News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by chollida1 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:45AM (#9191473)
I've spent more than a few words bashing Flash boys so I won't try to do it anymore.

In a way I feel kind of bad for Michael Lewis. He's had such success with earlier books that it must be hard for him to find a target for each new book. In my opinion this book was his first awful book.

Instead of finding data and following it through to reach a conclusion he starts with a trendy conclusion, HFT is bad, and then really contorts and reaches with his data to try and make his case. He was also hit by the issue of HFT starting to wind down around 2010 and really starting to wind down around 2012. Many HFT firms no longer concentrate on the US Equity markets alone, they do alot more volume in the futures, options and bond markets where there are alot more mathematical correlations, and hence more opportunities for mispricings to correct.

If you want a sound rebuttal, and in my opinion a better book have a look at this book:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8577237

I find it more balanced, better researched and it provides a much better understanding of the HFT industry.

Having said that, credit where credit is due, he's a tremendous writer and the book is a fun read that you can consume in 2 days. If you like it then I recommend his entire back catalog, they are all fun and informative reads.

EDIT someone asked for an example of why I didn't like the book so....

One of Lewis' biggest issues was what he termed HFT front running. This alone was a pain as front running already had a well understood meaning( it originally was meant for a intermediary who took your order and executed its own order ahead of yours, often buying the stock lower and selling it to you at a slightly higher price).

His example was that a HFT system would see an order for say Microsoft trade on the exchange BATS, say a buy of 1000 shares. The HFT system would then run ahead to all the other exchanges and buy up the remaining shares on those other exchanges, an ammount that might be 1000 shares or it might be 100,000 shares, so when the remaining part of the order to buy Microsoft got to those exchanges it would have to buy the shares from eh faster HFT system at a higher price.

This is down right silly for a few reasons.

1) it assumes that the order that got filled at BATS was either a market order or a limit order that was priced for more than the fill price, because if it was a limit for the same price as the fill then buying up the remaining shares won't do the HFT firm any good:)

2) it assumes that the order was for more shares than what got filled on BATS, so now the HFT firm is exposing itself by owning shares it's not even sure anyone wants to buy at the price its willing to sell.

3) it assumes that the HFT system can both buy the remaining shares at the original price and get to the top of sell side of the order book to sell those shares back. The HFt firm now has to take the risk that it won't be at the top of the order book and even if it was right about steps one and two, a big if, it might not be able to capitalize on it as it can't jump ahead of anyone who had previous sell limit orders at the price it now wants to sell at.

There are just so many unknown factors there that there is almost no way this type of trading system could be profitable.

Remember HFT firms worship at the alter of the law of large numbers, they make fractions of a penny per share traded but only do it if they have an edge ie 90% upside to 10% downside. There just isn't any edge to be had in the above scenario, its just a heaping pile of risk.

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by kasey_junk on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:57AM (#9191547)
The problem I had with it, is it was the first time he's written about an industry that I knew about and it shook my confidence in all of his other writing.

If he got HFT so very wrong in Flashboys, what does that mean for Moneyball or The Big Short?

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by patio11 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:12PM (#9191680)
This thought generalizes (terror-inducingly) to the whole media. "A pity they're totally nincompoops when it comes to tech but at least they've got politics, crime, and the economy sor... oh dear."

(Think pg had an observation like this once.)

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by everly on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:21PM (#9191769)
"When the press writes about a topic you know well, you realize every news article you've read could have been equally mistaken." -pg
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by kasey_junk on Thursday March 12, 2015 @07:47PM (#9194802)
I think what made it particular bothersome in this case is how easy the HFT narrative fits with his standard template, but in the opposite way than he wrote it.

He could of easily written the "smart guys take on the rich insiders" using the HTF folks as the heroes. Plus, I felt the narrative suffered because of all the convolutions he had to do to make the millionaire trader bros at IEX meet that template.

Further, I doubt you'd find a more Moneyball loving population sample than at HFT shops.

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by gd1 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:16PM (#9191712)
I think there is a name for this effect (and a wikipedia page). I've forgotten what it is called though.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by patio11 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:20PM (#9191761)
Murray Gell-Mann Effect maybe? Been a few years, can't remember if I have the order right.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by kbenson on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:23PM (#9191791)
That's it (usually written Gell-Mann effect I believe), but it actually describes the cognitive dissonance of ignoring that feeling when reading other non-domain stories, so it's the opposite.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by aptwebapps on Friday March 13, 2015 @02:24AM (#9195873)
The Gell-Mann Amnesia effect, coined by Michael Crichton.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by kbenson on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:16PM (#9191724)
I seem to recall there's a term for this, but I can't remember the actual name.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by vasilipupkin on Thursday March 12, 2015 @01:55PM (#9192514)
Well, just because he got A wrong, doesn't mean he also got B and C wrong. HFT is very complicated AND secretive. In all seriousness, it's unlikely someone can understand it well without working in the industry
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by patio11 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:07PM (#9191635)
The referenced book was fantastic.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by devingoldfish on Thursday March 12, 2015 @01:03PM (#9192139)
Ah so in your view, why was the order flow of retail brokerages worth hundreds of millions of dollars per year to these HFT firms?

