News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by mhomde on Monday March 09, 2015 @01:31PM (#9172317)
Open Source, wow that was unexpected from Apple
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by duaneb on Monday March 09, 2015 @01:37PM (#9172358)
It's calculated. Reception would be distinctly negative if something as crucial as health research were closed source—here, the utility is in the transparency as well as apple's traditional offers of usability and reliability.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by a_c_s on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:48PM (#9172955)
What's the point about speculating about motivation? Whether motivated by altruism or calculated strategy, who cares?

These kinds of discussions tend to devolve into platform bickering rather than substantive commentary.

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by duaneb on Monday March 09, 2015 @05:40PM (#9174329)
> These kinds of discussions tend to devolve into platform bickering rather than substantive commentary.

True. However, occasionally (I at least) learn something new from these conversations.

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by Osmium on Monday March 09, 2015 @01:58PM (#9172522)
> Reception would be distinctly negative if something as crucial as health research were closed source

I don't know about that. HealthKit is essentially closed and no one seems to mind, and it's all about the data ultimately anyway. Maybe it's a regulatory thing? Regardless, it's nice to see.

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by duaneb on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:12PM (#9172624)
HealthKit is a glorified database. Would definitely like to see it open sourced, though.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by antris on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:42PM (#9172883)
Can you name an app that is not "a glorified database"? Seems to apply for almost anything. Hacker News, Facebook, Twitter and so on... It's all about putting in and getting data from a database
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by duaneb on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:53PM (#9173515)
> Can you name an app that is not "a glorified database"?

Apps, sure. Tools? Hell no. File processors, browsers, libraries.... But HealthKit adds virtually no value aside from the schema of health data. There's not much to be gained from opening it. Honestly, I'd argue the same about hacker news and reddit: it's great that reddit is open source, but it's hardly necessary for me to perform research on it because the semantics of loading/storing/existing are so well defined.

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by __david__ on Monday March 09, 2015 @06:59PM (#9174669)
HealthKit is not an app.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by mbreese on Monday March 09, 2015 @01:40PM (#9172383)
Plus, these are all academic partners - that code usually needs to be open source to publish.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by streptomycin on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:09PM (#9172599)
It's not "usually". More like "rarely". Papers without code are very common.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by dataker on Monday March 09, 2015 @04:40PM (#9173895)
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by epistasis on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:13PM (#9172640)
Why would that be unexpected? Apple does plenty of things open source, just not GPL.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by topkekz on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:34PM (#9172815)
>Apple does plenty of things open source

most of the time, it's broken or need closed source dependencies.

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by pionar on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:31PM (#9172791)
Apple usually only does things open source when it's required of them. I can't think of one piece of useful Apple open source software that's open.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by adamcw on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:39PM (#9172865)
I'd consider Webkit pretty useful.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by tonyarkles on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:47PM (#9172942)
clang too...
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by nkuttler on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:58PM (#9173079)
Webkit was derived from KHTML, which is LGPL.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by rsynnott on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:18PM (#9173232)
However, the bulk of modern Webkit is BSD 2.0, using LGPL libraries. Apple (and the other contributors) were under no obligation to contribute that bit.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by thetinguy on Monday March 09, 2015 @07:27PM (#9174830)
Don't say forget CUPS
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by teamhappy on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:47PM (#9172943)
WebKit has been open sourced 10 years ago. CUPS is even older than that. What has Apple been up to recently?

---

You know, you could name projects instead of clicking the upside-down arrow. Clang comes to mind (not LLVM). Google and others contribute heavily to clang, but Apple started it. They deserve credit for that. Anything else?

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by bwindels on Monday March 09, 2015 @09:43PM (#9175484)
Vikram Adve and Chris Lattner started LLVM at the University of Illinois in 2000. Only 5 years later, Apple got involved and hired Lattner.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by mirashii on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:52PM (#9173002)
Keep in mind when responding that Webkit, Clang/LLVM, and Cups are all not created by Apple, they're all preexisting projects or forks that essentially necessitated doing their work in the open.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by mrsteveman1 on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:36PM (#9173382)
Apple owns CUPS though, I highly suggest that you read the license terms[1] for it now:

License Exceptions

1. (a) Software that is developed by any person or entity for an Apple Operating System ("Apple OS-Developed Software"), including but not limited to Apple and third party printer drivers, filters, and backends for an Apple Operating System, that is linked to the CUPS imaging library or based on any sample filters or backends provided with CUPS shall not be considered to be a derivative work or collective work based on the CUPS program and is exempt from the mandatory source code release clauses of the GNU GPL.

[1] http://www.cups.org/documentation.php/doc-1.5/license.html

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by pikachu_is_cool on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:44PM (#9173452)
AFAIK Clang (not LLVM) was entirely created by Apple and could have been proprietary

Also the x86 Darwin kernel was made open source with no benefit to Apple, and winocm managed to port it to ARM too (although it's pretty debatable if it actually provides anything useful)

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by rsynnott on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:17PM (#9173226)
> they're all preexisting projects or forks that essentially necessitated doing their work in the open.

That's true of Cups and part of WebKit (most of the actual browser engine is BSD-licensed, but there are LGPL libraries used); however, Apple was certainly under no obligation to contribute its changes to LLVM back, or to contribute clang back _at all_.

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by Joky on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:13PM (#9173195)
Clang/LLVM is BSD, what do you mean by "necessitated doing their work in the open"?
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by pikachu_is_cool on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:46PM (#9173467)
He probably means that making it open source would benefit Apple moreso than if they kept it closed, not out of the goodness of their hearts
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by adamcw on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:05PM (#9173128)
Noted, but I'd argue that contributing to existing open source projects is better for the general populace than reinventing wheels.
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by sbuk on Monday March 09, 2015 @04:10PM (#9173640)
Why does that matter?
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by maccard on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:49PM (#9172959)
Clang/llvm
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by sbuk on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:49PM (#9172967)
CUPS
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by dguaraglia on Monday March 09, 2015 @09:16PM (#9175345)
Open Source in this case might not make much of a difference. If this is written in Swift and only runs under iOS, or if it ties with a certain Apple service that requires certificates issued by Apple it won't make much of a difference if you can read the full source code, even if it's released under an MIT or similarly open license.

As long as the data this gathers can't be used (or contributed to) by a third party, it's still a 100% Apple property, regardless of code availability.

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by mrsteveman1 on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:19PM (#9173239)
We'll see how this stuff actually works in practice pretty soon, but as this is more than just a chunk of code to run on a device, what exactly is going to be "open" here?

A formal standard that can be implemented and used by other platforms, both on the device and server side, would be great. But Apple's last promise to make something they developed "open" (iMessage as a standard) evaporated and has since been completely proprietary.

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by cududa on Tuesday March 10, 2015 @11:00AM (#9178046)
No, it was facetime they were going to make an open standard. And patent trolls killed that. So..
Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by return0 on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:58PM (#9173078)
Kind of a no-brainer if universities are going to be involved in building apps for it.

Wonder if they announced anything about external addon biosensors?

Re:ResearchKit: A software framework designed to benefit med... by taozhuo on Monday March 09, 2015 @04:12PM (#9173655)
iOS and Mac OS are closed systems with lots of open source components.