News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by maxerickson on Monday March 09, 2015 @10:45AM (#9171165)
Is the Chevy Volt too pragmatic to be considered a competitor with pure EV?
Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by mikeash on Monday March 09, 2015 @10:59AM (#9171247)
It's certainly a competitor. Any car is a competitor to a pure EV, except to the irrelevantly small segment of the population who refuses to consider anything else.

Personally, I thought the Volt is pretty cool and seriously considered it when buying a new car about two years ago, but the lack of a middle seat in the back was a deal-killer for me. Similarly, I considered Ford's Energi plugins, and rejected them because they lacked cargo space. I ended up going with a Prius v, which is a decent car and has lots of room.

For EVs to be interesting, they need to get away from the model of building a compromised car that people buy because it's an EV. The batteries intrude into the cabin, the range is poor, they often look weird, etc. I don't think most people are buying a Volt because it's the best car for the money. They're buying it because they want an EV, and it's an OK car for the money.

A Model S, on the other hand, is just plain good. It's a nice car that just happens to be an EV. There's no, "This is a problem, but at least it's an EV." It's, "This is great, and can you believe it's an EV too?" The only "but" with the Model S is, of course, the tremendous price.

It's similar to hybrids. The original Honda Insight was extremely efficient, but compromised. The original Prius was similar. You bought them to save gas, and sacrificed for it. Fast-forward to 2013, and I bought a Prius v because it was the best car for my needs for the money, ignoring fuel efficiency. The fact that it got 40-50MPG was just a bonus. And that's why they're popular.

If Tesla can repeat the Model S experience with the Model 3 at a more reasonable price, I can't see anyone else matching it. That's a big "if" of course, but they at least have a shot. Are the other car makers going to build something that's just plain good, or are they going to continue building cars where being electric is the main reason to buy them?

Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by coryrc on Monday March 09, 2015 @11:03AM (#9171266)
It's small, uncomfortable, and expensive, as well as having poor mpg on gas. In about any calculation, a Corolla is a better deal.

The Leaf, on the other hand, is selling gobs of them for a good reason.

Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by ryanhuff on Monday March 09, 2015 @12:37PM (#9171939)
The Leaf sold better than the Volt in 2014, but I wouldn't say they are selling gobs of them. Also, the Volt had a new model on the horizon last year, so lets see how sales go with the new model.
Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by maxerickson on Monday March 09, 2015 @11:11AM (#9171304)
The Volt has an answer for long distance. The Leaf does not.
Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by mikeash on Monday March 09, 2015 @02:30PM (#9172780)
I think this is a nice summary of what I'm saying. You have two compromised EVs (or PHEVs) and you're arguing over which compromise is less bad. If they can't get beyond that stage then they're going to have trouble.
Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by maxerickson on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:30PM (#9173333)
I wasn't very clear about it, but I was thinking that they aren't necessarily so far behind strategically. Hybrids don't look so bad if there is no $25,000, 200+ mile range EV (with a good distance solution).
Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by mikeash on Monday March 09, 2015 @03:58PM (#9173558)
I agree, hybrids are probably your best bet if you're on a budget right now.

What it comes down to, for Tesla's future and the future of EVs, is whether the big car companies will be able to improve their EVs better or faster than Tesla can reduce the price of theirs. If Tesla could sell the Model S for the price of a Leaf, they'd sell like crazy. If Nissan could make the Leaf as good as a Model S, they'd sell like crazy. The question is, which end do the odds favor? I think Tesla has a better chance, partly because it's all they do, and partly because it just seems like their task is the easier one at this point.

Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by soperj on Monday March 09, 2015 @11:38AM (#9171484)
and yet one is selling well and the other is not.
Re:Tesla Cuts Jobs in China by maxerickson on Monday March 09, 2015 @11:44AM (#9171526)
I'm not trying to argue in favor of the Volt. The comment I initially responded to spoke about long range. I chose the Volt for comparison because it satisfies that requirement. In the comment you replied to, I was pointing out that the Leaf does not satisfy the requirement.