We already know the NSA's power has been extensively abused with "SEXINT" (stealing people's private photos for personal enjoyment and likely blackmail), JTRIG (discrediting people not accused or suspected of any crime), PRISM (monitoring every communication via to/from data and other private data), not to mention others.
None of these things relate to foreign espionage or generalized signals intelligence. Snowden said it himself: the NSA is only about SIGINT in their press releases. Really, their purpose is social control and consolidation of power. Their spying does not stop at members of the public or foreign publics; whistleblower Russ Tice said long before Snowden that the NSA had a tap on Barack Obama as early as 2004.
I would just like to remind everyone that surveillance is about control, not security. Some may claim it's security through control, but that's not the social contract I was taught to understand my country worked under.
Source: https://youtu.be/d6m1XbWOfVk?t=2m45s
They went after General Patreus, Justice Alito and Senator Barack Obama [3:25].
So if someone, say Europe, became more powerful than the US they would be extremely corrupt. Where does that tautology leave us?
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/11/16/magazine/what-an-uncensore...
I agree, but there's no proof that the Equations Group/TAO were conducting operations without oversight, so I fail to see why this is a big deal. The fact that the oversight that DOES exist consists of rubber-stamping is the fault of either ineffective overseers or unscrupulous intelligence officers. It has no bearing on the people writing the exploits.
Those are absolutely real issues, but they don't apply to this case in any apparent way. I'm all for Intelligence reform but railing against the evils of the NSA when discussing a highly effective portion of its legitimate purpose just muddies the waters of the debate.
I'm not saying contractors are hives of abuse or anything, just that if there is abuse, it seems far more likely to happen there.
I'd also say the more senior the position, government or not, the more likely they are to be able to get away with it.
Most worrisome are the well-connected people who sit at the intersection of state and corporate power. For example, former intelligence officials who frequent the revolving door and take high-level executive positions at major contractors. These are people you wouldn't want to cross.
Another thing I've gleaned is that Mallory spends incredible amounts of money to undermine the stability and security of our internet & hardware. We cannot compete with them on that level; we don't have the means to stabilize as quickly as they destabilize.
I actually want to know if anyone has any ideas about what to do in this reality. What do you do when constructive and legal means both fail? Seems like Mallory can get away with anything.
As the NSA et al get more [unchecked] power it will become more corrupt, isn't this like, the law of nature?
People say "This is exactly what I want the NSA to do -- foreign espionage, just like always" -- Sure, there's past precedent for this being a good idea.
How far are you willing to take this? How much power should one [or small group] employee at the NSA have?
Right now, Right this very minute, I bet if [Employee X] wanted you silenced, it would happen, and no one would bat an eye. Is that the world you want to live in? What road are we taking?
No, we shouldn't stop all foreign espionage [anytime soon].
No, I don't want Employee X doing queries on oil activists for the purposes of muffling them.
My solution? Take them to court, and establish clear oversights. This is what keeps getting said.
EDIT: CIA changed to FBI/Hoover