Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by ojbyrne on Sunday November 01, 2009 @09:08PM
(#915923)
Boo hoo. I golf, but the basic gist of this story is "tax payers used to subsidize high-end golf courses for executives, then those tax breaks were taken away, resulting in the growth of less-expensive golf courses that would actually appeal to the taxpayers who were previously subsidizing the wealthy members of the high-end courses."
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by mhb on Sunday November 01, 2009 @11:05PM
(#916094)
That's a curious way to look at it. Would you say that all the (infinite) taxes I am not paying in excess of what I am paying are a subsidy from the rest of you?
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by geebee on Sunday November 01, 2009 @11:42PM
(#916157)
Maybe. I'd be comfortable calling it a subsidy if it's a very specific break given to a narrow segment of the economy. So no I wouldn't call the infinite taxes you're not paying a "subsidy", but if you're paying lower taxes than I am because the government has chosen to tax me at a higher rate than you, I might call the difference a subsidy.
BTW, I'm not necessarily opposed to subsidies, there can be good reasons to do this.
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by codexon on Monday November 02, 2009 @12:25AM
(#916224)
Think about it this way. If everyone but me gets a 50% tax and I get a 0% tax, does this seem fair?
Assuming that the government provides some value to society, doesn't this seem like other people are paying their share to maintain the national infrastructure more than I am?
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by mhb on Monday November 02, 2009 @02:45AM
(#916396)
I understand the inequity you're pointing out. But calling this a subsidy suggests that there is some baseline that the government is justified in taking and that what we retain is a subsidy that is allowed us by the good grace of the government. Which is exactly backwards.
Your interpretation of what a subsidy is is also subject to the vagaries of where you choose to set the baseline for the funding to which the government is entitled. Is everything less than that a subsidy?
Also, in this case in particular, I'd guess that the people taking advantage of the tax break for golf club membership are above whatever baseline you would set.
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by codexon on Tuesday November 03, 2009 @03:33AM
(#918918)
If you interpret the government as providing no value to society whatsoever, then I could see your point.
However, if you believe the government does provide value, any baseline would equalize your income with everyone else in the population, thus not really decreasing the buying power of the money you earn.
The only part where this would not be the case is if the rulers kept most of the money to themselves (a monarchy) or to a select group (unfortunately happening with Goldman Sachs recently.).Then value of your money would truly be unfairly decreased.
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by travisjeffery on Sunday November 01, 2009 @10:25PM
(#916031)
Anyone that doesn't believe me or other people here on HN saying that HN is getting shittier (unrelated articles, quick unthoughtful comments and so on) each day can just take a look at this submission and these comments.
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by patio11 on Sunday November 01, 2009 @09:13PM
(#915935)
This is a truly fascinating financial look into a culture which is far, far more foreign to me than Japan ever was. (Granted, they golf here, too. I still don't get it. I mean, I know it is a networking tool and sort of like WoW for "grownups" but, much like "grownups" vis-a-vis WoW, I just can't feel in my bones how I would ever actually enjoy it.)
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by human_v2 on Sunday November 01, 2009 @09:22PM
(#915946)
Don't let anyone tell you otherwise: golf is about getting trashed and seeing if you can still manage to ever put the ball in the cup. While on a business outing, the object of the game is now to play WORSE than the exec you are there with. Golf is no longer a competition, but a social function. Turns out I don't enjoy social functions OR golf.
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by peterwwillis on Sunday November 01, 2009 @09:57PM
(#915994)
It is a social game, but i'm not sure how much it's not as social as basketball or any other sport really. Those who don't play for money or to win an executive over (redundant) play in order to hang out with their friends. The game itself has its own interesting skill to acquire, but I guess since it doesn't have an athletic component it's lost in the "shuffle" of old person games.
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by jrockway on Sunday November 01, 2009 @10:56PM
(#916082)
Maybe in movies. I played golf in high school, and not everyone is out there to get drunk. Many people enjoy the game because it's difficult and interesting. Executives, even...
Re:Golf courses across the nation are in crisis as membershi...
by ShabbyDoo on Sunday November 01, 2009 @09:59PM
(#915995)
>In Cleveland, two clubs facing declining memberships, Sand Ridge and Mayfield
Since the 60's, the Mayfield Country Club has offered curling -- I think I was told it's the only "dedicated" (not a hockey rink) curling ice in Ohio. I note this purely for amusement. And, yes, I curled there once (the only time I have ever curled).
BTW, I'm not necessarily opposed to subsidies, there can be good reasons to do this.
Everything you earn is taxable, except <long list of exceptions>.
Nothing is deductible, except <long list of exceptions>.
When you add to either of those lists of exceptions, you're increasing the overall tax rate for people who can't take advantage of those exceptions.
Assuming that the government provides some value to society, doesn't this seem like other people are paying their share to maintain the national infrastructure more than I am?
Is this not a subsidy?
Your interpretation of what a subsidy is is also subject to the vagaries of where you choose to set the baseline for the funding to which the government is entitled. Is everything less than that a subsidy?
Also, in this case in particular, I'd guess that the people taking advantage of the tax break for golf club membership are above whatever baseline you would set.
However, if you believe the government does provide value, any baseline would equalize your income with everyone else in the population, thus not really decreasing the buying power of the money you earn.
The only part where this would not be the case is if the rulers kept most of the money to themselves (a monarchy) or to a select group (unfortunately happening with Goldman Sachs recently.).Then value of your money would truly be unfairly decreased.
Still, I defer to George Carlin on my opinion about what we should do with golf courses: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7C7c-nZIyfc
Since the 60's, the Mayfield Country Club has offered curling -- I think I was told it's the only "dedicated" (not a hockey rink) curling ice in Ohio. I note this purely for amusement. And, yes, I curled there once (the only time I have ever curled).