So it's basically vertical integration (exclusive manufacturing rights and retail presense) + economies of scale. They made themselves a very powerful intermediary and signed some very lucrative exclusive contracts to compound that advantage.
There are people taking advantage of this. Namely, Warby Parker.[1] They opened retail stores to combat Luxottica's market share in that arena, manufactured their own eyeglasses, and raised $41mm in funding to do so. They're growing rapidly, but still a relatively small part of the overall market. They originally were going to price their glasses at $50, but found that consumers branded their products as cheap so they artificially raised the price to $100! Still enough to undercut the competition, but shows you how the current market has skewed consumer perceptions of price/quality.
http://www.masoneyewear.com/buy-eyeglasses-online-purchase-g...
You have correctly identified Luxottica's value proposition: "You don't know how to get into eyewear, but we are experts on it. Partner with us!"
However, to even move the needle for Luxottica, that brand partnership has to be worth many millions of dollars.
Warby Parker is not competing against Luxottica. They are not trying to do white-label eyewear for other fashion brands. Warby is simply another fashion brand. They are competing with the other brands that Luxottica is making glasses for.
There is another company (which I used to work for, called Eponym, Inc.) who is a closer competitor to Luxottica in terms of trying to capture the market of fashion who want to get into eyewear. Though the success of selling glasses to individual customers is important, Luxottica is more of a B2B partnership whereas Warby is B2C.
It's being a 2 sided market,same like ebay - a meeting place between most brands and most consumers.And we know that those types of businesses are very tough to attack, and probably even more so offline.
In a way, similar to walmart, but luxury brands don't fight through lower prices, so it might enabled luxxotica to ask them not to sell lower at any other place. In a sense this luxxotica monopoly is great for luxury brands, so i could even imagine a scenario where luxxotica tells to each brand "we're building a monopoly on glasses in the u.s., and we want this place to be the ideal place to sell luxury goods ... , please help us" - why won't they help ?
So if you control the retail chain, you've got the monopoly.
They said their competition was walmart. And that they bought Oakley after refusing to stock their product.
"In 2013, French lens manufacturer Essilor purchased a majority stake in EyeBuyDirect": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EyeBuyDirect
"France’s Essilor International and Italy’s Luxottica Group, the two largest optical companies in the world, have ended merger talks that took place in secret over the past 18 months." http://www.insightnews.com.au/_blog/NEWS_NOW!/post/essilor-a...
Okay, competition's alive for now. How long will that last?
I'm SUPER satisfied with them and have been telling everyone I know to use them.
It's very difficult to find ones that are fitted exactly right and look the way you want. If you re-order exactly the same frame style and size as you've had previously, then you can do alright, but it's hard to get the same experience as with a physical store.
Also, people often put off getting new glasses until they have to, and it's convenient to get it all done in one shot.
Additionally, the business is still sitting on some convenient anti-competitive regulations that exist at the state level in most places.
Another big factor is insurance. Health insurance often covers enough of the cost of eye exams and glasses, people end up not caring how much it actually costs.
The fact that there are many places to buy glasses online but they still have a very limited marketshare is perhaps the best evidence that it's not really a comparable experience.
Offhand, it seems like this stuff isn't that difficult to make. After all, it's just frames made out of plastic, right? But it is at this point we get a glimpse into what it takes to manufacture products.
The basic design of glasses - like any accessory - is a skill in itself! We look at the shape, the materials, used, the colors, the hinges, the nose-pads, and the aesthetic of frames. Many of us can look at a pair of glasses and "know" that they are styled for men or women, and different frame shapes and colors are better suited for different face shapes and skin tones.
This is all to say that, even before we start manufacturing, one has to find talent who understands all of these aspects of accessory design in order to produce a great product. Parallels to software engineering suggest themselves.
When it comes to manufacturing, most all of it is done outside the US in China. Physical manufacturing is difficult. There is a years-long iterative process of choosing materials, manufacturing samples, working with the vendors, and ensuring quality. Maybe you are importing acetate from another country. Oh, and it is February - you planned for Chinese New Year, right? Import these frames into the US and let them sit in customs for a month. Etc. Physical manufacturing is hard.
What if you're making eyewear for another brand? Now you have to design things which are consistent with that brand's aesthetic.
Then you have to find an optical lab to fulfill prescriptions. A lab which is reliable, does not ship products with scratches on lenses, and has strong inventory controls. Optical labs, incidentally, are really expensive operations to run because the machinery is so specialized.
And then there is the shipping, logistics, and customer service pipeline.
At a unit level, it is true that glasses are pretty cheap to make. In that sense, because it is easy to get into the market - which is relatively unregulated compared to, say, payment processing - you deal with a lot of unscrupulous businesses and middlemen trying to peddle bad-quality goods.
Eyewear may have recurring customers, but perhaps not so much brand loyalty. Many customers want to physically try on frames before buying, which increases customer acquisition costs (either via home-try-on programs or physical showrooms.)
Companies like Luxottica, I have heard, sell their eyewear to mom-and-pop optometrists and use sales data to figure out the size of the market. Then they plop down with a Lens Crafters.
This is all to say... it is a difficult business, there are many competitors, it is hard to wade through the crap, it is hard to find good talent, and things like aesthetics and brand recognition are important - and take time to develop. Not as easy as it seems!
So, why is that?
PayPal seems like one, especially for international payments. iPhones and Androids. Windows. Cargill for food.
Granted, I am having trouble coming up with companies where "just one" company dominates the market, but overall this seems more common than one would like to think.
You are correct in that "it is difficult" would not be sufficient to explain why there are so few competitors. But I think I feel similarly about these other industries as well.
http://www.amazon.com/Cornered-Monopoly-Capitalism-Economics...
This seems like a particularly interesting case study, perhaps not fitting well into any particular ideological framework.
This problem is across every industry, but because of the way branding, shell corporations etc work people do not notice.
Ask yourself whether shoes is truly different? How many places around the globe produce a _lot_ of shoes?
How about hard drives? Refrigerators?
jbert said above: "people want to try on several pairs of glasses and see which ones they look best in." That seems like a very good reason that is different from any other industry.
Are they that good at taking advantage of positional goods and marketing? Are they litigious? Do they use kickbacks effectively? Are they buying out competition, and, if so, how are they doing it and why is new competition not emerging?
A situation like this appears to be a complete affront to nearly any economic model I can think of, and demands attention.
Additionally, we in the startup community should all be sitting around and thinking: "Wait, high margins, simple product and I can sell it online... Wait, what?"