Michael Lewis is not the only person accusing HFT firms of front-running trades. Joseph Stiglitz, a nobel laureate in economics, has made similar accusations. Does he too just not understand the market?

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by patio11 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @01:41PM (#9192417)
why was the order flow of retail brokerages worth hundreds of millions of dollars per year to these HFT firms?

Order flow from retail brokerages can be assumed to be "non-directional", which means that it comes from people who are buying or selling for some reason other than "I have better-than-market knowledge of information which will shortly be relevant to this stock."

One extremely important example of directional order flow is when you have the knowledge "100k shares of this stock are shortly going to be shopped on various exchanges" because you're doing the selling. This will typically cause price impact (i.e. the price of the stock declines), meaning that market makers who take your first few hundred/thousand shares are going to get shellacked. They generally don't love this.

In the (virtually guaranteed) absence of directional order flow, market making is a license to print money. Both sides pay you the spread and you don't accumulate much inventory risk. (i.e. You buy, you sell, you sell, you buy, and you're rarely left with a meaningfully sized position in either direction which would expose you to the stock at issue.)

That's why you pay for non-directional order flow. It's like leasing a toll bridge.

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by harryh on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:39PM (#9192823)
It does seem like the fee being paid for order flow should be able to be captured by those making the orders in the form of further reduced spreads rather than by brokerage firms selling the flow. Though perhaps the issue is that with stocks regulated to trade in penny increments that's hard to do?

I am uncertain.

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by kasey_junk on Thursday March 12, 2015 @07:52PM (#9194822)
The spreads can't reduce much more than they are now due to the regulation issue.

The order makers do see part of that rebate in the lowering of the fees they explicitly pay to trade.

Robinhood is a particularly good example of this. They seem to be financing a no-fee model based purely on selling the order flow.

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by evanpw on Thursday March 12, 2015 @01:43PM (#9192432)
I think you're confusing two different issues. If a retail customer's order is actually sent to an internalizing firm, then trading ahead of it would be _actual_ front-running, is already illegal [1], and is taken very seriously by the regulators.

What Lewis _calls_ front-running in his book is something completely different, and involves reacting quickly to public information rather than misappropriating private information.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manning_rule

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by RickHull on Thursday March 12, 2015 @01:32PM (#9192353)
Stiglitz hates private markets. He always pushes for a larger public sector, praising the Venezuelan approach.

https://www.google.com/search?q=stiglitz+venezuela

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by fuzzywalrus on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:19PM (#9191753)
"conclusion he starts with a trendy conclusion, HFT is bad"

I tried finding the Amazon review linked but didn't see it. While it seems that Lewis has a distorted view, there still hasn't been a compelling reason for HFT other than the exploit the edge cases and loopholes of the current system.

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by toast0 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @01:25PM (#9192302)
Automated trading has reduced bid/ask spreads significantly (usually to the regulated minimum of one cent for popular issues). This is a compelling benefit for individual investors.

It has negatively impacted investors doing large trades, but those investors generally have more tools at their disposal to break their trades into smaller groups, or whatever. The major example impact I've heard is that the larger investors can't look at the order books at all the markets, and issue one order (to one exchange?) and take all the orders.

It seems that the automated players are duplicating their orders at multiple exchanges, and removing or replacing orders at other exchanges when one fills. A simple solution would be for the large investor to send individual orders to each exchange, and pace them so they arrive simultaneously at each exchange (instead of sending them simultaneously); of course, if you do that often enough, automated traders will probably put out smaller orders or do less duplication.

Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by harryh on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:22PM (#9191778)
Automated trading has reduced trading costs hugely. You're flat out wrong.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by kbenson on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:28PM (#9191822)
Doesn't it also add liquidity to the market? With many trades happening when the price fluctuates by fractions of a cent, doesn't that hone the market to a more accurate value quicker? Not to ignore the downsides, but my understanding is that there are known upsides.
Re:Flash Boys a Year Later by mmodahl on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:34PM (#9191880)
Unemployed cab drivers are the only ones arguing self-driving cars are bad.