News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by brandonbloom on Sunday March 15, 2015 @08:51PM (#9208996)
Rent control does not force landlords to keep renters ad infinitum. It protects tenants from price gouging. Landlords can impose rent increases far beyond fair market rents for new tenants because it's costly and inconvenient to move, but (in a sellers' market) cheap to replace tenants. This imbalance of negotiating power necessitates regulations.

Now, you can argue that particular rent control laws are too aggressive, or that the strategy for calculating bounds on rent increases cause excessive opportunity losses. But that's a far cry from the implication of your message.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by orangecat on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:28PM (#9209180)
Landlords can impose rent increases far beyond fair market rents for new tenants because it's costly and inconvenient to move, but (in a sellers' market) cheap to replace tenants.

The market rent is exactly what other potential tenants are willing to pay.

Now, you can argue that particular rent control laws are too aggressive, or that the strategy for calculating bounds on rent increases cause excessive opportunity losses.

Or that the inability to charge market prices causes property owners to refuse to rent in the first place, thereby making housing problems even worse.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by wpietri on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:09PM (#9209333)
> The market rent is exactly what other potential tenants are willing to pay.

You're not understanding the scam. Suppose you move in to a place and pay the then-market rent of $1000 a month. Let's further suppose that it cost you $2400 to move, plus a shitload of time and effort that you'd rather not repeat. If the next year the market price remains $1000/month, the landlord can still raise the rent on you because you'll be reluctant (and possibly unable) to pay moving costs again. The exact amount they can get away with depends on personal tolerance and your time value for money, but given how much moving sucks, in practice it's quite a bit.

> Or that the inability to charge market prices causes property owners to refuse to rent in the first place, thereby making housing problems even worse.

That is definitely a negative side effect, but not a huge one in practice. How many apartments can one person use? Who would really let an apartment building stand empty when you could be charging market rent? In San Francisco, pretty much nobody.

A bigger problem is that it might reduce the supply of new apartments. But that's also not a problem in SF because any building built after rent control was passed is not under rent control.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by andylei on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:28PM (#9209420)
> Suppose you move in to a place and pay the then-market rent of $1000 a month. Let's further suppose that it cost you $2400 to move, plus a shitload of time and effort that you'd rather not repeat. If the next year the market price remains $1000/month, the landlord can still raise the rent on you because you'll be reluctant (and possibly unable) to pay moving costs again

many cities do not have rent control. the city i live in is one such city. the scenario you're describing does not happen here.

if an owner decides to raise rent above market, now that owner is faced with the possibility of not being able to rent out that space, because now they are renting above market price. even just 1 month of vacancy is already lost revenue that would often dwarf the potential gain of raising the rent.

owners also have costs too. when someone moves out, they have to pay to have the apartment repainted, listed, and brokered.

this is not the reason rent control exists. rent control exists because SF wants to keep prices low without building more housing, making life miserable for everyone.

> A bigger problem is that it might reduce the supply of new apartments. But that's also not a problem in SF

because the city continually refuses to allow new housing developments to be built.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by simoncion on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:13AM (#9210489)
> many cities do not have rent control. the city i live in is one such city. the scenario you're describing does not happen here.

Because -as you mention at the end of the comment- your city builds new housing to meet demand. Rent Control was enacted BECAUSE landlords were raising rents to absurd levels in cities that (for a variety of disgusting reasons) found themselves incapable of building new housing to meet demand. :)

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by randallsquared on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:44PM (#9209487)
> The exact amount they can get away with depends on personal tolerance and your time value for money, but given how much moving sucks, in practice it's quite a bit.

It is my experience, as you say, that rent tends to increase by a small amount each year, usually about 2%. Even people on fixed incomes tend to get cost of living adjustments, though, and the range is about the same as typical rent increases.

I do not see rents increasing by the amounts you suggest, which suggests that either all landlords since I started renting in 1991 have been leaving money on the table, or they can't actually do this reliably.

I think there are several reasons why they can't raise rents by 10% a year in order to keep people there, even though that extra money would be about what it costs to move:

Since the money it would cost to move grows only at inflation, by the second or third year it would suddenly be profitable to move, even for renters who really hated moving. In order to avoid this, landlords would have to apply the rise only once. But if they do this, then the market rate is just the higher one, and you could look at the initial lower rate as a promotion. In fact, this is quite common in rental advertising! Often it comes in the form of "first month free", which is about of the same scale.

