News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by frik on Sunday March 08, 2015 @09:28AM (#9165509)
There is a lack of free open source state of the art game engines. The best one are based on the open sourced Quake 3 engine and Cube2, though they are 10-15 years old. Additionally such an engines needs a good WYSIWYG editor with an inbuilt shader editor like UnrealEd, CryEngine-Editor. The Quake3/Source-Engine editors are very basic and outdated. Game engines are written in C++, with game logic in a scripting language like Lua or JavaScript.

There is also a lack of web 3D engines that ate not based on ThreeJS. Every demo and tutorial is using ThreeJS, instead of WebGL. ThreeJS is an abstraction layer that made sense some years ago when WebGL wasn't around. ThreeJS is slow. One can compile C++ code via emscripten to ams.js, that's great - the downside is the JS filesize.

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by et1337 on Sunday March 08, 2015 @11:16AM (#9165801)
Just this past year GoDot went open source. Haven't delved too deep into it, but it looks professional, scriptable, and "actually open source" (i.e. they accept pull requests)

https://github.com/okamstudio/godot

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by Moter8 on Sunday March 08, 2015 @03:54PM (#9166959)
>(i.e. they accept pull requests)

Well, Epic accept pull requests too for UE4, you know, but they are not actually open/libre/whatever source.

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by morbius on Sunday March 08, 2015 @05:14PM (#9167297)
The engine he linked to is MIT licensed.
Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by zabast on Sunday March 08, 2015 @10:15AM (#9165624)
You are right with the lack of open source state of the art engines, it is a shame.

But you are misinformed about the webgl part: There are other Web 3D engines. For example Babylon or CopperLicht. The latter even has a pretty solid WYSIWYG 3D editor: http://www.ambiera.com/coppercube/

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by maccard on Sunday March 08, 2015 @10:38AM (#9165696)
> There is a lack of free open source state of the art game engines. The best one are based on the open sourced Quake 3 engine and Cube2, though they are 10-15 years old.

And most modern commercial engines are just as old. Unreal has been around since 98, and I'm sure there's at least some of the original code in there. Source is based on the quake engines too, and runs on an ancient version of Havok that valve licensed years ago. Cry engine I'm not sure about, having never looked at it. Most of the modern call of duty games run a modified quake engine. The problem doesn't just exist in open source engines. the difference is Commerical in house engines tend to start with a stock unreal engine, and rip it apart piece by piece until they're left with the same editor/base libraries, but almost entirely custom engine code underneath.

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by frik on Sunday March 08, 2015 @04:12PM (#9167025)
It's all about continuous development and not how old an engine is. Unreal 4 is great in 2015, id Tech 3 with little development since 1999 feels like yesterday.

Unreal, ID Tech, CryEngine, etc. most modern game engines date back to the mid to late nineties. But where as e.g. the Unreal 4 engine has been in continuous development since 1995 and came originally with an editor coded in Visual Basic, one cannot compare the limited Unreal 1 of 1998 with Unreal 4 as of today. Sure many code lines are still unchanged and in Unreal 4 but especially the graphics and editor have changed a lot.

A modern Call of Duty (e.g. Ghosts) still use a heavily modified Heavy Metal F.A.K.K.² engine (Ritual's ÜberTools) which itself was a heavily modified id Tech 3 engine with the GtkRadiant editor. Infinity Ward added texture and map streaming in Modern Warfare 2. The id Tech 3 engine is now open source, but there is a big difference in the capabilities of what you can do with Infinity Ward Call of Duty engine and what you can do with id Tech 3 that has seen little development since then - also in the tool section.

GoldSource/Source/Source2(?) is one of the oldest engine still used in AAA games, based on Quake and Quake World. The Worldcraft/Hammer editor is dated in comparison to UnrealEd. Hammer editor for Source 2 engine seems to catch up.

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by dietrichepp on Sunday March 08, 2015 @09:58AM (#9165583)
Until recently, there was a lack of free / inexpensive state of the art game engines, even considering the proprietary ones. Making a game is already hard, like writing a novel. And writing a "state of the art" game engine is like writing a web browser in scope and complexity. The best I'm hoping for is a few good open source engines targeting specific niches, and some better middleware, along with a ton of open-source tools that make it fun and painless to make small games (like Haxe).

That said, I'm looking forward to see what people do with Unity 5, UE4, Source 2 in the upcoming Ludum Dare (April 17), even if I'll only be slogging along in C++ and OpenGL.

(It is sad about WebGL tutorials--you're tempting me to write up a "bare WebGL" tutorial.)

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by amarsahinovic on Sunday March 08, 2015 @11:49AM (#9165934)
Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by pjmlp on Sunday March 08, 2015 @09:56AM (#9165578)
> ThreeJS is an abstraction layer that made sense some years ago when WebGL wasn't around.

So how are you loading textures, geometry, fonts, shaders, matrix calculations?

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by BruceM on Sunday March 08, 2015 @10:20AM (#9165649)
There's https://github.com/SonyWWS/ATF for building an editor...
Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by daredevildave on Sunday March 08, 2015 @12:32PM (#9166095)
Try PlayCanvas [http://github.com/playcanvas/engine]

It's definitely state of the art. See our latest tech demo: http://seemore.playcanvas.com

Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by cwyers on Sunday March 08, 2015 @02:21PM (#9166524)
I don't think this is state of the art. It's impressive, maybe, from a technical point of view given the massive constraints it runs under. It may compete with Unity or, to a lesser extent, Unreal on the low end. But there's lots of things you can do in Unity (which isn't really state of the art -- it lags behind the AAA engines in a lot of respects, although I don't know how much Unity 5 moved the ball forward there. This isn't to denigrate PlayCanvas, but it's not an open-source replacement for Unreal in the most typical Unreal Engine use-cases.
Re:In the age of free AAA game engines, are we still relevant? by tomjen3 on Sunday March 08, 2015 @12:12PM (#9166031)
Unity is free. Yeah it isn't open source, but it is unlikely your game will be either - and if it does then just put the source on github and have your comitters download unity.