a contract which allows you to keep them, by law. You usually even have certain duties to the tenant, as much as landlords like to shirk these. This is the same in many developed countries, and the world's yet to fall apart for it.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by comex on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:44PM (#9209242)
In many countries it's quite difficult for an employer to fire a worker, and if they do, they have to provide some financial support to help them, as you say, move and find new life patterns. I do not live in one of those countries, so I cannot vouch for the advantages and disadvantages of this system, but it's hardly unthinkable.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by Kalium on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:34PM (#9209447)
Ah, but the most harm to who? There are more people affected here than just the landlord and the tenant.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by kelnos on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:33PM (#9209666)
My answer is a decisive yes. For whatever the reason, they should be able to not renew a contract once it expires.

And therein lies some of the disconnect: my answer is a decisive no. I think there are some reasons for which a landlord should be able to kick out a tenant, but I do not believe that any reason will suffice.

And that's why we have (imperfect) laws such as the Ellis Act, and a raft of other things that protect tenants from capricious, rent-seeking landlords.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by cookiecaper on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:00PM (#9209033)
>Should they be uprooted every year (or more often) because someone wants to make a bit more money?

If they are living on someone else's property, and that person wishes to sell the property, and the lease and any other contractual or statutory guarantees have lapsed, then yes? This is really not a new thing. You can't do away with property ownership as a concept just because San Francisco is ridiculous.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by vertex-four on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:08PM (#9209077)
Property ownership is an abstract concept enforced by law in the first place. There are theoretical economic models which do away with it to varying extents, or implement alternative ownership models. Why is it so mind-boggling to modify how it works in one specific instance?

Actually, almost everywhere, when you have a tenant, you lose some ownership rights already, by law. For example, except in an emergency, you generally can't enter the building without prior notice.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by cookiecaper on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:09AM (#9210349)
The issue is not that acquiring a tenant restricts some rights that the owner would otherwise have; this is a compromise that the landlord knowingly makes when he rents. That control is relinquished for a pre-agreed, limited period of time, after which control will be returned to the owner, is the essence of renting. The issue is that some people seem to believe that once they are on someone's property, that person loses the future ability to determine how that property is used; i.e., it's not that they have to wait until the current contract expires, but rather that you seem to be arguing that the landlord should never be able to remove a tenant from his property if the tenant does not consent, even at points when the lease on the property has lapsed. That's a permanent deprivation of the core of ownership -- the ability to determine and direct the utilization or exploitation of the property, even if you have to fill existing contractual obligations first, like an active lease.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by simoncion on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:38AM (#9210551)
> The issue is that some people seem to believe that once they are on someone's property, that person loses the future ability to determine how that property is used...

Here's the thing, though. It's not as if existing rent control regulation catches landlords by surprise. If a prospective landlord is so unprepared as to be unaware of the rent control status of a property that he's planning on purchasing, then he's likely to do very poorly with pretty much all of the tasks that being a landlord requires of him.

In short, the fact that landlords rent out rent-controlled units is proof positive that they understand and accept the restraints imposed on them by rent control regulations. The fact that rent controlled apartments continue to be rented in SF (rather than withdrawn from the market for five years and converted into condos, as the law allows) is proof that rent control is not draining the lifeblood out of landlords.

The insane rents in SF are not due to rent control (how could they be?), but due to the pathological lack of new residential construction.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by cookiecaper on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:01PM (#9213105)
Rent control doesn't grant tenants a permanent interest in the property, even if some rent control regulations make it annoying and/or arduous to remove tenants. The person I replied to suggested that landlords should be required to let their tenants stay in their property eternally if the tenant so chose, i.e., that tenants should have permanent control of the property.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by candu on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:16PM (#9209367)
You absolutely can alter the concept of property ownership; to think otherwise is a failure of imagination, historical perspective, or both. (For instance: who owned the land under the buildings at 8th and Market three million years ago? What would an early Christian think of our complex system of interest-bearing loans? Have you ever read any sci-fi novels depicting societies in which property rights took fundamentally different forms? Should landlords be allowed to kill or enslave tenants if that would increase their profits? What if the government knocks on your door and claims eminent domain? And so on.)

Whether you should do so is another question, one to which I don't have the answer.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by kelnos on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:39PM (#9209687)
I think your view of property ownership is a bit out of touch with reality. It's pretty rare that having a deed to a piece of land lets you do whatever you want with it. Or even close to whatever you want.