More importantly, people who rent probably do not expect to stay in the same house or apartment for many years. In non-rent-controlled areas, rent is more expensive per month than buying the same sort of place, so if you intend to stay in the same location for more than a few years, there's no reason not to buy. As a renter, I've never lived in the same dwelling for more than three years, and when I move somewhere, I assume that I'll be moving again in a year or two, as conditions change (job, relationships, etc).

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by brandonbloom on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:59PM (#9209535)
I just moved out of a non-rent-controlled 1 bedroom in NYC, where my landlord wanted to raise the rent from $2550 to $3100 per month. I've spoken with the new tenant, who moved in at a rate of $2400 per month. I turned in my keys on Friday, they painted the apartment on Saturday, and the new tenant moved in on Sunday. Despite this being February, they rented the place so fast that the second half of the month was paid for twice.

The dollar and timeline figures here tells me one of two things:

1) they wanted to get rid of me, particularly, or...

2) they took a calculated risk based on their experience managing a great number of units

I'd bet heavily on #2, since this is a pretty typical story in NYC.

They tried to raise the rent 22% to something 29% above market rate. They weren't able to get anything close to that rate for a new tenant. They will pull the same crap on this tenant next year too.

> More importantly, people who rent probably do not expect to stay in the same house or apartment for many years.

This is patently false.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by simoncion on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:17AM (#9210499)
> In non-rent-controlled areas, rent is more expensive per month than buying the same sort of place...

Federal intervention has seriously distorted the home buying market with a variety of subsidies and tax writeoffs. Without this assistance, it would likely be substantially more expensive to buy than rent.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by TheCondor on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:54PM (#9209517)
That scam isn't that common or the reasoning for these laws. Let's just assume that most renters and most landlords are fair actors. Sure they both want a better deal but most landlords don't try to factor moving costs in to the equation. Fact of the matter, and I own rental properties, you generally want to keep great renters, at least in our market, want to keep them almost to the point of not raising rent to risk losing them
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by brandonbloom on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:00PM (#9209550)
> Let's just assume that most renters and most landlords are fair actors.

That's an insane assumption. Most landlords are companies which, if human, would be considered sociopaths.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by cc439 on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:06PM (#9209575)
That would be an insane decision on the part of the landlord though. An increase in price is either tolerable or intolerable. If the tenant is willing to pay an additional $1,000 a month, that's the new market price. If the tenant is willing to move, the landlord loses out on $500-2,000 as it takes time to bring in a new renter in even the hottest market.

The total loss of income is enough incentive for the landlord to keep rent increases reasonable. If your example held true, there would be violence in the streets across the globe but there aren't. The incentives keep increases in check in markets less insane than those in San Francisco and California at large. The policies of that city and state are the largest differentiator between them and areas with healthy markets/ Maybe we should be looking at policy beyond the veil of partisan rhetoric?

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by brandonbloom on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:08PM (#9209584)
> If the tenant is willing to pay an additional $1,000 a month, that's the new market price.

That is incorrect. That is the new price of that unit for that tenant, as if it were a market of size 1. A similar unit on the market would rent for a different rate paid by similar tenants in the market.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by agorabinary on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:04PM (#9209056)
Property owners took a risk by purchasing property, just as anyone does purchasing shares of a public company for instance. The value of your asset can go up and you find yourself in an advantageous position (a seller's market as you put it), or prices can fall and recurring buyers (like renters) are at the advantage. Rent control only distorts the market and is unfair to everyone.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by brandonbloom on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:14PM (#9209106)
1) Landlords can diversify their properties, renters only get one. Everyone needs to live somewhere, nobody needs to be a landlord.

2) You've missed my point about moving costs. Even when the market favors renters, the lease renewal negotiation favors landlords. This is because moving costs time and money payable to third parties. As a result, the landlord can charge higher rents for renewals than they can for new leases.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by tizzdogg on Monday March 16, 2015 @02:39AM (#9210173)
I actually know a few homeowners in San Francisco in this situation right now. They have extra units in their building (which is also where they live), and choose to leave it vacant rather than deal with the hassle of rent control. They do not need the income and would rather not bother with possibly getting a tenant who never leaves. It's not economically rational, but people are not always rational, especially when dealing with their homes.

The building I live in is also in the situation currently where a unit is being left vacant in anticipation of a condo conversion in a couple years.. San Francisco has a very complicated condo conversion law but part of it is that during conversion some existing tenants have to be offered lifetime leases which can never be increased. Leaving units vacant is a rational way of dealing with that.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by simoncion on Monday March 16, 2015 @05:25AM (#9210513)
> They have extra units in their building (which is also where they live), and choose to leave it vacant rather than deal with the hassle of rent control.

