I suspect they chose SHA256 because it's the best hash, not because it advantages their hardware. But yeah, Niagara 2 is pretty smokin for crypto: http://blogs.sun.com/sprack/entry/ultrasparc_t2_crypto_perfo...
New Intel CPUs now have a CRC32 instruction, which I am hoping Sun engineers will take advantage of soon and add as a choice for ZFS.
VAX had a CRC instruction.
While it might seem flippant to compare VAX to x86, it was found (on VAX) that a programmer could potentially get better aggregate performance by avoiding that instruction; that having an instruction doesn't automatically mean that the code is faster.
CRC32? Compared to SHA256? Seriously?
I can't bring myself to trust dedupe without verification after every hash match, so I plan to use it with a fast hash algorithm with full verify enabled.
CRC32 is faster than ZFS's default of Fletcher2 and has less frequent collisions.
Many ZFS users already leave compression enabled which uses more CPU time than SHA256 and is still fast enough.
And, BTW, I am in no means implying this is bad. Quite the contrary - I would love to have an inexpensive SPARC-based desktop. If it existed.