The advice makes sense for the rich as well as the poor.
Until your first layoff. Then it's an absolute blessing to live somewhere where your next job is one more exit up 101.
This is the thing that everybody who works in tech forgets. If you live in Pittsburgh, Tulsa, or Lubbock, you are in for a many month job search--or you are leaving the city--when (not if) you get laid off.
Seagate had this problem a couple years ago. They wanted VLSI layout people in Pittsburgh and were offering comparable to Silicon Valley money--and nobody from the tech cities would bite. Why? Everybody knew that they were going to be the most highly paid people in the office and subject to getting axed first. And would then have to move back to Silicon Valley.
The Bay Area is not the only place with a high amount of tech jobs. Sure it may have the most but there's many other cities with plenty of openings.
Searching "software engineer" job listings on LinkedIn[1] shows:
San Francisco (12,676)
New York City (6,619)
Washington D.C. Metro (5,613)
Seattle (4,584)
Boston (4,452)
Chicago (3,933)
Los Angeles (3,135)
[1] https://www.linkedin.com/job/software-engineer-jobs/There are many houses on the market that fail or pass "rent vs buy" calculators - savings can go into diverse sources instead of a property if you so choose.
I'm of the opinion that the overall package is "worth it" here, but each person should consider their own evaluation metrics - and yes, move if you don't think it's worth it.
Note: this is certainly off-topic from the troubles of extremely poor people in this area.
I'm hoping to be able to save ~$240k and buy a modest house on the outskirts of Portland or Tacoma and have a little left over.
I'm just wondering if there's anywhere else where I could save money like this?
That isn't how this works, at all. When the number of people who want to live in an area > the area's capacity, prices increase. See: every metro area in the world.
> Yeah, rich people get forced out of their homes because they can't afford them all the time. /s
Rich people move to optimize their finances all the time.
http://www.sfgate.com/business/networth/article/State-leader...
http://www.cbn.com/cbnnews/world/2014/February/Frances-Recko...
http://www.forbes.com/sites/dalebuss/2014/04/27/it-makes-sen...
http://www.aei.org/publication/companies-are-leaving-califor...
If rich people living around you only affected house prices then you'd be right, but they tend to push the cost of everything up. That's what drives poor people out.
It's like people think this situation is new, and poor people are the "real" natives of SV. If those damn facebooks and googles had left the valley alone everything would be great!
Actually, in some places (certain NYC or London neighborhoods), the rich are getting pushed out by the ultrarich. What chance does a mere millionaire have against billionaires?
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/02/19/h...
I'm not poor by any means, but if SF rents keep going up, I'm going to be leaving if I can't find affordable housing (even on a relatively high salary).
My point is that it might not be fair that low-income folks have to move when housing gets more expensive, but it doesn't stop with low-income. I'm sure plenty of middle-income folks have been forced out of the Bay area as well.
So if we want to outlaw rent control, we should outlaw fixed rate mortgages too, and eliminate the artificial cap on property taxes (something that corporations exploit by using shell companies to 'own' commercial real estate, and then transferring ownership or voting control of the shell company while shielding themselves from property tax on the current value of the real estate). But we both know that that's not likely to happen.
No. It began in SF as a very-specific response to Prop 13, which is essentially property-tax-control
Both are bad policies in terms of market distortion and are often the overlooked elephants in the room in discussion of housing supply and affordability.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_rent_control_in_Engl...
You just think poor people should have to move out of their homes because rich people decided they want to live there. Got it.
> The same argument applies to people of all socioeconomic background.
Yeah, rich people get forced out of their homes because they can't afford them all the time. /s