Good for them. Better that they do this than take the rental income, and later whine about how terribly unfair renter protection laws are. :)

Based on my immensely scientific[0] survey of Internet Message Boards (and personal experience in the American Southeast), it seems that potential landlords sometimes forget that when they rent their property to others for use as the renters' home, the landlord loses almost all control over that property. This is right and just: everyone deserves a safe, secure, private place to live.

> Leaving units vacant is a rational way of dealing with SF's condo conversion laws.

Again, it's good for the landlords that they showed this much restraint.

The condo conversion laws prevent landlords from turning their apartment stock (that pays off smaller amounts over time) into condo stock (that pays off one large lump sum). These are sane and rational laws to have in cities that (for a variety of disgusting reasons) find themselves unable to create sufficient housing to meet demand.

[0] Ha!

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by tizzdogg on Monday March 16, 2015 @04:39PM (#9214239)
The problem with leaving units vacant though is it takes those units off the market, driving rents up for the remaining units. That is the end result of overly aggressive rent control, and one of the big problems in San francisco right now.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by clarky07 on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:32PM (#9209194)
1 - first, so what? second, nobody needs to live "there". They can move to a different rental.

2 - moving isn't "that" expensive. It's a pain in the ass, but you can do it in a weekend with a few hundred dollar moving truck. You might be able to raise rates a few percent, but you can't just move them significantly above market.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by wpietri on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:22PM (#9209392)
> It's a pain in the ass, but you can do it in a weekend with a few hundred dollar moving truck.

Let me guess: no kids, haven't lived in your place very long, don't know your neighbors, don't have family nearby, don't live in a city with substantial pressure on housing, and you make over the median income.

> You might be able to raise rates a few percent, but you can't just move them significantly above market.

That you can't imagine something doesn't always mean it's not possible. It can mean the world is more complex than you expect.

I'm glad that you have such an easy and comfortable life that moving is no big deal, but that's just not true for everyone on the planet.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by clarky07 on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:17PM (#9215484)
Let's see. I moved last summer, from a place I lived in for seven years. Check. I'm married, kid on the way, I knew my neighbors, and I have family nearby. You were so close. (I do make over the median income, so you did get that one.)

If your landlord raises their rates to double the market value, move. If you don't, that just means you're doing it wrong.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by wpietri on Monday March 16, 2015 @08:38PM (#9215558)
So you're telling me that in one weekend with one truck, you packed everything for a family, moved it, unpacked it, and had total expenses of a few hundred bucks? Congrats on being a minimalist. When I see most people do it, though, they take a couple of months of spare time to prep and months more to get everything situated and recover.

Yes, sure, if the rent is doubled, one should probably move despite the hassle. But the point is that landlords can take advantage of the asymmetry in cost/difficulty of changing places to hike rents. Nobody would move because the landlord was charging them $1/yr above what they could pay elsewhere. Most would move if it were double. The landlord's advantage is somewhere in between.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by jackmaney on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:24PM (#9209402)
> moving isn't "that" expensive. It's a pain in the ass, but you can do it in a weekend with a few hundred dollar moving truck

Care to show me a single company that would allow me to rent a truck for a cross country move for less than four hundred dollars?

Go ahead. Take your time.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by joeclark77 on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:34PM (#9209446)
Isn't this guy getting his $12,500 security deposit returned? I think that would set you up pretty well with a U-Haul and gas.
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by jackmaney on Sunday March 15, 2015 @10:57PM (#9209532)
What makes you think that the landlord wouldn't find a "reason" to keep the deposit?
Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by kelnos on Sunday March 15, 2015 @11:06PM (#9209576)
Most people don't have $12,500 sitting around in the bank, or often even enough to rent a truck for the weekend. Some people work multiple jobs and can't even carve out a full day to move houses. Some people aren't in the best physical health (due to age or disability) and cannot actually move their own stuff.

You've described the typical SF tech worker and decided that everyone is like that. Might want to broaden your horizons a bit.

Regardless, you don't get the security deposit back until a few weeks after you've moved out. Never seen a truck rental or moving company who is all like "sure, you can pay us in a month". A bit of a chicken-and-egg problem, there.

Re:“Your monthly rent .. shall increase from $2145 to $8900” by nsxwolf on Sunday March 15, 2015 @09:29PM (#9209182)
I need to be a landlord because my other mortgage is so far underwater I could either foreclose and not be able to buy a suitable place for my family, or be a landlord and be able to pay both mortgages. It seems there would be people around to criticize me no matter which option I chose.