Re:On Secretly Terrible Engineers
by x0x0 on Sunday March 08, 2015 @04:34PM
(#9167120)
I asked someone with a PhD in statistics to, "Explain regression to me like I know some math but have never used statistics." For those of you who don't know, regression can be taught to people either with a single course in calculus or people with a single course in linear algebra. It is also a, maybe the, fundamental statistical tool. I'm generally satisfied with people drawing some points on a 2-variable graph, explaining we're trying to calculate the least error fit, then telling me what that the error specifically is squared error. If the candidate can discuss penalties and outliers and glms and exponential family distributions and IRLS and sampling distributions and gauss-markov then great, but I'm satisfied with a really basic understanding. This guy couldn't get any of it. I simply don't understand how you can have a phd in statistics and not be able to explain in 60 seconds roughly what regression is, how one interprets the betas, and at least one basic inference method.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
FWIW I've come across many PhDs (I've worked in PhD-rich environments for the last 15 years) who are surprisingly poor at fundamental level stuff in their field. They're so far beyond it and so specialized that they just don't really remember how the basic stuff works.